APFC Vs IDAS/ICAS/IPTAFS/IRAS

What is the difference in work profile?Which is better one and why?
Troll

Comments

  • edited April 20
    Koi nehi hai forum mei?
    Troll
  • Sab bekar hai.. B) go for IAS.
  • edited April 21
    007_A said:

    Sab bekar hai.. B) go for IAS.

    Naa..Only IPS,no IAS......like bond 007 B)
    Troll
  • edited May 21

    What is the difference in work profile?Which is better one and why?

    Apfc is way way below these posts....even AFHQ civil service is better than APFC.....highest grade pay you can attain in EPFO is 10000 and there are only 3 or 4 posts in that grade pay....while in said civil services everyone will attain 10000 grade pay and there are numerous higher post in HAG grade in these services. ....in IDAS there are two apex scale post (highest anyone can attain in civil services except cabinet secretary) and there are numerous deputation opportunities in IDAS,IPATFS,IRAS etc.......work profile is quite varied....for example in IDAS you are accounting Army,Air Force Navy,Ordnance factories, Drdo,MES etc. also you are concerned with internal auditing of every penny spent therein....you are also involved in high level defence purchases...you will rub shoulder with Who's and who of defence forces ..In my opinion group A services through CSE exam including Indian Forest Service are way way above than all other services except CIVIL ENGINEERING RAILWAY/CPWD,top posts of state civil services and to some extent Indian Economic Service.

  • mimansa said:

    What is the difference in work profile?Which is better one and why?

    Apfc is way way below these posts....even AFHQ civil service is better than APFC.....highest grade pay you can attain in EPFO is 10000 and there are only 3 or 4 posts in that grade pay....while in said civil services everyone will attain 10000 grade pay and there are numerous higher post in HAG grade in these services. ....in IDAS there are two apex scale post (highest anyone can attain in civil services except cabinet secretary) and there are numerous deputation opportunities in IDAS,IPATFS,IRAS etc.......work profile is quite varied....for example in IDAS you are accounting Army,Air Force Navy,Ordnance factories, Drdo,MES etc. also you are concerned with internal auditing of every penny spent therein....you are also involved in high level defence purchases...you will rub shoulder with Who's and who of defence forces ..In my opinion group A services through CSE exam including Indian Forest Service are way way above than all other services except CIVIL ENGINEERING RAILWAY/CPWD,top posts of state civil services and to some extent Indian Economic Service.

    1. Absolutely wrong. Very few deputation opportunities.
    2. Lol.. All have accounting profile tau. How is it varied.

    But yes Group A better.
  • edited May 21
    okie said:

    mimansa said:

    What is the difference in work profile?Which is better one and why?

    Apfc is way way below these posts....even AFHQ civil service is better than APFC.....highest grade pay you can attain in EPFO is 10000 and there are only 3 or 4 posts in that grade pay....while in said civil services everyone will attain 10000 grade pay and there are numerous higher post in HAG grade in these services. ....in IDAS there are two apex scale post (highest anyone can attain in civil services except cabinet secretary) and there are numerous deputation opportunities in IDAS,IPATFS,IRAS etc.......work profile is quite varied....for example in IDAS you are accounting Army,Air Force Navy,Ordnance factories, Drdo,MES etc. also you are concerned with internal auditing of every penny spent therein....you are also involved in high level defence purchases...you will rub shoulder with Who's and who of defence forces ..In my opinion group A services through CSE exam including Indian Forest Service are way way above than all other services except CIVIL ENGINEERING RAILWAY/CPWD,top posts of state civil services and to some extent Indian Economic Service.

    1. Absolutely wrong. Very few deputation opportunities.
    2. Lol.. All have accounting profile tau. How is it varied.

    But yes Group A better.
    We are here comparing it with APFC.

  • mimansa said:

    okie said:

    mimansa said:

    What is the difference in work profile?Which is better one and why?

