INTERVIEW FOR CSE 2019
All ForumIAS members selected for CSE 2019 Personality Test must submit their details and DAF and register below to receive further instructions and guidance from ForumIAS. Click here to register now
INTERVIEW 2020 CHANNEL
ForumIAS Channel for Interview Preparation is now Active! Please join the channel by clicking here
We are hiring!

The 2015 Intolerance Debate

1246745

Comments

  • bhai kaunsi hindu bashing ho gai? pk dikh raha hain itna? oh my god nahi dikhi thi kya? pk movie mein shivji jo bana tha wo bhi ek hindu tha. writer bhi hindu tha. director bhi. bhai kab tak yehi sab sochoge. yehi sab tumhrare msgs aur baaki jo fb pe aaj kal dikhte hai inko dekh k hi amir khan ka support kiya
    intellectual bhai jaan agar aap sahi se padha ho to maine kaha hai..ki agar koi just imagine mohammad ko PK main SHIVA ki jageh dikha deta to kiya hota.......

    yesterday ...on tv channel TARIQ FATEH said if allah or mohammad would have shown in PK amir would not have been alive to tell us that his wife was thinking of leaving india.

    bhai jaha tak Amir ke support ki baat hai to sahi logo ko chuno colonel Mahadik jaise jinke bachho ko unki maa fauji banana chahati hai unko UNHE nahi jinhone khaya ajj tak hindustan ka aur jara se newspaper se darr ke bhagna chahete hai..
    jo itne darrpok ho unhe tumhare kiya khud bhagwan bhi nahi bacha sakte

    POINT 1 ,2 PARR BHI APNI RAI JAROOR DE
    ..N THIS IS JUST DISCUSSION DON`T DECLARE ME INTOLERANT OUTRIGHTLY...

    soch ki jaha tak baat hai wo to unse puchho jo rooj hamare jawan shaheed karr rahe hai...

    jo keval isliye dusro ko marr dete hai ki app kafir hai.........

    hum log to bass ink phek karr hi intolerant ho jate hai........

    by the way guru teg bahdur ji ki 24 november ko death anniversary thi....aurangzeb ke chahane wale agar intolerance ko koi example agar dekhana chate hai to pata chale ki auranzeb ne kui bharat maa ke bete ko mara tha


    bhai "bharat mata ka beta"?? I guess nand lal boss and others draw bhart mata painting at the time of bengal partitions or ye concept prior 19th century nh tha... even 1857 me b nobody used it. However mother earth is in our cultute since vedic times but sikhs never used it and u mean mughals/ musilms (those who born in indian subcontinent ) were outisders and silkhs nd others were INDIAN in todays terms.
    Can u really find nationality in medivial india. acc to ur concept sikkim shouldnt b the part of our nationality since it joined india very late.
    Here what is the problem, medivial characteristics should be the part of history only. Vo aj ka waqt nh tha dost we cnt set examples on the basis of that. Otherwise we had countious ladai jhagda patterns in the past. Chalukya burned the beautiful cities of pallavs (that too include temples, quila, settlement ) pallav did the same. Chaula did very NOTORIOUS thing in srilanka. Shashank shaiv king cut the bodhi vraks/three. Gaud raja burned the nalanada univ earlier then khilji.
    Main yaha hindu attacks vs muslim attacks nh mention kar rha hu. Mera matlab h uss jamane me aisa hi hota tha .BHARAT MATA K SHER BETE RAJPOOT vijaydashmi ki puja j bad bagal vale rajya pe chadai kar dete the. Iska matlab ye to nh ki aisa aj ka b RAJPPOT karta ho.waqt waqt ki baat h.

