INTERVIEW FOR CSE 2019
All ForumIAS members selected for CSE 2019 Personality Test must submit their details and DAF and register below to receive further instructions and guidance from ForumIAS. Click here to register now
INTERVIEW 2020 CHANNEL
ForumIAS Channel for Interview Preparation is now Active! Please join the channel by clicking here
We are hiring!

UPSC PRELIMS 2017 Question Paper Discussion

1209210212214215792

Comments

  • edited June 2017
    cabinet wala question...any clarity on that..??
    my take :smile:
    forget about india and its cabinet.
    governments can be analysed in different sense like parliamentary form or presidential form.
    cabinet form or council form.
    council form where chief executive is responsibile for every thing.
    cabinet form where portfolios is allocated to different ministers.
    even before independence we have cabinet form of government ,which started after 1861 act. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_Councils_Act_1861.

    cabinets can be in presidential /parliamentary /auctocratic governments.

    also no way cabinet can ensures collective responsibilty to people.!


    then why cabinet ? we hav already council of ministers who r collectively responsible...why make a smaller team? dnt u think they cld hav taken a collective decision with just council of ministers? why wld council of ministers will b irresponsible to people? why wld council of ministers which is a larger team than cabinet will be fail 2 stop prime minister from being a dictator?
    ohh sry.. u r supporting my point.. i shd go nd sleep.. too much boozing
  • cabinet wala question...any clarity on that..??
    my take :smile:
    forget about india and its cabinet.
    governments can be analysed in different sense like parliamentary form or presidential form.
    cabinet form or council form.
    council form where chief executive is responsibile for every thing.
    cabinet form where portfolios is allocated to different ministers.
    even before independence we have cabinet form of government ,which started after 1861 act. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_Councils_Act_1861.

    cabinets can be in presidential /parliamentary /auctocratic governments.

    also no way cabinet can ensures collective responsibilty to people.!


    Cabint vaala to b hi hai
    Pata nai kyu saari keys c de rai hain iska answer , aur responsibility to chodo c option me ye likha hai ki it is a mechanism of "parliamentary" form of govt

    Ab cabinet to US me bhi hai ye to stmt yahin galat ho gya
  • How UPI benefits DBT..

    In UPI the transaction cost decreases .Inter banking transfer easy now..From govt sponsored bank to beneficiary bank account..Now Banks are charging high rate for DBT transfers..
    ye padho bhai idhar to bol rahe h ki mobile apps required for UPI but single app se kaam ho jayega
    http://www.npci.org.in/UPI_Background.aspx
    UPI k liye koi app nhi chhiye me roj krta UPI se payment, net ka bill bhi UPI se ho jata he. BS phone USSD support krna chahiye i.e cdma phone nhi hona chahiye i.e. GSM hona chahiye...........hahaha
    matlab npci ki site pe galat likha h? aur ussd vala bhai online payment me ata h kya? online ke liye to phir app chahiye hoga na
    nhi Bhai online me nhi aata , *99# dial krk try kro shi cheej he
    to bhai option A galat hua na is hisab se usme likha h
    mobile wallets will not be necessary for online payments.
    online ke liye to wallet chahiye hoga
    agar online ki jagah digital likha hota to ye option thik hota
    correct me if i am wrong.
    mobile wallets isliye nhi chahiye kyuki when you are paying online via UPI option you will receive a collect request on you phone in the form of a popup when you dial *99#, and then you can make that payment from your phone. If you have set up your UPI then I can give you an example by sending you a collect request......hahaha
    kya baklol ho be kabhi to khud hi bol rahe USSD online payment me nahi aata aur ab ye kya bol rahe ho?

    abe bunty tumhara dimag slow he, passages me bhi pakka glt krk aaye hoge.........hahaha.........online kha se ho gya bc jb no. dial krk payment kr rha wo bhi nokia 3310 se
  • cabinet wala question...any clarity on that..??
    my take :smile:
    forget about india and its cabinet.
    governments can be analysed in different sense like parliamentary form or presidential form.
    cabinet form or council form.
    council form where chief executive is responsibile for every thing.
    cabinet form where portfolios is allocated to different ministers.
    even before independence we have cabinet form of government ,which started after 1861 act. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_Councils_Act_1861.

    cabinets can be in presidential /parliamentary /auctocratic governments.

    also no way cabinet can ensures collective responsibilty to people.!


    then why cabinet ? we hav already council of ministers who r collectively responsible...why make a smaller team? dnt u think they cld hav taken a collective decision with just council of ministers? why wld council of ministers will b irresponsible to people? why wld council of ministers which is a larger team than cabinet will be fail 2 stop prime minister from being a dictator?
    since nature of responsibilities have increased tremendously for governemnt over the years .it is not possibile for entire council of ministers to meet regurlarly andalso arriving at consensus is difficult.so it is actually cabinet which meets and speeds up the decisison making process in governmnet.
  • insights aye shankar mein bas Indus valley horse ka answer different hai na?

    pls confirm.
    Bhai insights me fundamental duty me both dia hai shankar and every other key has given none
  • cabinet wala question...any clarity on that..??
    my take :smile:
    forget about india and its cabinet.
    governments can be analysed in different sense like parliamentary form or presidential form.
    cabinet form or council form.
    council form where chief executive is responsibile for every thing.
    cabinet form where portfolios is allocated to different ministers.
    even before independence we have cabinet form of government ,which started after 1861 act. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_Councils_Act_1861.

    cabinets can be in presidential /parliamentary /auctocratic governments.

    also no way cabinet can ensures collective responsibilty to people.!


    then why cabinet ? we hav already council of ministers who r collectively responsible...why make a smaller team? dnt u think they cld hav taken a collective decision with just council of ministers? why wld council of ministers will b irresponsible to people? why wld council of ministers which is a larger team than cabinet will be fail 2 stop prime minister from being a dictator?
    since nature of responsibilities have increased tremendously for governemnt over the years .it is not possibile for entire council of ministers to meet regurlarly andalso arriving at consensus is difficult.so it is actually cabinet which meets and speeds up the decisison making process in governmnet.
    u r right ....

  • online via UPI mtlb options hote he na pay by credit card/ debit card to wha pr UPI ka option bhi aata he, jb wo option chose kroge toh yumse virtual payment address puchega tumhara, or fir tumhare phone no, pr message ayega..........choddo tum live demo dekhlo youtube pr............hahaha
  • Guys getting 118 Obc category any chance.
  • online via UPI mtlb options hote he na pay by credit card/ debit card to wha pr UPI ka option bhi aata he, jb wo option chose kroge toh yumse virtual payment address puchega tumhara, or fir tumhare phone no, pr message ayega..........choddo tum live demo dekhlo youtube pr............hahaha
    ye hahahaha kya laga rakha hai ..
  • insights aye shankar mein bas Indus valley horse ka answer different hai na?

    pls confirm.
This discussion has been closed.

Welcome!

We are a secret self-moderated community for Civil Services preparation. Feel free to join, start a discussion, answer a question or just to say Thank you.

Just dont spread the word ;)

Sign in or join with Facebook or Google