INTERVIEW FOR CSE 2019
All ForumIAS members selected for CSE 2019 Personality Test must submit their details and DAF and register below to receive further instructions and guidance from ForumIAS. Click here to register now
INTERVIEW 2020 CHANNEL
ForumIAS Channel for Interview Preparation is now Active! Please join the channel by clicking here
We are hiring!

UPSC PRELIMS 2017 Question Paper Discussion

1362363365367368792

Comments

  • just a qus how do people ensure collective responsibility of cabinet ?? Can they bring adjurnment motion etc ??? Its d COM which is responsible to loksabha nd there by indirectly responsible to people... dats wht written in constitution..
    Just to add : Cabinet is a subset of CoM of minister. Isme mat confuse ho jaana.
    Bhaii log qstn hi nahi samjhe. Ki usme likha tha "Cabinet form of govt" , jiska matlab "parliamentary form" and "COM" bhi hai.
    Wo abhi bhi Cabinet and COM k difference ki peepdi baja rahe hai.
    This stupidity is a serious turn off.
    Exactly. I have read D D Basu many times since start of prep. And it is mentioned there at many places that Parliamentary and Cabinet form of government is synonymous. They are used interchangeably. Wahi soch ke I marked that responsibility wala option.

    I found speeding up things wala option absurd during exam. Sorry, but no offence intended.

    Apart from that, Vairam's polity answers are rarely wrong.
    I
    just a qus how do people ensure collective responsibility of cabinet ?? Can they bring adjurnment motion etc ??? Its d COM which is responsible to loksabha nd there by indirectly responsible to people... dats wht written in constitution..
    Just to add : Cabinet is a subset of CoM Council of minister. Isme mat confuse ho jaana.
    and more thing, Collective responsibility means, ki even if one minister loses his confidence in HoP then the CoM has to go.

    i know that... chutiya maat samjoo :D so why cabinet?? we already hav council of minister..
    Cabinet may also be for speeding of things for CoM, among other advantages.

    But Cabinet Form of government is different. Our and British system is called Cabinet Form of government or Parliamentary system in all types of parlance. Had it asked for need of Cabinet in CoM, speeding up things would definitely have been correct. But not in case of Cabinet Form of Government
    If the question refers to British and Indian type of parliamentary/cabinet form of govt then option C is totally false. Coz parliament is never responsible to the 'people' but to the legislature only.
    Haan bhai.. mera galat ho gya.. You add +2.66 and I'm subtracting that much.
    And haan, all these Coaching wale are dumb-ass..
  • sala 90% janta k marks 10 se zyada kam hue h.. and cutoff wahi tika rhega..
    Section to 1% ka hota hai 90% se koi matter nahi karega wo to wesi hi bhaar hai
  • @Cremator hemu bhai ye dekho..ye 3 lines s poora Q create kia gya hai...saare options yhi s bnaye hain...
    1942 edition :D :D :D horse bones were found after 1970s I think
    Kejru bahut desperate he bhai tu to.. apne muffler se chasme saf karke dekh iski latest print 2014 ki he and it was edited and infos were added. Anyways tuje cabinet form of government hi parliamentary form of government he ye simple si bat samaj ni ayi to ye to kya ghanta samaj me ayega
    bhai vo reprint hai..rewrite nhi.
  • edited June 2017
    105 by vision zyada h 103 sae 1 no zyada cut off nhi jaani...yaha elimination vala khel b nahi chla happy bday kar dia
    haha.. sala mere 2-3 dost h and mera din accha ho toh m bhi... hum log JEE and GATE m khel liye options se jaha itna tight pack rehta h options.. upsc m bhi khele 2 saall.. iss baar lekin down kar diya upsc ne.. baith hi nhi rha tha combinations.. last year 35 Qs aise hi kiye the.. isss baar sirf 20 k aaspass. nhi ho pa rha tha kuch bhi. har technique fail ho ja rhi thi.. options acche design hue h ..
  • Getting 80-84 in p2 and getting good marks in p1.How much variation may occur p2 in the final marks??
  • Getting 80-84 in p2 and getting good marks in p1.How much variation may occur p2 in the final marks??
    20-25 no k kareeb ....
  • Getting 80-84 in p2 and getting good marks in p1.How much variation may occur p2 in the final marks??
    Enough to knock people out, just 5-6 question variation is required :D
  • Getting 80-84 in p2 and getting good marks in p1.How much variation may occur p2 in the final marks??
    20-25 no k kareeb ....
    Maths k kitne aa the hain ...excluding English comprehension
    :/
  • Getting 80-84 in p2 and getting good marks in p1.How much variation may occur p2 in the final marks??
    20-25 no k kareeb ....
    Maths k kitne aa the hain ...excluding English comprehension
    :/
    major portion passage se hai.
  • Getting 80-84 in p2 and getting good marks in p1.How much variation may occur p2 in the final marks??
    20-25 no k kareeb ....
    Maths k kitne aa the hain ...excluding English comprehension
    :/
    major portion passage se hai.
    Phir to gadbad hai >:)
This discussion has been closed.

Welcome!

We are a secret self-moderated community for Civil Services preparation. Feel free to join, start a discussion, answer a question or just to say Thank you.

Just dont spread the word ;)

Sign in or join with Facebook or Google