INTERVIEW FOR CSE 2019
All ForumIAS members selected for CSE 2019 Personality Test must submit their details and DAF and register below to receive further instructions and guidance from ForumIAS. Click here to register now
INTERVIEW 2020 CHANNEL
ForumIAS Channel for Interview Preparation is now Active! Please join the channel by clicking here
We are hiring!

IAS or IPS ?

1679111223

Comments

  • ek mera frnd hai...pehle IRPS tha..ab IRS hai..abhi tak uska behaviour bilkul waise hi hain jaise selection se pehle tha..no change at all..

    ek doosre frnd hai..wo bhi IRS ..par wo change ho gaya...diwali me message karta hai official wala...happy diwali to u and ur family ...xyz (IRS, Govt of India )...is mssg ke baad maine use block kar diya wats app pe...

    Haha, correct. Half of them derive self importance by conversing in poorly drafted sarkari speak. Kaisi kaisi gandagi bhar gayi system me!
    haha...kya karein...ek dum to kam zindagani..usme se kam jawani..par log samajhte hi nahi
    Log ek doosre Jo imitate hi kar rahe hote mostly. Yahi institutional memory hai!
    there was a lady on forum who had given several attempts and in her attempt that year she appeared in interview as well...she was quite optimistic about a top rank ( as many are ), and hence her optimism led her to prepare herself for media interviews even before result was declared

    for instance, she started saying on forum " i belong to such family where girls are not even allowed to born " etc etc ...wahi ghisa pita struggle and success story..the rags to riches one which every successful person tends to claim in public as if rest of the population does nt face any strugggle


    unfortunately she did not make it to the list
    Yar aisa nahi hain.Mahilwao ki choti moti upladhiyo ko v humare desh m bada chada ke bataya jata.As if they are not supposed to do anything. Like when my neighbours son qualified for bank po,his parents were not very happy but when daughter got some placements they thrown party :joy:
    Nari shakti award,all women railway stations.i mean y the hell is this .a working woman or a woman achiever is not doing any favour to society she has simply learned to prioritise herself and has understood her responsobilty towards familys economy.

    Now this mindset is being imprinted in woman who strives for success so she begins such jargon. :smile:
  • ek mera frnd hai...pehle IRPS tha..ab IRS hai..abhi tak uska behaviour bilkul waise hi hain jaise selection se pehle tha..no change at all..

    ek doosre frnd hai..wo bhi IRS ..par wo change ho gaya...diwali me message karta hai official wala...happy diwali to u and ur family ...xyz (IRS, Govt of India )...is mssg ke baad maine use block kar diya wats app pe...

    Haha, correct. Half of them derive self importance by conversing in poorly drafted sarkari speak. Kaisi kaisi gandagi bhar gayi system me!
    haha...kya karein...ek dum to kam zindagani..usme se kam jawani..par log samajhte hi nahi
    Log ek doosre Jo imitate hi kar rahe hote mostly. Yahi institutional memory hai!
    there was a lady on forum who had given several attempts and in her attempt that year she appeared in interview as well...she was quite optimistic about a top rank ( as many are ), and hence her optimism led her to prepare herself for media interviews even before result was declared

    for instance, she started saying on forum " i belong to such family where girls are not even allowed to born " etc etc ...wahi ghisa pita struggle and success story..the rags to riches one which every successful person tends to claim in public as if rest of the population does nt face any strugggle


    unfortunately she did not make it to the list
    Who are such arrogant persons on forum, who take pride that they have given interview(s)..?? :astonished:
    many are... appearing in mains..appearing in interview ..add to the achievement profile n hence arrogance of such people.