    YES there is no diff when it comes to bjp and congress. Vote k liye ye log kuch b kar sakte h farak ye h ki bjp vale saffron chola pahan lete h m congres vale chhupe bhediye h (remember muzzfarpur danga congress did nothing being in center).
    Rest ye logic ki koi apni baat islye nh kahe kyki pahle aur bure waqt me nh ki toh ye logic sarasar galat h..."
    ..pahle kyku nh pizza khya jab jyada bhuk thu aj kyun kha rehe ho jab kam bhuk h" ye aisa hi logic h.
    Aur ye logic to darawana h ki desh ka apman h intolerant kahna ye vahi baat h jo congress k time congress sarkar ko corrupt kahne pe kahti thi. Bhai agar koi doctor kahe city polluted h that does not mean city is bad.

    Yes u m even nt am admi party ajkal kuch b kaho paty ka tagg log laga dete h
  • Switzerland banned burka 2 days back ... how tolerant... :D
  • Firstly, I am no supporter of Lalu and political motivation argument is mostly true. But not everyone can be motivated, some could have been alarmed by the headlines in the newspapers. Mostly such incidents are not reported and people in cities don't hear about them, nor do MPs/MLAs usually ask people to relocate to Pakistan. You cannot assume to know what must have been going in the minds of other people. And artists are soft targets, someone can announce that anyone who slaps him will get 1 lakh and I am quite sure that there would have been no dearth of people threatening to rape his wife on Twitter.

    And yet this is the best time to be in India than ever in the history of mankind. Poverty is at a historic low, famines no longer occur in India, even most most traditional people do not subscribe to notions of overt caste discrimination (even though it has not completely been eradicated) and there are no kings anymore(I am a Republican and have no interest in celebrating kings of yesterday be it Akbar or Ashoka or Shivaji).

    But you cannot deny that there are some people who believe that it is the majority's benevolence that has 'allowed' Muslims to survive. Even celebrities like Raveena Tandon who seem to have no political motivations seem to suggest that Hindus have allowed a Muslim like Aamir Khan to succeed. And, please listen to Tariq's answer to the SALON-Firstpost talk held today on his take on Aamir Khan's situation.

    For anyone convinced that intolerance has been eradicated from India please also listen to Tariq's answer on intolerance in India, he has called all of us intolerant on the question of 'aukaat' and how we don't treat those less fortunate as us equals. Caste distinction continues to exist. Nepal has banned discrimination against LGBT individuals but we continue to stigmatize them, same goes for people with mental illness, AIDS and leprosy.

    And I have not compared India to Saudi Arabia, but I do have a dream that India is more open than what it is now.

    I am an atheist and even I don't have a fear in claiming that I am one so that is a testament to the social fabric of India. But, in the current stage of our society if I had been a LGBTQI individual I would have still been apprehensive of sharing that.
  • Muslim Apologetics and ISIS supporters have so much in common.
  • Muslim Apologetics and ISIS supporters have so much in common.
    True that.
  • And they say ISIS will find no support in India.
    nobody dares to speak against them becoz

    1.they vote tactically.not divided on caste lines.

    2.they have highest fertility rate their voters will be maximum in future in Dynasty politics who wants to speak against welfare of their own children.

    3.people are afraid to speak up imagine some other religion personality would have been shown like SHIVA in PK movie running in toilets(remember charlie hebdo,salman rushdie)

    4.above all Hindu bashing in cool in India.If you are intellectual first you have to abuse Hindus at most they can throw ink on you(haha ..India is sooo intolerant and saudi barbaria is place to migrate to becoz it is tolerant).
    1. No real evidence for this

    real evidence???......haven`t you read muslim confessing to vote for defeating BJP in newspapers ....i believe that is what is tactical voting you vote to defeat somebody not on issue of governace or development

    2. SCs STs have similar fertility rates. Fertility rates are dependent on socio-economic status and every UPSC aspirant knows that. BJP has supported dynastic groups all their lives. All parties in NDA are Dynastic. Piyush Goyal's dad was a minister in last NDA government, the have Sanjay Gandhi- the designer of the horrible sterilization program - his wife and son, Rajnath Singh's son is getting into politics.

    can you explain me kerala scenario???

    and recent one a techie america educated t went for jehad....to syria had 5 children...i believe he was more socially economically forward than most of us...........

    http://www.thehindu.com/news/national/techie-left-note-for-wife-before-heading-to-join-is/article7897123.ece


    have you ever read of lebanon in 1950s muslim and christian population was equal..now christians are minorty...90%muslims,10%chritians this is population jehad.......


