INTERVIEW FOR CSE 2019
All ForumIAS members selected for CSE 2019 Personality Test must submit their details and DAF and register below to receive further instructions and guidance from ForumIAS. Click here to register now
INTERVIEW 2020 CHANNEL
ForumIAS Channel for Interview Preparation is now Active! Please join the channel by clicking here
We are hiring!

UPSC PRELIMS 2017 Question Paper Discussion

1374375377379380792

Comments

  • https://books.google.co.in/books?id=oAo1X2eagywC&pg=PA189&lpg=PA189&dq=secretary+of+state+british+india+1927&source=bl&ots=-yI9y2dRY9&sig=GZk9GXu2K3M6IYLXXM0877sjEIY&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwizz97i2s7UAhVIuI8KHUMtCdkQ6AEIPzAF#v=onepage&q=secretary of state british india 1927&f=false


    Look at this one regarding Butler committee. It says the princely states should be transferred to British India and NOT to an Indian Government or (Government of India) as mentioned in the ALL the keys as well.

    Butler Committee report answer is NOT Indian states and Government of India.

    I think it's time to throw away spectrum and pick up Pearson General studies.
    At that time Government of India meant the Government of British India only. GoI Act 1919/1935 were not named as GoBI Acts.
    No other choices of the question is even close for Butler report.
    British India and Government of India are NOT the same. The source is CLEARLY stating that the states are NOT to be under any Indian Government that will be formed (Which is Government of India). It gives power to the Viceroy of India as the person responsible for states representing the crown. The option which states defining the power of secretary of state for India is the closest.
    yeh aya launda .....ek number bhaiii ...kahan se lae itna tagda zeher
    Ohhh Teri.... -2.66 humbly accepted!
    Harcourt Butler Committee A three -member committee headed by Harcourt Butler, appointed on December 16, 1927 to examine the relations between the native states and the paramount power, declined to define what paramountcy was but clearly and fortrightly stated that “paramountcy must remain paramount”. The committee fully endorsed that the viceroy, not the governor general should remain the Crown agent in dealing with the native states. In fact the right to protect includes right to internal intervention. Paramountcy is the supreme sovereign power which was kept above the reach of law and interpretation, to be exercised at the appropriate time subject to resiraints of morality and constitutional propriety against an erring ruler of a native statewhen other correctional means had proved to be futile. It is a concept developed into a deterrent in the political relation between the British and the Indian rulers
    http://www.gktoday.in/quiz-questions/with-reference-to-the-relations-of-the-princely-states-with-british-crown-which-among-the-following-report-said-that-paramountcy-must-remain-paramount/

    this shows it intend to define the jurisdiction of the Central and Provincial Governments

    Bhai Harcourt Butler mere college ka sansthapak h baat karta hu usse



  • Ye lo ek aur ... Padmapni paintings in Bagh also... http://www.cpreecenvis.nic.in/Database/BaghCaves_2897.aspx
    Bhai i think in saare cases m upsc best possible answr card khelegi...
    Motipalli more popular than masuli,
    Chandipur more popular than bhavngr,
    Ajanta one more popular than bagh..

    Ye sb deliberately kia hai upsc ne..wrna itne close options dene ka point nai tha..
  • edited June 2017
    https://books.google.co.in/books?id=oAo1X2eagywC&pg=PA189&lpg=PA189&dq=secretary+of+state+british+india+1927&source=bl&ots=-yI9y2dRY9&sig=GZk9GXu2K3M6IYLXXM0877sjEIY&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwizz97i2s7UAhVIuI8KHUMtCdkQ6AEIPzAF#v=onepage&q=secretary of state british india 1927&f=false


    Look at this one regarding Butler committee. It says the princely states should be transferred to British India and NOT to an Indian Government or (Government of India) as mentioned in the ALL the keys as well.

    Butler Committee report answer is NOT Indian states and Government of India.

