INTERVIEW FOR CSE 2019
All ForumIAS members selected for CSE 2019 Personality Test must submit their details and DAF and register below to receive further instructions and guidance from ForumIAS. Click here to register now
INTERVIEW 2020 CHANNEL
ForumIAS Channel for Interview Preparation is now Active! Please join the channel by clicking here
We are hiring!

Mains 2015 gs paper 2 - your analysis and probable score

1235789

Comments

  • Givn mains only aftr multiple coaching mocks.wrtng at multuple sites,discusn wid parnts n seniors alrdy in service.wid decnt marks n remrks.my 2cents-
    satisfactory answrs=5×5.5=27.5
    average answrs= 4×4.5=18
    below avrge anwrs= 5×3.5=17.5
    sub-optima= 2×3= 06
    garbage= 3×2= 06
    total= 75*
    *discount=7 aftr compring on dis thrd expectd=68
    aapke marks jayda aayenge lekin upsc me ye distribution nahi chalta coaching wala satisfactory aur avg me +1 aur aayega.
    but garbage aur sub optimal me kam.( kuch bhi likhne se upsc kuch bhi marks nahi deti hai 2013 paper 1 87 in 19 attempted ques out of 25 and gs-2 about 50 with 25 attempt ab saare garbage toh nahi hi honge kuch acha bhi hoga aur koi ans complete incorrect nahi tha)
    overall
    2013 paper2 avg to sub40 tha shayad.us hisab se dekha jai to apke mrks thik hi the paperII me
    Is bar kya lagta hai apko
  • Givn mains only aftr multiple coaching mocks.wrtng at multuple sites,discusn wid parnts n seniors alrdy in service.wid decnt marks n remrks.my 2cents-
    satisfactory answrs=5×5.5=27.5
    average answrs= 4×4.5=18
    below avrge anwrs= 5×3.5=17.5
    sub-optima= 2×3= 06
    garbage= 3×2= 06
    total= 75*
    *discount=7 aftr compring on dis thrd expectd=68
    aapke marks jayda aayenge lekin upsc me ye distribution nahi chalta coaching wala satisfactory aur avg me +1 aur aayega.
    but garbage aur sub optimal me kam.( kuch bhi likhne se upsc kuch bhi marks nahi deti hai 2013 paper 1 87 in 19 attempted ques out of 25 and gs-2 about 50 with 25 attempt ab saare garbage toh nahi hi honge kuch acha bhi hoga aur koi ans complete incorrect nahi tha)
    overall
    2013 paper2 avg to sub40 tha shayad.us hisab se dekha jai to apke mrks thik hi the paperII me
    lekin gs-1 ka bhi avg 60+ nahi tha waise dekhiyega toh gs-1 ka bahout marks hai ye us time pe.
  • edited January 2016
    In DC wadhwa case, SC had pronounced a lot of guidelines,statements and rulings. I think listing the exceptions of Ordinance is not very important among other things said by the Apex Court. Why? Because In the Art 123 itself the exceptional situation is mentioned where Parliamentary procedure can be bypassed(SC merely reiterates it)

    In our GS2 question, I believe the aspect which was required to be mentioned was that in Wadhwa case SC had said that people have constitutional right to question the re-promulgation of an ordinance(Land ordinance was repromulgated). See the language of the question, I think question wanted this, otherwise exceptions have nothing great to be mentioned in that answer, as one would already mentioned them while explaining 2 lines about Art 123.
  • Givn mains only aftr multiple coaching mocks.wrtng at multuple sites,discusn wid parnts n seniors alrdy in service.wid decnt marks n remrks.my 2cents-
    satisfactory answrs=5×5.5=27.5
    average answrs= 4×4.5=18
    below avrge anwrs= 5×3.5=17.5
    sub-optima= 2×3= 06
    garbage= 3×2= 06
    total= 75*
    *discount=7 aftr compring on dis thrd expectd=68
    aapke marks jayda aayenge lekin upsc me ye distribution nahi chalta coaching wala satisfactory aur avg me +1 aur aayega.
    but garbage aur sub optimal me kam.( kuch bhi likhne se upsc kuch bhi marks nahi deti hai 2013 paper 1 87 in 19 attempted ques out of 25 and gs-2 about 50 with 25 attempt ab saare garbage toh nahi hi honge kuch acha bhi hoga aur koi ans complete incorrect nahi tha)
    overall
    2013 paper2 avg to sub40 tha shayad.us hisab se dekha jai to apke mrks thik hi the paperII me
    lekin gs-1 ka bhi avg 60+ nahi tha waise dekhiyega toh gs-1 ka bahout marks hai ye us time pe.
    ha...ha gsI k to apke mrks kamal hi hai us time k hisab se.phir to is bar aram se apke three digit cross honge(marks m rank m nahi).
  • In DC wadhwa case, SC had pronounced a lot of guidelines,statements and rulings. I think listing the exceptions of Ordinance is not very important among other things said by the Apex Court. Why? Because In the Art 123 itself the exceptional situation is mentioned where Parliamentary procedure can be bypassed.

