INTERVIEW FOR CSE 2019
All ForumIAS members selected for CSE 2019 Personality Test must submit their details and DAF and register below to receive further instructions and guidance from ForumIAS. Click here to register now
INTERVIEW 2020 CHANNEL
ForumIAS Channel for Interview Preparation is now Active! Please join the channel by clicking here
We are hiring!

DISCUSSION: PHILOSOPHY MAINS 2016 PAPER 1 & 2

18911131437

Comments

  • 219
    Badiya the pichli bar yar kitne se reha
    Mere 234 the lekin essay aur interview ne wat laga thi

  • jain nay kya hai bhai ne idea is it saptbhangi nyaya agar yes to sala nay kyun likha upsc ne
  • jain nay kya hai bhai ne idea is it saptbhangi nyaya agar yes to sala nay kyun likha upsc ne
    Nay means aansink gyan aur uske 6 rup likh kar syadwad se compare karna tha ki wo purana darstikaun hai

  • can someone tell which theory of religious lang is more acceptable .. after giving all gyan i wrote in favour of wittgenstien and braithwhite non cognivist as most favourable
  • can someone tell which theory of religious lang is more acceptable .. after giving all gyan i wrote in favour of wittgenstien and braithwhite non cognivist as most favourable </blockquote
    Sahi hai bhai maine bhi yehi likha hai usme thoda carnep , haier ,antony flu, air baithwhite ka bhi dal kar bata diya bas ....


  • @yoga123
    actually Tattvartha is not very difficult.
    It is just summary of entire Jain Philosophy that we have read in coaching notes.
    Tattvartha Sutta of Umaswami Acharya is divided into 10 chapters
    Chapter 1-4 are on Jiva
    Chapter 5 is on Ajeeva
    Chapter 6,7,8,9 are on Ashrav, Bandh, Samvar and Nirjara
    Chapter 10 on Liberation/Kaivalya
    So these are the 7 Tatvas in this doctrine
    It is like that chart of coaching notes given under doctrine of dravya/anekantvad

    I like Hegel very much, one of Vivan's answer was alsp very helpful in understanding Hegel.
    After Donald Trump's election I was wondering that if Democracy/Egalitarianism/inclusion is the highest Idea in polity, then why should Trump win on a divisive campaign.
    Here I found a very interesting Hegelian view.
    Hegel says that Idea can even provoke a contradiction which might appear against the Idea itself.
    But Idea does this so as to accelerate its own development
    For example, had there been no world wars, growth towards peace would have been very slow.
    Similarly, it was only after Trump won that electorate which was sleeping on election day woke up and started protesting. Now they will not forget to vote next time. So democracy will deepen because of Trump.
    So Hegel's theory is like ''chit bhi meri pat bhi meri'' :smiley:





    The issue is how would ppl know the term tattvartha itself. :/
  • can someone tell which theory of religious lang is more acceptable .. after giving all gyan i wrote in favour of wittgenstien and braithwhite non cognivist as most favourable
    i also supported non cognivists view....coz the objects of religion like God,soul etc cannot be experienced...hence they can neither be proved or disproved like scientific facts
  • can someone tell which theory of religious lang is more acceptable .. after giving all gyan i wrote in favour of wittgenstien and braithwhite non cognivist as most favourable
    i also supported non cognivists view....coz the objects of religion like God,soul etc cannot be experienced...hence they can neither be proved or disproved like scientific facts
    How about Analogical argument? seems like a fair religion + non-religion reconciliation?
  • can someone tell which theory of religious lang is more acceptable .. after giving all gyan i wrote in favour of wittgenstien and braithwhite non cognivist as most favourable
    i also supported non cognivists view....coz the objects of religion like God,soul etc cannot be experienced...hence they can neither be proved or disproved like scientific facts
    How about Analogical argument? seems like a fair religion + non-religion reconciliation?
    I believe any of the views are correct from exam point of view if justified properly...I didn't opted for RS as analogy coz it has two problems-it limits God by anthropomorphizing him and it also leads to ascription of negative attributes of humans to God.
  • bhai wo satre ka nothingness kya hai?
    I think it's about consciousness is constituted of "nothingness". From this he explains existence precedes essence, atheism, freedom and responsibility, abandonment, despair, anguish, and finally bad faith/inauthentic existence.
    bhai maine bhi vaise hi link lagayi hai.. dekhate hai..

    and wo NAY concept kya thi?
    Chawark bhai how many no you expected


    210-220, wbu??
Sign In or Join to comment.

Welcome!

We are a secret self-moderated community for Civil Services preparation. Feel free to join, start a discussion, answer a question or just to say Thank you.

Just dont spread the word ;)

Sign in or join with Facebook or Google