    Apfc is way way below these posts....even AFHQ civil service is better than APFC.....highest grade pay you can attain in EPFO is 10000 and there are only 3 or 4 posts in that grade pay....while in said civil services everyone will attain 10000 grade pay and there are numerous higher post in HAG grade in these services. ....in IDAS there are two apex scale post (highest anyone can attain in civil services except cabinet secretary) and there are numerous deputation opportunities in IDAS,IPATFS,IRAS etc.......work profile is quite varied....for example in IDAS you are accounting Army,Air Force Navy,Ordnance factories, Drdo,MES etc. also you are concerned with internal auditing of every penny spent therein....you are also involved in high level defence purchases...you will rub shoulder with Who's and who of defence forces ..In my opinion group A services through CSE exam including Indian Forest Service are way way above than all other services except CIVIL ENGINEERING RAILWAY/CPWD,top posts of state civil services and to some extent Indian Economic Service.

    1. Absolutely wrong. Very few deputation opportunities.
    2. Lol.. All have accounting profile tau. How is it varied.

    But yes Group A better.
    We are here comparing it with APFC.

    Deputation opportunity
    Apfc = 0
    These services = 1
    Is it lot brother? :D
  • edited May 21
    okie said:

    mimansa said:

    okie said:

    mimansa said:

    What is the difference in work profile?Which is better one and why?

    Apfc is way way below these posts....even AFHQ civil service is better than APFC.....highest grade pay you can attain in EPFO is 10000 and there are only 3 or 4 posts in that grade pay....while in said civil services everyone will attain 10000 grade pay and there are numerous higher post in HAG grade in these services. ....in IDAS there are two apex scale post (highest anyone can attain in civil services except cabinet secretary) and there are numerous deputation opportunities in IDAS,IPATFS,IRAS etc.......work profile is quite varied....for example in IDAS you are accounting Army,Air Force Navy,Ordnance factories, Drdo,MES etc. also you are concerned with internal auditing of every penny spent therein....you are also involved in high level defence purchases...you will rub shoulder with Who's and who of defence forces ..In my opinion group A services through CSE exam including Indian Forest Service are way way above than all other services except CIVIL ENGINEERING RAILWAY/CPWD,top posts of state civil services and to some extent Indian Economic Service.

    1. Absolutely wrong. Very few deputation opportunities.
    2. Lol.. All have accounting profile tau. How is it varied.

    But yes Group A better.
    We are here comparing it with APFC.

    Deputation opportunity
    Apfc = 0
    These services = 1
    Is it lot brother? :D
    Deputation
    Apfc=0
    IDAS=more than 25 at SAG level...while APFC has only 3-4 total posts at SAG level leave alone deputation....LOL

    Check this civil list
    https://www.google.co.in/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=http://cgda.nic.in/pdf/pink.pdf&ved=0ahUKEwiT_Zf30YHUAhWIKo8KHSzACYUQFggqMAE&usg=AFQjCNFx0SgDOf7KNjYhmZW3f2nAcRiNFQ&sig2=IrZGec92UlhvGnvUglxucA

    @okie
  • Mimansa is right.
    All central accounts services provide very good deputation opportunities.
  • ICAS>IDAS>IPTAFS>iras => this is based on foreign deputation oppurtunities.
  • mimansa said:

    okie said:

    mimansa said:

    okie said:

    mimansa said:

    What is the difference in work profile?Which is better one and why?

    Apfc is way way below these posts....even AFHQ civil service is better than APFC.....highest grade pay you can attain in EPFO is 10000 and there are only 3 or 4 posts in that grade pay....while in said civil services everyone will attain 10000 grade pay and there are numerous higher post in HAG grade in these services. ....in IDAS there are two apex scale post (highest anyone can attain in civil services except cabinet secretary) and there are numerous deputation opportunities in IDAS,IPATFS,IRAS etc.......work profile is quite varied....for example in IDAS you are accounting Army,Air Force Navy,Ordnance factories, Drdo,MES etc. also you are concerned with internal auditing of every penny spent therein....you are also involved in high level defence purchases...you will rub shoulder with Who's and who of defence forces ..In my opinion group A services through CSE exam including Indian Forest Service are way way above than all other services except CIVIL ENGINEERING RAILWAY/CPWD,top posts of state civil services and to some extent Indian Economic Service.

    1. Absolutely wrong. Very few deputation opportunities.
    2. Lol.. All have accounting profile tau. How is it varied.

    But yes Group A better.
    We are here comparing it with APFC.