    In our GS2 question, I believe the aspect which was required to be mentioned was that in Wadhwa case SC had said that people have constitutional right to question the re-promulgation. See the language of the question, I think question wanted this, otherwise exceptions have nothing great to be mentioned in that answer, as one would already mentioned them while explaining 2 lines about Art 123.
    http://www.prsindia.org/theprsblog/?p=3088 ye cooper case me judicial review bola tha. wadhwa me extraordinary hi bola tha. maine yanhi se copy kiya kanhi prs ne toh galat nahi likh diya :/
  • Givn mains only aftr multiple coaching mocks.wrtng at multuple sites,discusn wid parnts n seniors alrdy in service.wid decnt marks n remrks.my 2cents-
    satisfactory answrs=5×5.5=27.5
    average answrs= 4×4.5=18
    below avrge anwrs= 5×3.5=17.5
    sub-optima= 2×3= 06
    garbage= 3×2= 06
    total= 75*
    *discount=7 aftr compring on dis thrd expectd=68
    aapke marks jayda aayenge lekin upsc me ye distribution nahi chalta coaching wala satisfactory aur avg me +1 aur aayega.
    but garbage aur sub optimal me kam.( kuch bhi likhne se upsc kuch bhi marks nahi deti hai 2013 paper 1 87 in 19 attempted ques out of 25 and gs-2 about 50 with 25 attempt ab saare garbage toh nahi hi honge kuch acha bhi hoga aur koi ans complete incorrect nahi tha)
    overall
    2013 paper2 avg to sub40 tha shayad.us hisab se dekha jai to apke mrks thik hi the paperII me
    lekin gs-1 ka bhi avg 60+ nahi tha waise dekhiyega toh gs-1 ka bahout marks hai ye us time pe.
    ha...ha gsI k to apke mrks kamal hi hai us time k hisab se.phir to is bar aram se apke three digit cross honge(marks m rank m nahi).
    Is bar rank 1 digit me aygi bhai ki
  • Givn mains only aftr multiple coaching mocks.wrtng at multuple sites,discusn wid parnts n seniors alrdy in service.wid decnt marks n remrks.my 2cents-
    satisfactory answrs=5×5.5=27.5
    average answrs= 4×4.5=18
    below avrge anwrs= 5×3.5=17.5
    sub-optima= 2×3= 06
    garbage= 3×2= 06
    total= 75*
    *discount=7 aftr compring on dis thrd expectd=68
    aapke marks jayda aayenge lekin upsc me ye distribution nahi chalta coaching wala satisfactory aur avg me +1 aur aayega.
    but garbage aur sub optimal me kam.( kuch bhi likhne se upsc kuch bhi marks nahi deti hai 2013 paper 1 87 in 19 attempted ques out of 25 and gs-2 about 50 with 25 attempt ab saare garbage toh nahi hi honge kuch acha bhi hoga aur koi ans complete incorrect nahi tha)
    overall
    2013 paper2 avg to sub40 tha shayad.us hisab se dekha jai to apke mrks thik hi the paperII me
    lekin gs-1 ka bhi avg 60+ nahi tha waise dekhiyega toh gs-1 ka bahout marks hai ye us time pe.
    ha...ha gsI k to apke mrks kamal hi hai us time k hisab se.phir to is bar aram se apke three digit cross honge(marks m rank m nahi).
    Is bar rank 1 digit me aygi bhai ki
    1 digit choro 2 digit bhi choro 3 digit me bhi rank aa gayi toh dhanya ho jaunga :D :D
  • In DC wadhwa case, SC had pronounced a lot of guidelines,statements and rulings. I think listing the exceptions of Ordinance is not very important among other things said by the Apex Court. Why? Because In the Art 123 itself the exceptional situation is mentioned where Parliamentary procedure can be bypassed.

    In our GS2 question, I believe the aspect which was required to be mentioned was that in Wadhwa case SC had said that people have constitutional right to question the re-promulgation. See the language of the question, I think question wanted this, otherwise exceptions have nothing great to be mentioned in that answer, as one would already mentioned them while explaining 2 lines about Art 123.
    http://www.prsindia.org/theprsblog/?p=3088 ye cooper case me judicial review bola tha. wadhwa me extraordinary hi bola tha. maine yanhi se copy kiya kanhi prs ne toh galat nahi likh diya :/
    Its not incorrect if you have quoted cooper
  • edited January 2016
    @warrior0602 Subhash Kashyap page no 230 dekhlo bro. Our Constitution. Sirf judical review nahi aur bhi batein kahin hain. Cooper main judicial review 1970 main hi kaha ja chuka tha
  • Givn mains only aftr multiple coaching mocks.wrtng at multuple sites,discusn wid parnts n seniors alrdy in service.wid decnt marks n remrks.my 2cents-
    satisfactory answrs=5×5.5=27.5
    average answrs= 4×4.5=18
    below avrge anwrs= 5×3.5=17.5
    sub-optima= 2×3= 06
    garbage= 3×2= 06
    total= 75*
    *discount=7 aftr compring on dis thrd expectd=68
    aapke marks jayda aayenge lekin upsc me ye distribution nahi chalta coaching wala satisfactory aur avg me +1 aur aayega.
    but garbage aur sub optimal me kam.( kuch bhi likhne se upsc kuch bhi marks nahi deti hai 2013 paper 1 87 in 19 attempted ques out of 25 and gs-2 about 50 with 25 attempt ab saare garbage toh nahi hi honge kuch acha bhi hoga aur koi ans complete incorrect nahi tha)
    overall
    2013 paper2 avg to sub40 tha shayad.us hisab se dekha jai to apke mrks thik hi the paperII me
    lekin gs-1 ka bhi avg 60+ nahi tha waise dekhiyega toh gs-1 ka bahout marks hai ye us time pe.
    ha...ha gsI k to apke mrks kamal hi hai us time k hisab se.phir to is bar aram se apke three digit cross honge(marks m rank m nahi).
    Is bar rank 1 digit me aygi bhai ki
    1 digit choro 2 digit bhi choro 3 digit me bhi rank aa gayi toh dhanya ho jaunga :D :D
    Aa jayge bhai
Sign In or Join to comment.

Welcome!

We are a secret self-moderated community for Civil Services preparation. Feel free to join, start a discussion, answer a question or just to say Thank you.

Just dont spread the word ;)

Sign in or join with Facebook or Google