    I think it's time to throw away spectrum and pick up Pearson General studies.
    At that time Government of India meant the Government of British India only. GoI Act 1919/1935 were not named as GoBI Acts.
    No other choices of the question is even close for Butler report.
    British India and Government of India are NOT the same. The source is CLEARLY stating that the states are NOT to be under any Indian Government that will be formed (Which is Government of India). It gives power to the Viceroy of India as the person responsible for states representing the crown. The option which states defining the power of secretary of state for India is the closest.
    yeh aya launda .....ek number bhaiii ...kahan se lae itna tagda zeher
    Ohhh Teri.... -2.66 humbly accepted!
    Harcourt Butler Committee A three -member committee headed by Harcourt Butler, appointed on December 16, 1927 to examine the relations between the native states and the paramount power, declined to define what paramountcy was but clearly and fortrightly stated that “paramountcy must remain paramount”. The committee fully endorsed that the viceroy, not the governor general should remain the Crown agent in dealing with the native states. In fact the right to protect includes right to internal intervention. Paramountcy is the supreme sovereign power which was kept above the reach of law and interpretation, to be exercised at the appropriate time subject to resiraints of morality and constitutional propriety against an erring ruler of a native statewhen other correctional means had proved to be futile. It is a concept developed into a deterrent in the political relation between the British and the Indian rulers
    http://www.gktoday.in/quiz-questions/with-reference-to-the-relations-of-the-princely-states-with-british-crown-which-among-the-following-report-said-that-paramountcy-must-remain-paramount/

    this shows it intend to define the jurisdiction of the Central and Provincial Governments





    Censorship of press option hi bacha hai ab.
  • https://books.google.co.in/books?id=oAo1X2eagywC&pg=PA189&lpg=PA189&dq=secretary+of+state+british+india+1927&source=bl&ots=-yI9y2dRY9&sig=GZk9GXu2K3M6IYLXXM0877sjEIY&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwizz97i2s7UAhVIuI8KHUMtCdkQ6AEIPzAF#v=onepage&q=secretary of state british india 1927&f=false


    Look at this one regarding Butler committee. It says the princely states should be transferred to British India and NOT to an Indian Government or (Government of India) as mentioned in the ALL the keys as well.

    Butler Committee report answer is NOT Indian states and Government of India.

    I think it's time to throw away spectrum and pick up Pearson General studies.
    At that time Government of India meant the Government of British India only. GoI Act 1919/1935 were not named as GoBI Acts.
    No other choices of the question is even close for Butler report.
    British India and Government of India are NOT the same. The source is CLEARLY stating that the states are NOT to be under any Indian Government that will be formed (Which is Government of India). It gives power to the Viceroy of India as the person responsible for states representing the crown. The option which states defining the power of secretary of state for India is the closest.
    yeh aya launda .....ek number bhaiii ...kahan se lae itna tagda zeher
    Ohhh Teri.... -2.66 humbly accepted!
    Harcourt Butler Committee A three -member committee headed by Harcourt Butler, appointed on December 16, 1927 to examine the relations between the native states and the paramount power, declined to define what paramountcy was but clearly and fortrightly stated that “paramountcy must remain paramount”. The committee fully endorsed that the viceroy, not the governor general should remain the Crown agent in dealing with the native states. In fact the right to protect includes right to internal intervention. Paramountcy is the supreme sovereign power which was kept above the reach of law and interpretation, to be exercised at the appropriate time subject to resiraints of morality and constitutional propriety against an erring ruler of a native statewhen other correctional means had proved to be futile. It is a concept developed into a deterrent in the political relation between the British and the Indian rulers
    http://www.gktoday.in/quiz-questions/with-reference-to-the-relations-of-the-princely-states-with-british-crown-which-among-the-following-report-said-that-paramountcy-must-remain-paramount/

    this shows it intend to define the jurisdiction of the Central and Provincial Governments

    Bhai Harcourt Butler mere college ka sansthapak h baat karta hu usse



    Actually unka poora naam bhi Sir Spencer Harcourt Butler tha , yeh question hi galat h Poora naam likhna tha unka ...yeh bhi doubt mein aa gaya ab..theek h
  • https://books.google.co.in/books?id=oAo1X2eagywC&pg=PA189&lpg=PA189&dq=secretary+of+state+british+india+1927&source=bl&ots=-yI9y2dRY9&sig=GZk9GXu2K3M6IYLXXM0877sjEIY&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwizz97i2s7UAhVIuI8KHUMtCdkQ6AEIPzAF#v=onepage&q=secretary of state british india 1927&f=false


    Look at this one regarding Butler committee. It says the princely states should be transferred to British India and NOT to an Indian Government or (Government of India) as mentioned in the ALL the keys as well.

