INTERVIEW FOR CSE 2019
All ForumIAS members selected for CSE 2019 Personality Test must submit their details and DAF and register below to receive further instructions and guidance from ForumIAS. Click here to register now
INTERVIEW 2020 CHANNEL
ForumIAS Channel for Interview Preparation is now Active! Please join the channel by clicking here
We are hiring!

civil service prelims 2016 discussion on controversial questions

13468912

Comments

  • Regarding the CS, Governor question. Lets get one thing right. What UPSC decides is final. The UPSC has already decided in IES 2006 paper that the answer to this question is (d) Neither 1 nor 2. Yes, this question is a straight forward repeat from IES 2006 General Studies Paper. This is the link:

    http://examrobot.com/searchvie...[0]=field_question_year:2006.

    Remember the President vs Supreme Court controversy regarding the custodian of constitution last year in prelims?? In that one also there was a question in 2005 or so in one of the UPSC conducted exams in which a few statements were given and the option containing the correct set of statements was to be marked. The correct answer in that did not contain that statement in the question which says "The President is the custodian of the Constitution". Thats it.

    UPSC's views and interpretations matter. They have already been expressed before.
    i dont think UPSC used to release official answer keys in that era (correct me if wrong)..the answer must have been the interpretation of the website..
  • Regarding the CS, Governor question. Lets get one thing right. What UPSC decides is final. The UPSC has already decided in IES 2006 paper that the answer to this question is (d) Neither 1 nor 2. Yes, this question is a straight forward repeat from IES 2006 General Studies Paper. This is the link:

    http://examrobot.com/searchvie...[0]=field_question_year:2006.

    Remember the President vs Supreme Court controversy regarding the custodian of constitution last year in prelims?? In that one also there was a question in 2005 or so in one of the UPSC conducted exams in which a few statements were given and the option containing the correct set of statements was to be marked. The correct answer in that did not contain that statement in the question which says "The President is the custodian of the Constitution". Thats it.

    UPSC's views and interpretations matter. They have already been expressed before.
    i dont think UPSC used to release official answer keys in that era (correct me if wrong)..the answer must have been the interpretation of the website..
    I cant say anything about that...May be..
  • My cut off practically depends on few questions - Millets, TEEB, Sustainable Development Goals (apparently Club of Rome didn't spell out the goals), and Capital accounts wala. I'm swinging between 106 and 114. Hope it works out
    Millets - 1 and 2 only; SDG - only 2; TEEB - 2 and 3 only; Capital budget you mean - All.
  • Yes. Got it. Thanks.

    Pls throw light on drip irrigation and salinity link.
    For Drip irrigation,it reduces weed and soil erosion
    https://ucanr.edu/repositoryfiles/ca4904p19-69973.pdf
    Please See the headline-
    'Drip irrigation controls Soil salinity under row crops.'
    So ,Reduction in weed & Reduction in soil salinity is definitely correct.
  • My cut off practically depends on few questions - Millets, TEEB, Sustainable Development Goals (apparently Club of Rome didn't spell out the goals), and Capital accounts wala. I'm swinging between 106 and 114. Hope it works out
    Millets - 1 and 2 only; SDG - only 2; TEEB - 2 and 3 only; Capital budget you mean - All.
    I guess, that puts me at 114. Should be safe
  • http://pib.nic.in/newsite/PrintRelease.aspx?relid=139028.

    Public Sector is also issuing Masala Bonds..
    Both vajiram and Sriram have taken both as correct.... As per them answer is C.

  • oh no this thread :|
  • Regarding the CS, Governor question. Lets get one thing right. What UPSC decides is final. The UPSC has already decided in IES 2006 paper that the answer to this question is (d) Neither 1 nor 2. Yes, this question is a straight forward repeat from IES 2006 General Studies Paper. This is the link:

    http://examrobot.com/searchvie...[0]=field_question_year:2006.

    Remember the President vs Supreme Court controversy regarding the custodian of constitution last year in prelims?? In that one also there was a question in 2005 or so in one of the UPSC conducted exams in which a few statements were given and the option containing the correct set of statements was to be marked. The correct answer in that did not contain that statement in the question which says "The President is the custodian of the Constitution". Thats it.

