Interview 2014 Transcripts and Experiences

sananthan

I think that strange 'freedom' vaali baat landed our anonymous benefactor in some trouble

Roaring_Jaguar

Constitution "does" permit reservation on the basis of gender. Otherwise, women reservation is state civil services and panchayats would have been nullified by Supreme Court. I think he made a mistake by saying that Constitution does not permit women reservation.
As of now, there is no provision for women reservation in central government jobs. As soon as the Central govt. passes a bill to introduce women reservations in central govt. jobs, they will get.

Roaring_Jaguar

I think that strange 'freedom' vaali baat landed our anonymous benefactor in some trouble

Yes, I agree. It was a too casual and hasty answer. Should have answered in a constructive way like better infra. facilities, professors, etc.

Roaring_Jaguar

I will maintain..
1. Caste based or social criteria of reservation should be abolished and a economic criteria should be implemented.
2. No reservation for women in civil services!

How will you identify only economic criteria for reservations. This may not be feasible. For ex, a person holding 50 acres of land can hide his property details and get reservation. Therefore, correct method should be to include social as well as economic criteria.

idealupsc

@Shkk n ur optional subject was . . .

Bhai when is your interview ??

22nd May. ~X(

Bhai if u keep on studying every transcripts until 22 then I'm sure u can perfectly anticipate and prepare each and every questions that will be asked for u and can score even 250+

DAF poora hojaye bas kaafi hai yar.
I think nobody has mentioned his/her hobby as singing, playing musical instruments. :P
I hope ppl who are to face the i/v later than mine show up here on this forum, I'd b happy to share my i/v experience with them also.

I have mentioned my hobby as 'singing, reading', God knows why! I have no idea about singing except singing in the bathroom. My interview is on 3rd June. Waiting for your transcript. :-SS

ZenBuddhist

Reservation : Ahem, There are my two cents :

1. If the govt. recognises that 'creamy layer' amongst OBC doesn't need the benefits of reservation, why isn't such a condition there for SC/ST? Also, it recognises the importance of economic backwardness in reservation so why isn't it also extended to economically weaker members of General Category students?

2. Our reservation policy is nonuniform and somewhat even irrational. It does have a value in the sense that it tries to do away historical unequalness, but basing it on caste only is wrong.

Interview answer would be on the lines that The policy itself has noble intentions but there are some issues with it namely economic 'creamy layer' criteria should be followed for SC/STs as well, so that the benefits reach the intended audience. Furthermore, reservation may only be allowed only at one level.

Women reservation : As probably the most exploited group(They are the second rate citizens even in the most exploited groups like tribals), there reservation makes sense. They also bring diverse experience and a different perspective to the table.

rookie

I will maintain..
1. Caste based or social criteria of reservation should be abolished and a economic criteria should be implemented.
2. No reservation for women in civil services!

How will you identify only economic criteria for reservations. This may not be feasible. For ex, a person holding 50 acres of land can hide his property details and get reservation. Therefore, correct method should be to include social as well as economic criteria.

come to Karnataka, I will get u SC/ST certificate wth 500/-
social criteria has outlived its utility..

rookie

Straight from orkut

PT on 16 Apr. Board: Alka Sirohi Mam.
Biodata: Pol Sci, Chem Engg, Patents, IRS IT, Reading etc
Duration~ 25 mins

Questions:
chairperson:politics in all about impossibles. Comment on this.
M:compulsory license
M:tax evasion (some cross questions)
M:ignorance of law cant be an excuse for violation of law. do u subscribe to this maxim. isnt it unjust at times?
M:commission stating that middle classes would expand 10 fold.
M:middle class role in economy and development (3-4 cross questions)
M:reading nonfiction, what do u read. Recently read books.
M:most favourite quote
M:excess nitrogen in agricultural land, why? hows nitrogent taken up by plants?
M:chemical engg questions related to urea uptake and how to control differentail rates (4-5 cross questions) pure chemical engineering.
M: three things that are not palatable about this election?
M:regulation and competition (some cross questions) but questions werent asked very clearly in a sense I didnt get what he was trying to ask despite me asking him to clarify the question. but finally it ended well too.
M:character and reputation. define. differentiate etc
chairperson:role of ability and character in success (some cross questions)

There were few more questions here and there which I forgot.

Sirohi Mam is an excellent interviewer. I liked her.

rookie

one more

Nidhi Dwivedi - 56 minutes ago
PT-17-04-14,forenoon session, Manbir Singh' board,duration 25 mins
background- B.tech (electronics and comm.) optional-geography, hobbies- visiting tourist places, singing, IPS
C- do u read newspaper,do u follow them closely
kashmir issue, difference between kashmir,junagadh and hyderabad issue(in detail)
M1(lady)- do u watch tv, role of ministry of info n broadcasting, prasar bharti, awareness drives etc.
M2- status of sports in India..what are d problems..what can be done..y cricket frenzy ..should v trying removing the attention from cricket etc etc
M3- visitor vs traveller...difference/similarity bw bhopal,lucknow, hyderabad..etc.
some general questions on industrial towns etc.
M4- cyber terrorism, electronic warfare bw india-pak...standard of editorials in papers, paid news
m5- What service were you allocated last year...
future wars on water-possible?...problems of water resources- distribution, problem of plenty etc.(in detail)
i might have missed some questions
interview was cool..very general.

Autobots

I will maintain..
1. Caste based or social criteria of reservation should be abolished and a economic criteria should be implemented.
2. No reservation for women in civil services!

How will you identify only economic criteria for reservations. This may not be feasible. For ex, a person holding 50 acres of land can hide his property details and get reservation. Therefore, correct method should be to include social as well as economic criteria.

person cannot hide their wealth in obc case.....have to fill detail form mentioning every property and if it exceeds certain limit...then u come under creamy layer and thus excluded from reservation......so that can be applied for SC/ST also.