    Butler Committee report answer is NOT Indian states and Government of India.

    I think it's time to throw away spectrum and pick up Pearson General studies.
    At that time Government of India meant the Government of British India only. GoI Act 1919/1935 were not named as GoBI Acts.
    No other choices of the question is even close for Butler report.
    British India and Government of India are NOT the same. The source is CLEARLY stating that the states are NOT to be under any Indian Government that will be formed (Which is Government of India). It gives power to the Viceroy of India as the person responsible for states representing the crown. The option which states defining the power of secretary of state for India is the closest.
    yeh aya launda .....ek number bhaiii ...kahan se lae itna tagda zeher
    Ohhh Teri.... -2.66 humbly accepted!
    Harcourt Butler Committee A three -member committee headed by Harcourt Butler, appointed on December 16, 1927 to examine the relations between the native states and the paramount power, declined to define what paramountcy was but clearly and fortrightly stated that “paramountcy must remain paramount”. The committee fully endorsed that the viceroy, not the governor general should remain the Crown agent in dealing with the native states. In fact the right to protect includes right to internal intervention. Paramountcy is the supreme sovereign power which was kept above the reach of law and interpretation, to be exercised at the appropriate time subject to resiraints of morality and constitutional propriety against an erring ruler of a native statewhen other correctional means had proved to be futile. It is a concept developed into a deterrent in the political relation between the British and the Indian rulers
    http://www.gktoday.in/quiz-questions/with-reference-to-the-relations-of-the-princely-states-with-british-crown-which-among-the-following-report-said-that-paramountcy-must-remain-paramount/

    this shows it intend to define the jurisdiction of the Central and Provincial Governments





    Baal Ki Khaal Mat Nikaalo. D is correct

    The Committee was formed to inquire into the relationship between the Indian states and the paramount power and to suggest ways and means for more satisfactory adjustments of the existing relations between them and British India

  • https://books.google.co.in/books?id=oAo1X2eagywC&pg=PA189&lpg=PA189&dq=secretary+of+state+british+india+1927&source=bl&ots=-yI9y2dRY9&sig=GZk9GXu2K3M6IYLXXM0877sjEIY&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwizz97i2s7UAhVIuI8KHUMtCdkQ6AEIPzAF#v=onepage&q=secretary of state british india 1927&f=false


    Look at this one regarding Butler committee. It says the princely states should be transferred to British India and NOT to an Indian Government or (Government of India) as mentioned in the ALL the keys as well.

    Butler Committee report answer is NOT Indian states and Government of India.

    I think it's time to throw away spectrum and pick up Pearson General studies.
    At that time Government of India meant the Government of British India only. GoI Act 1919/1935 were not named as GoBI Acts.
    No other choices of the question is even close for Butler report.
    British India and Government of India are NOT the same. The source is CLEARLY stating that the states are NOT to be under any Indian Government that will be formed (Which is Government of India). It gives power to the Viceroy of India as the person responsible for states representing the crown. The option which states defining the power of secretary of state for India is the closest.
    yeh aya launda .....ek number bhaiii ...kahan se lae itna tagda zeher
    Ohhh Teri.... -2.66 humbly accepted!
    Harcourt Butler Committee A three -member committee headed by Harcourt Butler, appointed on December 16, 1927 to examine the relations between the native states and the paramount power, declined to define what paramountcy was but clearly and fortrightly stated that “paramountcy must remain paramount”. The committee fully endorsed that the viceroy, not the governor general should remain the Crown agent in dealing with the native states. In fact the right to protect includes right to internal intervention. Paramountcy is the supreme sovereign power which was kept above the reach of law and interpretation, to be exercised at the appropriate time subject to resiraints of morality and constitutional propriety against an erring ruler of a native statewhen other correctional means had proved to be futile. It is a concept developed into a deterrent in the political relation between the British and the Indian rulers
    http://www.gktoday.in/quiz-questions/with-reference-to-the-relations-of-the-princely-states-with-british-crown-which-among-the-following-report-said-that-paramountcy-must-remain-paramount/

    this shows it intend to define the jurisdiction of the Central and Provincial Governments