    Mention them Sir, I'd be beware of them. :neutral:
    not just on forum..in real life as well..this is a general tendency...
    Sir what do you think of them, who mention their interviews and ranks in their signatures..?? :astonished:
    i think u better know why they write so in their signatures :trollface:
    Are Sir aap bolo na..I'm new here. :)
  • edited June 2018
    ek mera frnd hai...pehle IRPS tha..ab IRS hai..abhi tak uska behaviour bilkul waise hi hain jaise selection se pehle tha..no change at all..

    ek doosre frnd hai..wo bhi IRS ..par wo change ho gaya...diwali me message karta hai official wala...happy diwali to u and ur family ...xyz (IRS, Govt of India )...is mssg ke baad maine use block kar diya wats app pe...

    Haha, correct. Half of them derive self importance by conversing in poorly drafted sarkari speak. Kaisi kaisi gandagi bhar gayi system me!
    haha...kya karein...ek dum to kam zindagani..usme se kam jawani..par log samajhte hi nahi
    Log ek doosre Jo imitate hi kar rahe hote mostly. Yahi institutional memory hai!
    there was a lady on forum who had given several attempts and in her attempt that year she appeared in interview as well...she was quite optimistic about a top rank ( as many are ), and hence her optimism led her to prepare herself for media interviews even before result was declared

    for instance, she started saying on forum " i belong to such family where girls are not even allowed to born " etc etc ...wahi ghisa pita struggle and success story..the rags to riches one which every successful person tends to claim in public as if rest of the population does nt face any strugggle


    unfortunately she did not make it to the list
    Who are such arrogant persons on forum, who take pride that they have given interview(s)..?? :astonished:
    many are... appearing in mains..appearing in interview ..add to the achievement profile n hence arrogance of such people.


    Mention them Sir, I'd be beware of them. :neutral:
    not just on forum..in real life as well..this is a general tendency...
    Sir what do you think of them, who mention their interviews and ranks in their signatures..?? :astonished:
    i think u better know why they write so in their signatures :trollface:
    Are Sir aap bolo na..I'm new here. :)
    the psychology behind it is " though i am on forum..but don't treat me as ur equal..i am superior to most of u ..i m special"

    and another factors is the basic instinct one, hope u get it it :smiley:
  • Jo IRS IRPS etc jaise service me select hote hai with rank in late 200s 300s 400s 500s etc wo forum pe khul ke bat karte hain

    par jo early 200s 100s ya within 100 rank le aate hain..matlab IAS IPS post mil jata hai..wo forum pe baat cheet kam karte hain..wo bhi reserved type

    kuchh marks ka difference and hence of rank insaan me kitna ghamand bhar deta hai...

    ek nandini hai forum pe..mujhe to uske nature pe suru se hi shaq tha ki ye fake hai..jab se select huyi hai..forum pe comment karna chhod diya hai usne

    ghamand se upar uthna insaan k liye behad mushkil hai...wo to bas wait karta hai ki kab ghamand karne ka mauka mile...aur fir kahenge ' i want to serve the society "
    It's not like that , Sachin is a good friend of mine , and he is very helpful atleast till now he is fine , of course he gets so many requests so it's tough to answer all of them ,

    Waise IRS bhi kaffi he under 200 and early 200 me he and they are also very helpful, so I guess it's more about the person than about the ranks etc. , Atleast that's what I believe

    Also another factor may be is that someone who is working as an ips or ias will get less time to interact comapred to someone with IRS or say iaas, but again that's when one entres the service
  • ek mera frnd hai...pehle IRPS tha..ab IRS hai..abhi tak uska behaviour bilkul waise hi hain jaise selection se pehle tha..no change at all..

    ek doosre frnd hai..wo bhi IRS ..par wo change ho gaya...diwali me message karta hai official wala...happy diwali to u and ur family ...xyz (IRS, Govt of India )...is mssg ke baad maine use block kar diya wats app pe...

