INTERVIEW FOR CSE 2019
All ForumIAS members selected for CSE 2019 Personality Test must submit their details and DAF and register below to receive further instructions and guidance from ForumIAS. Click here to register now
INTERVIEW 2020 CHANNEL
ForumIAS Channel for Interview Preparation is now Active! Please join the channel by clicking here
We are hiring!

Can a human be killed on the suspicion of what he ate?

1246720

Comments

  • @INeeDtoGetIn
    God gaya tel lene pahale ye batao janwaron ko marna kaha ka dharm hai?
    pehle batao phool pattiyon ka maarna kaha ka dharm hai? =)) :))


    When wheat plant is dried and it's life cycle ends only then it's seeds are eaten. If you wish you can chew the bones of dead animals..nobody will have any issue.
  • @INeeDtoGetIn
    God gaya tel lene pahale ye batao janwaron ko marna kaha ka dharm hai?
    pehle batao phool pattiyon ka maarna kaha ka dharm hai? =)) :))


    When wheat plant is dried and it's life cycle ends only then it's seeds are eaten. If you wish you can chew the bones of dead animals..nobody will have any issue.
    Ooh kabhi biology padha karo mahagyani mishraji. :P Seeds are not dead. :))
    Aur apka stomach wala acid microbes kyun marta hai? woh dharm hai? aap roz hazaro microbes ke upar chalte ho. woh dharm hai? aap vegetarian khane ke hazaro microbes ko ingest karte ho. woh dharm hai? :))
  • @shopra

    Sabse pahle ye batao..mai tumhe maar ke khaa jaun? Mai pryaapt takatwar hun..bahut bade baap ka beta hun..khud ke paas paise ki koi kami nahi hai...chahu to maar sakta hun tumhe..bolo..theek hai? =))
  • @shopra

    Sabse pahle ye batao..mai tumhe maar ke khaa jaun? Mai pryaapt takatwar hun..bahut bade baap ka beta hun..khud ke paas paise ki koi kami nahi hai...chahu to maar sakta hun tumhe..bolo..theek hai? =))
    galat shopra ka tag kardiye. bechara darr jaega. :))
    Oooh rowdism /:) karo karo. :D
  • @shopra

    Sorry dost. Kisi aur ko likha par tumhe chala gaya.
  • Minimum government, mobximum governance.

    Ye "SMART" police...Strict and Sensitive, Modern and Mobile, Alert and Accountable, Reliable and Responsive, Techno savvy and Trained .. ye wali police kahan thi?

    Proactive governance

    Effective governance

    M governance

    All for witnessing mob justice to prevail?
  • Minimum government, mobximum governance.

    Ye "SMART" police...Strict and Sensitive, Modern and Mobile, Alert and Accountable, Reliable and Responsive, Techno savvy and Trained .. ye wali police kahan thi?

    Proactive governance

    Effective governance

    M governance

    All for witnessing mob justice to prevail?

    Sawal UP sarkaar se hai yaa kisi aur se?
  • edited September 2015
    @INeeDtoGetIn
    God gaya tel lene pahale ye batao janwaron ko marna kaha ka dharm hai?
    @Mornity Mishra

    Bhai, ek baat batao.
    Man is an omnivorous animal. This is a fact. You ancestors were meat eaters, irrespective of whether they were Brahmins or dalits, Hindus or Muslims.

    If you really want to talk about life, even plants have life. When you pluck fruits, eat them, don't they die? When you cut trees, with which paper is made, don't they die?

    Anyway, i understand your point. Animal slaughter does have an ethical issue.

    The problem is, i have to get 120 gms of protein per day to maintain my body. It is not possible without chicken. It is not possible on a vegetarian diet while keeping fat at a minimum. Please don't argue in this issue. I have done enough research. You can see the result. When you eat chicken everyday, every meal, it becomes more than just a tasty dish. It becomes a compulsion, like drinking milk every day. Or you might like eating choole bature every day. Chicken is my thing.

    If they find artificial meat, which i think will be done soon, then i will choose that. Till then, let me choose my own menu, dress, anything till it does not cause harm to another human. When it causes physical harm to someone else, then i have crossed the line. This is the basis of justice in today's world based on individualism. It is the basis of our constitution. Read constitutional debates. So please don't argue that individualism is a western concept.

    And don't say that kisi aur ko kyo nahi khaa jate(why dont you eat another human).

    I think we can all agree that human life is more valuable than chicken. If you disagree, i think you are one of the people who was complicit in today's religious grotesque misadventures in UP. They also thought there is no difference between a human and a cow.
  • Man is many things. It's only man who fights a war, it's only a man who murders, it's man who rapes, it's man who saves, it's man who sacrifices, it's man who gives UPSC, it's man who takes...so what?

    Man is many things my friend. Thing is man has to eat.

    Just because man did many things wrong in past..how can it justify doing same in present? For example waging a war..

    And this argument about plant and microbe life is stupid. Here it's about animals. Human survival depends on plant's products not on animal's meat.

    As for as technical point of availability of protein is concerned. See before 70s a large chunk of humanity was dying just for the lack of food and many more were malnourished..what did we do? increased the production of cereals. Why can't we increase that of pulses and beans and milk products.

    Human life is surly more valuable than animal but this thing arises when we are compelled to murder one of them either human or animal.

    if you have any ethical or moral point in killing the animals..pls put forth otherwise rest are unsustainable.
  • Rss and bjp are polarizing people on name of religion,this incident is a bolt on India democracy
    Why blaming rss bjp only? Each and every party is busy doing it..taali ek haath se nhi bajti bhaiya..owaisi bhai saab ko bhool gye aap? Just hoping it shud not get worse but the thing is both sides are equally involved..
    . I have no sympathy for owaisi also but just because somebody is doing wrong it doesn't give u right to do the same ,and I blame rss and bjp because they act like custodian of hindusim which. Is very diverse where meat eating has been phenomenon since ages and irrespective of who is government this particular incident was instigated by sangh parivar at ground level and usually victims of such incidents are poor and vulnerable irrespective of religion ,because they cant go to 5star hotel kill people who eat beef steak ,so my concern is victims are always poor and helpless


This discussion has been closed.

Welcome!

We are a secret self-moderated community for Civil Services preparation. Feel free to join, start a discussion, answer a question or just to say Thank you.

Just dont spread the word ;)

Sign in or join with Facebook or Google