INTERVIEW FOR CSE 2019
All ForumIAS members selected for CSE 2019 Personality Test must submit their details and DAF and register below to receive further instructions and guidance from ForumIAS. Click here to register now
INTERVIEW 2020 CHANNEL
ForumIAS Channel for Interview Preparation is now Active! Please join the channel by clicking here
We are hiring!

'Rights' Movement : CSE-2015' [Final Draft] - Start Sending

1151618202161

Comments

  • edited October 2015
    @failure guide
    let's stop fighting govt,even in our wild imagination,even as all-powerful bureaucracy is swiftly responding to our concerns.
  • I think the most potent argument for increasing the age limit or giving extra attempts as compensation or woman issue is not on the humanitarian ground ( It would been better if we call it an issue of human rights violation) but its on the ground of justice. Denying candidates ample opportunity to prepare for an exam and and declaring them failure is destroying their dignity and proving them inferior to those who are successful. Its like awarding death sentence to the intellectual inside a human being. Its making him/her weak for his entire life at least in the social life around.

    Since its a case of human rights violation I would suggest to send the petitions to the NHRC as well.

    Please reply and do not simply overlook. @gks @geeta @all
    Thank you mister for this powerful and original comment.
  • @Failure'sGuide

    I don't think it would be feasible and would add any extra value to the cause
  • legal corse is futile..even CAT delhi reffered d case to DOPT. dont fight wid govt,just request.
  • Let the administration also put cut off limits for marriage and having kids also until unless one can boast of membership in any affirmative action schemes. General category people should not marry if they are above the age of 30. In exceptional cases marriage can be done but in no case a general category person should have children above the age of 30...

    To many of you, this would sound rubbish and funny. Only to a very few of you this would sound downright offensive.. And only those who are offended by the above will understand the logic and essence of my gratuitous proposal and the intellectual morass of fixing a upper age limit to civil services.
  • @Failure'sGuide

    I don't think it would be feasible and would add any extra value to the cause
    legal corse is futile..even CAT delhi reffered d case to DOPT. dont fight wid govt,just request.
    Feasibility and practicability is another issue and in no way should be ignored. But first comment on the truth, relevance and significance of the argument to the cause. if it is true, relevant and very significant we must not ignore this for the sake of feasibility. @gks

    Its not a legal approach, I think. Human rights violation adds very important dimension to our argument if its true. @Battle_begins2015

  • sab kahne ki baat hai...finally its upto govt of d day.period.
  • feasibility in terms OF US DEMANDING for it and feasibility in terms of THEM ACCEPTING it

    and not in REAL LIFE
  • @failure guide
    let's stop fighting govt,even in our wild imagination,even as all-powerful bureaucracy is swiftly responding to our concerns.</blockquote

    Its not fighting the government. its just highlighting something very important which is conspicuous by its absence in the present discourse.
  • Since it has come to this point let me ask a troubling question.

    How many of you(who get extra attempt in 2016) would be 100 percent confident of getting IAS in 2016 as their last attempt?

    One out of ten may get IAS. Then what about the remaining 9. And if you name exists in that 9 people, would you not like to have another chance to show your fighting spirit ?

    You will definitely want to.

    A Rising tide lifts all boats. The meaning of this saying translates to, Request our honourable government to increase general category age limit.

    Nah, I got my attempt in 2016 na..why should I care?......If you feel like this, then also no problem. You will still have roti, kapada, makaan. But in a few years, OC CATEGORY WILL BECOME THE NEW MINORITY..Nothing bad in being labelled as a minority, you would say?

    Then no force on earth can save you.

This discussion has been closed.

Welcome!

We are a secret self-moderated community for Civil Services preparation. Feel free to join, start a discussion, answer a question or just to say Thank you.

Just dont spread the word ;)

Sign in or join with Facebook or Google