    Baal Ki Khaal Mat Nikaalo. D is correct

    The Committee was formed to inquire into the relationship between the Indian states and the paramount power and to suggest ways and means for more satisfactory adjustments of the existing relations between them and British India

    Yeh sab man ko behlane ke bahane h ....
  • https://books.google.co.in/books?id=oAo1X2eagywC&pg=PA189&lpg=PA189&dq=secretary+of+state+british+india+1927&source=bl&ots=-yI9y2dRY9&sig=GZk9GXu2K3M6IYLXXM0877sjEIY&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwizz97i2s7UAhVIuI8KHUMtCdkQ6AEIPzAF#v=onepage&q=secretary of state british india 1927&f=false


    Look at this one regarding Butler committee. It says the princely states should be transferred to British India and NOT to an Indian Government or (Government of India) as mentioned in the ALL the keys as well.

    Butler Committee report answer is NOT Indian states and Government of India.

    I think it's time to throw away spectrum and pick up Pearson General studies.
    At that time Government of India meant the Government of British India only. GoI Act 1919/1935 were not named as GoBI Acts.
    No other choices of the question is even close for Butler report.
    British India and Government of India are NOT the same. The source is CLEARLY stating that the states are NOT to be under any Indian Government that will be formed (Which is Government of India). It gives power to the Viceroy of India as the person responsible for states representing the crown. The option which states defining the power of secretary of state for India is the closest.
    yeh aya launda .....ek number bhaiii ...kahan se lae itna tagda zeher
    Ohhh Teri.... -2.66 humbly accepted!
    Harcourt Butler Committee A three -member committee headed by Harcourt Butler, appointed on December 16, 1927 to examine the relations between the native states and the paramount power, declined to define what paramountcy was but clearly and fortrightly stated that “paramountcy must remain paramount”. The committee fully endorsed that the viceroy, not the governor general should remain the Crown agent in dealing with the native states. In fact the right to protect includes right to internal intervention. Paramountcy is the supreme sovereign power which was kept above the reach of law and interpretation, to be exercised at the appropriate time subject to resiraints of morality and constitutional propriety against an erring ruler of a native statewhen other correctional means had proved to be futile. It is a concept developed into a deterrent in the political relation between the British and the Indian rulers
    http://www.gktoday.in/quiz-questions/with-reference-to-the-relations-of-the-princely-states-with-british-crown-which-among-the-following-report-said-that-paramountcy-must-remain-paramount/

    this shows it intend to define the jurisdiction of the Central and Provincial Governments





    I'm trying very hard to see, where it shows that :O :O
    Do you understand what does provincial government means?
  • Harcourt Butler naam se Kanpur ( Uttar Pradesh) mein ek bahut Reputed Engineering College bhi hai na?
  • Ye lo ek aur ... Padmapni paintings in Bagh also... http://www.cpreecenvis.nic.in/Database/BaghCaves_2897.aspx
    Bhai i think in saare cases m upsc best possible answr card khelegi...
    Motipalli more popular than masuli,
    Chandipur more popular than bhavngr,
    Ajanta one more popular than bagh..

    Ye sb deliberately kia hai upsc ne..wrna itne close options dene ka point nai tha..
    Bagh option should not have been given. Confuse Kar Diya un logo ko jinko dono ka knowledge thaa
  • Harcourt Butler naam se Kanpur ( Uttar Pradesh) mein ek bahut Reputed Engineering College bhi hai na?
    engineering aur agriculture college hey shayad..
This discussion has been closed.

Welcome!

We are a secret self-moderated community for Civil Services preparation. Feel free to join, start a discussion, answer a question or just to say Thank you.

Just dont spread the word ;)

Sign in or join with Facebook or Google