    Haha, correct. Half of them derive self importance by conversing in poorly drafted sarkari speak. Kaisi kaisi gandagi bhar gayi system me!
    haha...kya karein...ek dum to kam zindagani..usme se kam jawani..par log samajhte hi nahi
    Log ek doosre Jo imitate hi kar rahe hote mostly. Yahi institutional memory hai!
    there was a lady on forum who had given several attempts and in her attempt that year she appeared in interview as well...she was quite optimistic about a top rank ( as many are ), and hence her optimism led her to prepare herself for media interviews even before result was declared

    for instance, she started saying on forum " i belong to such family where girls are not even allowed to born " etc etc ...wahi ghisa pita struggle and success story..the rags to riches one which every successful person tends to claim in public as if rest of the population does nt face any strugggle


    unfortunately she did not make it to the list
    Who are such arrogant persons on forum, who take pride that they have given interview(s)..?? :astonished:
    many are... appearing in mains..appearing in interview ..add to the achievement profile n hence arrogance of such people.


    Mention them Sir, I'd be beware of them. :neutral:
    not just on forum..in real life as well..this is a general tendency...
    Sir what do you think of them, who mention their interviews and ranks in their signatures..?? :astonished:
    i think u better know why they write so in their signatures :trollface:
    Are Sir aap bolo na..I'm new here. :)
    the psychology behind it is " though i am on forum..but don't treat me as ur equal..i am superior to most of u ..i m special"

    and another factors is the basic instinct one, hope u get it it :smiley:
    Got it Sir. :D
  • Jo IRS IRPS etc jaise service me select hote hai with rank in late 200s 300s 400s 500s etc wo forum pe khul ke bat karte hain

    par jo early 200s 100s ya within 100 rank le aate hain..matlab IAS IPS post mil jata hai..wo forum pe baat cheet kam karte hain..wo bhi reserved type

    kuchh marks ka difference and hence of rank insaan me kitna ghamand bhar deta hai...

    ek nandini hai forum pe..mujhe to uske nature pe suru se hi shaq tha ki ye fake hai..jab se select huyi hai..forum pe comment karna chhod diya hai usne

    ghamand se upar uthna insaan k liye behad mushkil hai...wo to bas wait karta hai ki kab ghamand karne ka mauka mile...aur fir kahenge ' i want to serve the society "
    It's not like that , Sachin is a good friend of mine , and he is very helpful atleast till now he is fine , of course he gets so many requests so it's tough to answer all of them ,

    Waise IRS bhi kaffi he under 200 and early 200 me he and they are also very helpful, so I guess it's more about the person than about the ranks etc. , Atleast that's what I believe

    Also another factor may be is that someone who is working as an ips or ias will get less time to interact comapred to someone with IRS or say iaas, but again that's when one entres the service
    main to selection k just baad ki baat kar raha..even before training starts....of course exceptions do exist..and dats v nice of them..but m speaking of d majority of such people
  • What about ifs? I want to work and travel in different countries and make some money(not much, though) for my family needs. After retirement, I would like to settle in foreign. Is ifs the right job for it?

    Moreover, My objective of preparing for UPSC is not any public service or make india great again. It's just pure self-interest and desire to have a good standard of living. Should I fill ifs the top priority in daf?
    Ifs is a great service for me it's above ias , as it has certain things which can never be provided to me by ias , yes ifs is the right service for ur own interests , and trust me after interacting with many fellow selected candidates I have realized very few come for public service they are here for that other thing, like someone has said about ias , this is the mindset of most , or else public service u can do in other services as well , infact u don't need a service for public service, every service has something different offer unfortunately we generally ignore the work aspect of the service and go for what's outside

    You are in a good path , atleast u have clarity on what you want and what you don't want
    India needs more IRS officers like you. Kindly don't appear for upsc again. This is a personal request. Say no to IFS. :p
    :# :#
    I believe that is a yes. :D
    No man I am not appearing any more as I said in a post , I am pretty sure I will not last here for more than 10-15 years , so why to fight again in this rat race, I will be able to achieve what I wanted to achieve even through irs , I have lost the enthusiasm for any particular service as I had realised that its just a means and it can never be the end , I need to upgrade myself and learn all the time and can never be stagnant, and for that it's just a means

    (Lamba hogya Gyan :# :# )
    Nahi Sir. Yahi to sunna tha. :#

    And I'm not sure aap tik nahi sakte. Decide it when the time comes. The nation needs honest officers like you. :)
    Thanks for your kind words Bhai and please no sir , yeah sir ka culture ne barbad Kar Diya he apne system ko , :p we are all humans after all and should be that only post toh secondary he :)kahin bhi jaao ek kaam he Kar lenge , hum bhi desh Seva Karte he :#
  • What about ifs? I want to work and travel in different countries and make some money(not much, though) for my family needs. After retirement, I would like to settle in foreign. Is ifs the right job for it?