  • plann
    http://indiatoday.intoday.in/story/facebook-account-of-a-journalist-blocked-after-post-about-child-sexual-abuse-in-a-madarassa/1/531743.html

    Cases like the above are ignored by the mainstream media.
    not ignored they set their agenda not to discus these topics.......remember azad maidan ..mumbai incident how much attention was given to it..imagine if that was done by hindus.......
  • Aurangzeb ne political reasons se maara tha. Kam se kam aap toh book padhiye. Ya wo bhi galat likhwa diya logo ne?
    ji haaa somnath ko loota economic reasons se

    nalanda ko jalaya cultural reason

    guru teg bahadur ko mara political reason se

    taimur aaya tourism reason se

    qasim aaya -gir ke lions dekhne incredible india


    paris attack hua hijab na pehnane dene ke reason se (mani bhai bole na)

    hum bhi INDIA ki side hai i come from freedom fighters family..my grand dad was in jail for 2.5 years in barasat becoz he fought in azad hind fauj...fought in aracan yoma myanmar singapore........

    parr mai khali isliye ki saachayi se nahi bhaag sakta ki problem those aur years ke liye tallll jaye......

    1920 khilafat ......mapillah revolts gandhi ji n his party ...tried to turn over the realities of kerala today that area is hotbed for jehadis...........

    i know we cant kill anybody but atleast we should accept what is true

    please koi book suggest kar do jaha likha ki aurenzeb kafiro ko pyaar karta tha.....


    In sab ka Hindustan se kya lena dena?
    Bhai toh ab kya aap in sab ka badla lene aaye hain?
    Ya yeh batane aaye hain ki non-Hindus yahan second grade citizens hain.
    kui bhai ye sab hindustani nahi the.........muslims attacker ne tabhayi ke alava kiya hi kiya hai....tumne to art and culture padha hoga na...indian mai invaders aane ke baad kui scientific discoveries band ho gayi ....koi aur nalanda ya takshakhshila kui nahi bani..???????????

    bhai hum apne ko defend karr rahe hai..na hum jehadi na hame bachpann se dusro ko hate karna sikhya jata hai..........

    yaha sab equal hai parr equal ka matlab EQUAL........jaha tak india ka sawaal hai ye desh hinduo ki vajahe se secular hai na ki kisi aur karan......

    muslims aur hindu ki population compare karr lo

    india,pakistan,bangladesh mai..1947 aur 2015 ki appko khud hi pata chal jayega............
  • Aurangzeb ne political reasons se maara tha. Kam se kam aap toh book padhiye. Ya wo bhi galat likhwa diya logo ne?
    ji haaa somnath ko loota economic reasons se

    nalanda ko jalaya cultural reason

    guru teg bahadur ko mara political reason se

    taimur aaya tourism reason se

    qasim aaya -gir ke lions dekhne incredible india


    paris attack hua hijab na pehnane dene ke reason se (mani bhai bole na)

    hum bhi INDIA ki side hai i come from freedom fighters family..my grand dad was in jail for 2.5 years in barasat becoz he fought in azad hind fauj...fought in aracan yoma myanmar singapore........

    parr mai khali isliye ki saachayi se nahi bhaag sakta ki problem those aur years ke liye tallll jaye......

    1920 khilafat ......mapillah revolts gandhi ji n his party ...tried to turn over the realities of kerala today that area is hotbed for jehadis...........

    i know we cant kill anybody but atleast we should accept what is true

    please koi book suggest kar do jaha likha ki aurenzeb kafiro ko pyaar karta tha.....


