CSM 2017 Ethics Answer Writing and Learning Together Here

Catman

Ethics gs4 mains paper Discussion :

My approach to road accident issue.


1. Human life >> all other priorities (whether of relative or stranger)

2. Golden hour best hour to save road victim

3. Being Good Samaritan = legal and ethical duty


Now my course=

1. Attend immidiately. Give all possible first aid. Call for help. Police/ambulance/ppl around.

2. If ambulance late.ask for help take auto/car. Make it to hospital asap.

3. Ensure the victims reach hospital = my first and ONLY priority at that time.

4. Call police / relatives. Give ur details to police/explain briefly. Now ask to go for upsc. Take number of police/hospital.


5. Reach upsc.

6. Tell them problem. If mentally stable plus time of day left reschedule request for same day. Otherwise next day onwards.

7. If they agree ok. Or approach higher authorities. Make call to hospital / police for veracity check.

Now assumed two scenerio

1. They agree it is done.

2. They dont - i go court. Here two scenario :-

2.1 i get my due.
2.2 i don't get.


Finally assumed worst case -
I lose my career - so whatttt ! Saved two precious lives ! >> ALREADY BECAME A PUBLIC SERVANT , IAS I WILL TRY AGAIN AND BECOME LATER ALSO !

I followed exactly the same steps till point 7. I didn't write about going to the courts. But that is a good point.

Rajadhiraja_ASB

Ethics gs4 mains paper Discussion :

My approach to road accident issue.


1. Human life >> all other priorities (whether of relative or stranger)

2. Golden hour best hour to save road victim

3. Being Good Samaritan = legal and ethical duty


Now my course=

1. Attend immidiately. Give all possible first aid. Call for help. Police/ambulance/ppl around.

2. If ambulance late.ask for help take auto/car. Make it to hospital asap.

3. Ensure the victims reach hospital = my first and ONLY priority at that time.

4. Call police / relatives. Give ur details to police/explain briefly. Now ask to go for upsc. Take number of police/hospital.


5. Reach upsc.

6. Tell them problem. If mentally stable plus time of day left reschedule request for same day. Otherwise next day onwards.

7. If they agree ok. Or approach higher authorities. Make call to hospital / police for veracity check.

Now assumed two scenerio

1. They agree it is done.

2. They dont - i go court. Here two scenario :-

2.1 i get my due.
2.2 i don't get.


Finally assumed worst case -
I lose my career - so whatttt ! Saved two precious lives ! >> ALREADY BECAME A PUBLIC SERVANT , IAS I WILL TRY AGAIN AND BECOME LATER ALSO !

Aapki answer dekhe ke lagta hai is baar aap phir 130 laoge ethics me.....waise i also wrote on same line except court wala....

Catman

In accident related, factory worker death:
1) Assure the workers a separate enquiry with their representation.

2) Identify if the death occurred due to his being in a drunken state or would have occurred even if he wasn't drunk. If latter, compensate him fully.

3) Even if death due to drunken state of worker, give some compensation to the family depending upon economic condition.

4) Work on strengthening safety and raising awareness about rules so that these don't happen again.

ashoka1234

@catman my answer is on same lines
hr's duty towards workers and company

Yo_Yo_Choti_Singh

My approach on Builder case study -

Intro - recent incidences.. and raising of legal and ethical concerns by this etc

Body - apart from Natural reasons like EQ etc mainly events transforming into disaster is due to double side failures -

(Made a table here)

Legal failures || Ethical lapses

Then subdivided it in 2 parts

1. On the part of builder

2. On the part of State/admins


Wrote 3 4 5 points in each portion like

(Corruption CANCER

Moral fiber degradation

Monetary concerns subduing conscience and morality


Lack of respect for human lives ..means >>ends

public servant forgetting both PUBLIC and SERVICE SPIRIT

etc etc)


Suggestions:

Legal - less focused

Use of ICT for vulnerability and hazard mapping

Transparency /Public participation /RWA watchdog committees / Anonymous complaints system etc stuff


-Already legal things mostly there but problem is implementation and more importantly Ethical lapses.

Here quoted ARC 2 - Rule of Law only checks perversity of Mind not heart - Rule of Ethics needed here.

Gave 4 5 points on Rule of Ethics part.


concluded in ethical tone.





PS- Not sure whether this much focus on ethics will be appreciated or not!

MINDGAME

Ethics gs4 mains paper Discussion :

My approach to road accident issue.


1. Human life >> all other priorities (whether of relative or stranger)

2. Golden hour best hour to save road victim

3. Being Good Samaritan = legal and ethical duty


Now my course=

1. Attend immidiately. Give all possible first aid. Call for help. Police/ambulance/ppl around.

2. If ambulance late.ask for help take auto/car. Make it to hospital asap.

3. Ensure the victims reach hospital = my first and ONLY priority at that time.

4. Call police / relatives. Give ur details to police/explain briefly. Now ask to go for upsc. Take number of police/hospital.


5. Reach upsc.

6. Tell them problem. If mentally stable plus time of day left reschedule request for same day. Otherwise next day onwards.

7. If they agree ok. Or approach higher authorities. Make call to hospital / police for veracity check.

Now assumed two scenerio

1. They agree it is done.

2. They dont - i go court. Here two scenario :-

2.1 i get my due.
2.2 i don't get.


Finally assumed worst case -
I lose my career - so whatttt ! Saved two precious lives ! >> ALREADY BECAME A PUBLIC SERVANT , IAS I WILL TRY AGAIN AND BECOME LATER ALSO !

Try again next year s a good point.

Diablo

@Yo_Yo_Choti_Singh sir vo wala batayein PIO wale mein kya likhe aap

Gowdru

My approach on Builder case study -

Intro - recent incidences.. and raising of legal and ethical concerns by this etc

Body - apart from Natural reasons like EQ etc mainly events transforming into disaster is due to double side failures -

(Made a table here)

Legal failures || Ethical lapses

Then subdivided it in 2 parts

1. On the part of builder

2. On the part of State/admins


Wrote 3 4 5 points in each portion like

(Corruption CANCER

Moral fiber degradation

Monetary concerns subduing conscience and morality


Lack of respect for human lives ..means >>ends

public servant forgetting both PUBLIC and SERVICE SPIRIT

etc etc)


Suggestions:

Legal - less focused

Use of ICT for vulnerability and hazard mapping

Transparency /Public participation /RWA watchdog committees / Anonymous complaints system etc stuff


-Already legal things mostly there but problem is implementation and more importantly Ethical lapses.

Here quoted ARC 2 - Rule of Law only checks perversity of Mind not heart - Rule of Ethics needed here.

Gave 4 5 points on Rule of Ethics part.


concluded in ethical tone.





PS- Not sure whether this much focus on ethics will be appreciated or not!

Even my approach was on similar lines but ended with giving representation to ministry of personnel and Pmo and also use of Twitter to consider my case on compassionate grounds...

Diablo

@Yo_Yo_Choti_Singh sir ??

Yo_Yo_Choti_Singh

@Yo_Yo_Choti_Singh sir vo wala batayein PIO wale mein kya likhe aap

Go by RTI Act provisions and spirit. Don't be judgemental. Law is complete and foolproof. Bss isi theme pe likhna tha