    Moreover, My objective of preparing for UPSC is not any public service or make india great again. It's just pure self-interest and desire to have a good standard of living. Should I fill ifs the top priority in daf?
    Ifs is a great service for me it's above ias , as it has certain things which can never be provided to me by ias , yes ifs is the right service for ur own interests , and trust me after interacting with many fellow selected candidates I have realized very few come for public service they are here for that other thing, like someone has said about ias , this is the mindset of most , or else public service u can do in other services as well , infact u don't need a service for public service, every service has something different offer unfortunately we generally ignore the work aspect of the service and go for what's outside

    You are in a good path , atleast u have clarity on what you want and what you don't want
    India needs more IRS officers like you. Kindly don't appear for upsc again. This is a personal request. Say no to IFS. :p
    :# :#
    I believe that is a yes. :D
    No man I am not appearing any more as I said in a post , I am pretty sure I will not last here for more than 10-15 years , so why to fight again in this rat race, I will be able to achieve what I wanted to achieve even through irs , I have lost the enthusiasm for any particular service as I had realised that its just a means and it can never be the end , I need to upgrade myself and learn all the time and can never be stagnant, and for that it's just a means

    (Lamba hogya Gyan :# :# )
    Nahi Sir. Yahi to sunna tha. :#

    And I'm not sure aap tik nahi sakte. Decide it when the time comes. The nation needs honest officers like you. :)
    Thanks for your kind words Bhai and please no sir , yeah sir ka culture ne barbad Kar Diya he apne system ko , :p we are all humans after all and should be that only post toh secondary he :)kahin bhi jaao ek kaam he Kar lenge , hum bhi desh Seva Karte he :#
    Okay BugsBunny. :#
  • Jina is back to form..
  • -being an IAS you will only report to IAS exclusively , all other services including IPS will bow down before you/your batchmates, if you choose/get other service you will have to serve an IAS officer
    -ips is on duty 24x7 (even when gone to senior level post ) IAS dont
    -political master knows only IAS
    -IAS lobby is the strongest and most powerfull collectivelly in india, you will feel proud to be part of it
    -all department including police,revenue are dominated by an IAS officer as its boss
    -not saying that IPS or any other service is good or bad , it depends on your intrest ; but IAS is hands down the best service in India be it in any form or view you take it . so if you have a chance choose IAS or else you may regret later.. do considerable amount of research ask serving officer if you must (there are people who choose others and now regret)
    -to begin with UPSC notification do offer clue about IAS when it says it is above all (it does mean that)
    -do not question the numero uno status of IAS from filing the UPSC form (or if not filling) till your death (or after) it was/is/and will remain no 1 service in govt job



    Please tell me, why are IAS officers killed .. like DK Ravi, Ashish Tiwari etc .. supposedly by mafia-politico nexus .. and nothing was done about it. Sincere question .. not meant to offend.

    But such questions make me doubt 'power' of IAS .. recently there was news .. some IPS was named in suicide note by an IAS officer of constant harassment which led entire family is the IAS officer, wife, 2 children to commit suicide ..

    Again, this is a sincere question? Are IAS officers really powerful .. I'm inclined to think IPS officers are more powerful, in line with that said by @BijuDada
Sign In or Join to comment.

Welcome!

We are a secret self-moderated community for Civil Services preparation. Feel free to join, start a discussion, answer a question or just to say Thank you.

Just dont spread the word ;)

Sign in or join with Facebook or Google