INTERVIEW FOR CSE 2019
All ForumIAS members selected for CSE 2019 Personality Test must submit their details and DAF and register below to receive further instructions and guidance from ForumIAS. Click here to register now
INTERVIEW 2020 CHANNEL
ForumIAS Channel for Interview Preparation is now Active! Please join the channel by clicking here
We are hiring!

BASWAN Committee Survey about UPSC Exam Process

1235736

Comments

  • please take this survey in large number..as they are planning to reduce attempt/age..planning to bring ur graduation subject as ur optional...
    if graduation subject will be included then there is more than hundred graduation subjects.
    optional should be removed
    how will upsc take paper on graduation sub like power eng, tool eng, ceramic eng, plastic eng, leather eng, food tech, etc. how
  • graduation subjects-- strongly disagree
  • @vijaydinanathchauhan: sensible sir perhaps you dint understand my point.. Let me explain.. There are many candidates who get selected into services but when they appear in the exam next year to improve their ranks are no able to move through prelims and m talking about ppl who are already into services.. Therefore are many people who in each of their attempts reach interview stage and unfortunately don't get selected and again have to appear for prelims the next month..
    This is a part of exam and justice equality requires that.
    Prelims is only stage which is fair as everyone knows mistake.
    mains luck works some extent and interview mostly luck.
    this provision 1st can't be implemented as it is illegal.
  • edited January 2016
    how will upsc take paper on graduation sub like power eng, tool eng, ceramic eng, plastic eng, leather eng, food tech, etc. how guys prep for upsc making foolish statement of includig graduation sub.
    and why upsc has included inclusion of grad subject in survey
    Power engg is no diiferent then others engineering which include mechanical , electrical and student can see the syllabus and make sure which branch include

    tool engineering is pure manufacturing which is covered in mechanical part and student might have to study deep and there is no harm in it as many engineering student take humanities as optional which they havent studied throught their life ( Some specialized book of tool engineering like HMT is presribed in many mechanical Institution

    Ceramic engineering is Combined engineering which includes polymers wit manufacturing and its similar to Mechanical with Little chemical concept in it like rheology different extrusion technic

  • @vijaydinanathchauhan: sensible sir perhaps you dint understand my point.. Let me explain.. There are many candidates who get selected into services but when they appear in the exam next year to improve their ranks are no able to move through prelims and m talking about ppl who are already into services.. Therefore are many people who in each of their attempts reach interview stage and unfortunately don't get selected and again have to appear for prelims the next month..
    This is a part of exam and justice equality requires that.
    Prelims is only stage which is fair as everyone knows mistake.
    mains luck works some extent and interview mostly luck.
    this provision 1st can't be implemented as it is illegal.
    Hmm true.. But this was a point forwarded by nigvekar committee that prelim score card should have a validity of two years ..
  • edited January 2016
    @vijaydinanathchauhan: sensible sir perhaps you dint understand my point.. Let me explain.. There are many candidates who get selected into services but when they appear in the exam next year to improve their ranks are no able to move through prelims and m talking about ppl who are already into services.. Therefore are many people who in each of their attempts reach interview stage and unfortunately don't get selected and again have to appear for prelims the next month..
    This is a part of exam and justice equality requires that.
    Prelims is only stage which is fair as everyone knows mistake.
    mains luck works some extent and interview mostly luck.
    this provision 1st can't be implemented as it is illegal.
    Hmm true.. But this was a point forwarded by nigvekar committee that prelim score card should have a validity of two years ..
    That why nigvekar commitee is the worst because it will be injustice towards new candidate
  • edited January 2016
    how will upsc take paper on graduation sub like power eng, tool eng, ceramic eng, plastic eng, leather eng, food tech, etc. how guys prep for upsc making foolish statement of includig graduation sub.
    and why upsc has included inclusion of grad subject in survey
    Power engg is no diiferent then others engineering which include mechanical , electrical and student can see the syllabus and make sure which branch include

    tool engineering is pure manufacturing which is covered in mechanical part and student might have to study deep and there is no harm in it as many engineering student take humanities as optional which they havent studied throught their life ( Some specialized book of tool engineering like HMT is presribed in many mechanical Institution

    Ceramic engineering is Combined engineering which includes polymers wit manufacturing and its similar to Mechanical with Little chemical concept in it like rheology different extrusion technic

    according to ur explanation , power eng guys will suffer and elect, mech guys will enjoy.

  • That why nigvekar commitee is the worst because it will be injustice towards new candidate
    Ok.. This is your pov.. And we can always state our povs without using slangs. And from a candidate who is already selected one can always expect a healthy discussion on argument bereft of slangs..
  • I think people should be cautious in filling their opinion....the end result may be the just opposite of what the majority want and have filled....Upsc is deceptive and unpredictable so never let your guards off...few things are not what they appear to be..this is particularly true for upsc....so beware of any such inducement..upsc never does reforms based on crowd sourcing data...its known to be ruthless and will continue to be.....
    No offence intended to anyone..ignore if u disagree but don't abuse..
  • how will upsc take paper on graduation sub like power eng, tool eng, ceramic eng, plastic eng, leather eng, food tech, etc. how guys prep for upsc making foolish statement of includig graduation sub.
    and why upsc has included inclusion of grad subject in survey
    Power engg is no diiferent then others engineering which include mechanical , electrical and student can see the syllabus and make sure which branch include

    tool engineering is pure manufacturing which is covered in mechanical part and student might have to study deep and there is no harm in it as many engineering student take humanities as optional which they havent studied throught their life ( Some specialized book of tool engineering like HMT is presribed in many mechanical Institution

    Ceramic engineering is Combined engineering which includes polymers wit manufacturing and its similar to Mechanical with Little chemical concept in it like rheology different extrusion technic

    according to ur explanation , power eng guys will suffer and elect, mech guys will enjoy.
    No one will suffer as upsc provide 6 attempt which means 6 years so i dont think Mechancial or electrical is so tough that a student cannot clear in 6 attempts . I myself had mining engineering and i took mechanical and i have studied it 3 years continuously and scored good marks in it . I studied mining for 4 years and 3 years mechanical with MTECH and PHD in Mechanical
This discussion has been closed.

Welcome!

We are a secret self-moderated community for Civil Services preparation. Feel free to join, start a discussion, answer a question or just to say Thank you.

Just dont spread the word ;)

Sign in or join with Facebook or Google