    In sab ka Hindustan se kya lena dena?
    Bhai toh ab kya aap in sab ka badla lene aaye hain?
    Ya yeh batane aaye hain ki non-Hindus yahan second grade citizens hain.
    kui bhai ye sab hindustani nahi the.........muslims attacker ne tabhayi ke alava kiya hi kiya hai....tumne to art and culture padha hoga na...indian mai invaders aane ke baad kui scientific discoveries band ho gayi ....koi aur nalanda ya takshakhshila kui nahi bani..???????????

    bhai hum apne ko defend karr rahe hai..na hum jehadi na hame bachpann se dusro ko hate karna sikhya jata hai..........

    yaha sab equal hai parr equal ka matlab EQUAL........jaha tak india ka sawaal hai ye desh hinduo ki vajahe se secular hai na ki kisi aur karan......

    muslims aur hindu ki population compare karr lo

    india,pakistan,bangladesh mai..1947 aur 2015 ki appko khud hi pata chal jayega............

    yar arguments ko itna peeche lejana hai to fir aryan raids on harappa . Killing of Buddhists and Jainas durinf the time of Pallava , Destruction of temples by Martanda varma of Kashmir , destruction of temples in Pallava Chalukya conflict , Shakya and Kushan invaders .....inke bare me bhi koi comments karo . Going into history is a slippery slope . Give arguments in present.
  • Aurangzeb ne political reasons se maara tha. Kam se kam aap toh book padhiye. Ya wo bhi galat likhwa diya logo ne?
    ji haaa somnath ko loota economic reasons se

    nalanda ko jalaya cultural reason

    guru teg bahadur ko mara political reason se

    taimur aaya tourism reason se

    qasim aaya -gir ke lions dekhne incredible india


    paris attack hua hijab na pehnane dene ke reason se (mani bhai bole na)

    hum bhi INDIA ki side hai i come from freedom fighters family..my grand dad was in jail for 2.5 years in barasat becoz he fought in azad hind fauj...fought in aracan yoma myanmar singapore........

    parr mai khali isliye ki saachayi se nahi bhaag sakta ki problem those aur years ke liye tallll jaye......

    1920 khilafat ......mapillah revolts gandhi ji n his party ...tried to turn over the realities of kerala today that area is hotbed for jehadis...........

    i know we cant kill anybody but atleast we should accept what is true

    please koi book suggest kar do jaha likha ki aurenzeb kafiro ko pyaar karta tha.....


    In sab ka Hindustan se kya lena dena?
    Bhai toh ab kya aap in sab ka badla lene aaye hain?
    Ya yeh batane aaye hain ki non-Hindus yahan second grade citizens hain.
    kui bhai ye sab hindustani nahi the.........muslims attacker ne tabhayi ke alava kiya hi kiya hai....tumne to art and culture padha hoga na...indian mai invaders aane ke baad kui scientific discoveries band ho gayi ....koi aur nalanda ya takshakhshila kui nahi bani..???????????

    bhai hum apne ko defend karr rahe hai..na hum jehadi na hame bachpann se dusro ko hate karna sikhya jata hai..........

    yaha sab equal hai parr equal ka matlab EQUAL........jaha tak india ka sawaal hai ye desh hinduo ki vajahe se secular hai na ki kisi aur karan......

    muslims aur hindu ki population compare karr lo

    india,pakistan,bangladesh mai..1947 aur 2015 ki appko khud hi pata chal jayega............
    Toh iska koi hal nikala hai kya aapne, population increase ka ya bas shor machana hai?
This discussion has been closed.

Welcome!

We are a secret self-moderated community for Civil Services preparation. Feel free to join, start a discussion, answer a question or just to say Thank you.

Just dont spread the word ;)

Sign in or join with Facebook or Google