    UPSC's views and interpretations matter. They have already been expressed before.
    i dont think UPSC used to release official answer keys in that era (correct me if wrong)..the answer must have been the interpretation of the website..
    Regarding the CS, Governor question. Lets get one thing right. What UPSC decides is final. The UPSC has already decided in IES 2006 paper that the answer to this question is (d) Neither 1 nor 2. Yes, this question is a straight forward repeat from IES 2006 General Studies Paper. This is the link:

    http://examrobot.com/searchvie...[0]=field_question_year:2006.

    Remember the President vs Supreme Court controversy regarding the custodian of constitution last year in prelims?? In that one also there was a question in 2005 or so in one of the UPSC conducted exams in which a few statements were given and the option containing the correct set of statements was to be marked. The correct answer in that did not contain that statement in the question which says "The President is the custodian of the Constitution". Thats it.

    UPSC's views and interpretations matter. They have already been expressed before.
    i dont think UPSC used to release official answer keys in that era (correct me if wrong)..the answer must have been the interpretation of the website..
    Sahi pakde hain...


  • Secondly in UNCCD mein, there is special/particular focus on North Africa and South Asia. I strongly feel this shud be right. But I am not able to find exact words in Google. Can somebody help here
    They don't have special focus on North America and South Asia. They have identified certain zones and areas which are rapidly undergoing desertification, and those are spread around Europe, Americas and Africa and Asia. True, Sahel in Africa is one of the largest, and possibly more could be in South Asia, but there is no dedicated focus



    see some links here for UNFCCD....in the year 2006, it organized international year of deserts and desertification. it was reported in the media that desertification is particularly problematic in sub saharan Africa and south asia

    https://www.alrc.tottori-u.ac.jp/japanese/iydd/index.html
    http://www.cepal.org/cgi-bin/getProd.asp?xml=/prensa/noticias/comunicados/7/25617/P25617.xml&xsl=/prensa/tpl-i/p6f.xsl&base=/prensa/tpl-i/top-bottom.xsl

    I can still be wrong. only upsc knows...
  • @steelalmirah

    Have a look at this site:
    http://www.agriinfo.in/default.aspx?page=topic&superid=8&topicid=2243

    In the advantages of drip irrigation it says:
    2. No water being available to weeds.
    7. No soil erosion.

    and it mentions that "salinity hazards" is a disadvantage.

    There is some explanation in Wikipedia:

    The main purpose of drip irrigation is to reduce the water consumption by reducing the leaching factor. However, when the available water is of high salinity or alkalinity, the field soil becomes gradually unsuitable for cultivation due to high salinity or poor infiltration of the soil. Thus drip irrigation converts fields in to fallow lands when natural leaching by rain water is not adequate in semi arid and arid regions.

    Not questioning the answer.
    It is reduced weeds, and reduced soil erosion.

    Want to understand how it controls soil erosion?

    I thought that drip irrigation = no water logging = less salinity. But that is wrong.

    And I couldn't figure how it will help in soil erosion? An explanation from someone, thank you.
    https://ucanr.edu/repositoryfiles/ca4904p19-69973.pdf
    Please See the headline-
    'Drip irrigation controls Soil salinity under row crops.'
    So ,Reduction in weed & Reduction in soil salinity is definitely correct.
    Also, please go through this link.
    http://www.omafra.gov.on.ca/english/engineer/facts/12-053.htm
    It says that soil erosion refers to the wearing away of a field's topsoil by the natural physical forces of water and wind or through forces associated with farming activities such as tillage. These forces will anyways be there(in case of flood water or speedy winds etc) whether drip irrigation or any other form of irrigation is being practiced. So, preventing soil erosion does not seem to be a very promising option.
    This is my inference of the links , please correct me if I am wrong. :smile:
Sign In or Join to comment.

Welcome!

We are a secret self-moderated community for Civil Services preparation. Feel free to join, start a discussion, answer a question or just to say Thank you.

Just dont spread the word ;)

Sign in or join with Facebook or Google