INTERVIEW FOR CSE 2019
All ForumIAS members selected for CSE 2019 Personality Test must submit their details and DAF and register below to receive further instructions and guidance from ForumIAS. Click here to register now
INTERVIEW 2020 CHANNEL
ForumIAS Channel for Interview Preparation is now Active! Please join the channel by clicking here
We are hiring!

Prelims 2017 Answer Key - All Sets + Share & Submit Scores to Estimmate Cut Off

1266267269271272352

Comments

  • @Burger the question 2 years back on real GDP growth also featured STEADILY INCREASED terms....in ur argument u r saying that in a decade a fall 1 or 2 times doesn't matter....but see the data which I have attached...there is a fall in GDP only twice but according to ur argument GDP is STEADILY INCREASING but UPSC in the given key did not consider it STEADILY INCREASING....similar argument will apply to the Tax to GDP question ......
  • I have a doubt: if right to vote is only a legal right why there was a need to amend the constitution through 61st amendment for reducing the age of voting? It could have done though the change in the statute only.
    I have a doubt: if right to vote is only a legal right why there was a need to amend the constitution through 61st amendment for reducing the age of voting? It could have done though the change in the statute only.
    All these things r discussed ....no final answer...leave it for upsc
  • @Burger the question 2 years back on real GDP growth also featured STEADILY INCREASED terms....in ur argument u r saying that in a decade a fall 1 or 2 times doesn't matter....but see the data which I have attached...there is a fall in GDP only twice but according to ur argument GDP is STEADILY INCREASING but UPSC in the given key did not consider it STEADILY INCREASING....similar argument will apply to the Tax to GDP question ......
    real gdp growth poochi hai, question to padh lo pehle
  • Saala easy questions galat(silly mistakes) karna bohot bhaari padgaya is baar. Ab ye doubtful questions ka sahaara lena pad raha hai.
    Last year 126 se seedhe 102.66 pe agaya.
    Ek bat batao.. 2016 ka agar paper na hota to 102.66 pe tum tension lete??.??
    Paper toh tough tha no doubt, but logo ke tukke lag jaate hain har saal. Mere last year thode lag gaye the but is baar bilkul ulta pad gaya almost saare. 5-6 questions kam sone ki wajah se galat hogaye, baaki doubtful waale nikal gaye.
    Vaise yaha kuch log inflated scores bataate hain, especially the first timers. Aur kuch log saare doubtful ko sahi maan kar total bataate hain.
    I still feel Shankar/Vaji etc ke keys se easily +-8 hosakta hai, so there's some hope.
  • Nobody seems to discuss the DPSPs constitute limitation.... question. They do pose constraint, at least moral, and "it 'shall' be the duty of the state to follow these principles both in the matter of administration as well as in the making of laws." -DD Basu. Attached are the relevant portions of the book
    Just relax. Its 100% correct. it does limit state's power.
  • @focus @Kejriwal

    If this s answer y no institute supporting this ?????? I too put same option a ... :p
    Mrunal kar to rha hai support, mrunal se upar kaun hai economy mein?
    M hu B) ...ignore kar diye mera graph
    Ignore nhi kiya, mrunal ne diya to hai same graph, uski conclusion padh li ab baar baar kya explain karun
    Isme kya explaination ho sakti h?? Wahi steady wali...m dekha nahi bata de
    Ruk waise main thoda aur research kar rha hun , tere graph par aata hu thodi der mein
    Check here
    Tax-GDP ka D jisne sahi mana hai wo apne marks dobara calculate kar le :mrgreen:
    Bhai hamne bhi revenue GDP ko sahi maara hai but it's wrong according to every key and it's not my expertise either. How are you saying ki sahi ho sakta ? Do you have some government data regarding that ?




    http://www.oecd.org/tax/increasing-tax-revenues-is-crucial-to-development-in-emerging-asian-economies.htm


    Here man.
    Read para 4 in above passage and see the word "steadily" used for Indonesia by OECD.



    https://tradingeconomics.com/indonesia/tax-revenue-percent-of-gdp-wb-data.html

    In this above mentioned link look for Indonesia's graph. No way close to linear in a decade.

    And tax revenue = tax collected.

    This gives me 90% hope of a being correct (q44 in set d )
    Bhai where is the data of finance department or some authority on it ? how are you saying the deviation is slight and that too only once ? steady is not the issue

    Bro kejri posted
    @focus @Kejriwal



    Dude this is what was needed. 100% A hoga. Yahoooooo

    Graph ke Footnote me dekho this is also an OECD report.

    Now read para 4 here.



    http://www.oecd.org/tax/increasing-tax-revenues-is-crucial-to-development-in-emerging-asian-economies.htm
    Economy me 10 years period is medium to long term. Ek sal ka fall doesnt make a difference, 9 sal baki lagatar badh rha hai. It is steady increase.

    Exactly. OECD did same for Indonesia Malaysia and Philippines.
    Sure beyond doubt
    hahah yeh wala question maine dekh liya, dhyan se padh yaar isko, real gdp ki growth rate likhe hai question mein , it acutally decreased during the decade, to wo statement waise hi wrong hua, us question aur is waale mein bahot antar hai :mrgreen:
    Kejriwal bhai real gdp growth also slowed only for brief period for 2 years and that to due to faulty base year.
    But in the above mentioned case too tax to gdp declined for 2012 13.
  • edited June 2017
    Saala easy questions galat(silly mistakes) karna bohot bhaari padgaya is baar. Ab ye doubtful questions ka sahaara lena pad raha hai.
    Last year 126 se seedhe 102.66 pe agaya.
    Ek bat batao.. 2016 ka agar paper na hota to 102.66 pe tum tension lete??.??
    Paper toh tough tha no doubt, but logo ke tukke lag jaate hain har saal. Mere last year thode lag gaye the but is baar bilkul ulta pad gaya almost saare. 5-6 questions kam sone ki wajah se galat hogaye, baaki doubtful waale nikal gaye.
    Vaise yaha kuch log inflated scores bataate hain, especially the first timers. Aur kuch log saare doubtful ko sahi maan kar total bataate hain.
    I still feel Shankar/Vaji etc ke keys se easily +-8 hosakta hai, so there's some hope.
    Dear friend... kuchh logoke tukke lag jate hai.. par ye mat bhule ki upsc ko 6.5k log lene hai..(general category) aur jab options aise design kiye ho ki tum galat answer ji taraf jao tab 6.5k logoke tukke sahi lagana bohot diffiçult hai
  • @Burger the question 2 years back on real GDP growth also featured STEADILY INCREASED terms....in ur argument u r saying that in a decade a fall 1 or 2 times doesn't matter....but see the data which I have attached...there is a fall in GDP only twice but according to ur argument GDP is STEADILY INCREASING but UPSC in the given key did not consider it STEADILY INCREASING....similar argument will apply to the Tax to GDP question ......
    real gdp growth poochi hai, question to padh lo pehle
    Steadily ka matlab withiut hiccups hota hai
  • i have marked 1 only in the revenue GDP question and counting it as wrong. But i have a genuine query. Do they expect us to ratto all such facts and figures ? like one can be aware of the broader trends but how come we ratto all those deviations ? and most importantly it said it has steadily increased in the last year. isn't 'in the last decade' and 'throughout the decade different things' ?
    P.S.- Wont argue just for the sake of doing it but really want to convince myself ki its incorrect only.
This discussion has been closed.

Welcome!

We are a secret self-moderated community for Civil Services preparation. Feel free to join, start a discussion, answer a question or just to say Thank you.

Just dont spread the word ;)

Sign in or join with Facebook or Google