    Deputation opportunity
    Apfc = 0
    These services = 1
    Is it lot brother? :D
    Deputation
    Apfc=0
    IDAS=more than 25 at SAG level...while APFC has only 3-4 total posts at SAG level leave alone deputation....LOL

    Check this civil list
    https://www.google.co.in/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=http://cgda.nic.in/pdf/pink.pdf&ved=0ahUKEwiT_Zf30YHUAhWIKo8KHSzACYUQFggqMAE&usg=AFQjCNFx0SgDOf7KNjYhmZW3f2nAcRiNFQ&sig2=IrZGec92UlhvGnvUglxucA

    @okie
    Symbolic kuch hota hai :D
  • okie said:

    mimansa said:

    okie said:

    mimansa said:

    okie said:

    mimansa said:

    What is the difference in work profile?Which is better one and why?

    Apfc is way way below these posts....even AFHQ civil service is better than APFC.....highest grade pay you can attain in EPFO is 10000 and there are only 3 or 4 posts in that grade pay....while in said civil services everyone will attain 10000 grade pay and there are numerous higher post in HAG grade in these services. ....in IDAS there are two apex scale post (highest anyone can attain in civil services except cabinet secretary) and there are numerous deputation opportunities in IDAS,IPATFS,IRAS etc.......work profile is quite varied....for example in IDAS you are accounting Army,Air Force Navy,Ordnance factories, Drdo,MES etc. also you are concerned with internal auditing of every penny spent therein....you are also involved in high level defence purchases...you will rub shoulder with Who's and who of defence forces ..In my opinion group A services through CSE exam including Indian Forest Service are way way above than all other services except CIVIL ENGINEERING RAILWAY/CPWD,top posts of state civil services and to some extent Indian Economic Service.

    1. Absolutely wrong. Very few deputation opportunities.
    2. Lol.. All have accounting profile tau. How is it varied.

    But yes Group A better.
    We are here comparing it with APFC.

    Deputation opportunity
    Apfc = 0
    These services = 1
    Is it lot brother? :D
    Deputation
    Apfc=0
    IDAS=more than 25 at SAG level...while APFC has only 3-4 total posts at SAG level leave alone deputation....LOL

    Check this civil list
    https://www.google.co.in/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=http://cgda.nic.in/pdf/pink.pdf&ved=0ahUKEwiT_Zf30YHUAhWIKo8KHSzACYUQFggqMAE&usg=AFQjCNFx0SgDOf7KNjYhmZW3f2nAcRiNFQ&sig2=IrZGec92UlhvGnvUglxucA

    @okie
    Symbolic kuch hota hai :D
    Sorry....I did not get you....kya Symbolic @okie

  • mimansa said:

    okie said:

    mimansa said:

    okie said:

    mimansa said:

    okie said:

    mimansa said:

    What is the difference in work profile?Which is better one and why?

    Apfc is way way below these posts....even AFHQ civil service is better than APFC.....highest grade pay you can attain in EPFO is 10000 and there are only 3 or 4 posts in that grade pay....while in said civil services everyone will attain 10000 grade pay and there are numerous higher post in HAG grade in these services. ....in IDAS there are two apex scale post (highest anyone can attain in civil services except cabinet secretary) and there are numerous deputation opportunities in IDAS,IPATFS,IRAS etc.......work profile is quite varied....for example in IDAS you are accounting Army,Air Force Navy,Ordnance factories, Drdo,MES etc. also you are concerned with internal auditing of every penny spent therein....you are also involved in high level defence purchases...you will rub shoulder with Who's and who of defence forces ..In my opinion group A services through CSE exam including Indian Forest Service are way way above than all other services except CIVIL ENGINEERING RAILWAY/CPWD,top posts of state civil services and to some extent Indian Economic Service.

    1. Absolutely wrong. Very few deputation opportunities.
    2. Lol.. All have accounting profile tau. How is it varied.

    But yes Group A better.
    We are here comparing it with APFC.

    Deputation opportunity
    Apfc = 0
    These services = 1
    Is it lot brother? :D
    Deputation
    Apfc=0
    IDAS=more than 25 at SAG level...while APFC has only 3-4 total posts at SAG level leave alone deputation....LOL

    Check this civil list
    https://www.google.co.in/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=http://cgda.nic.in/pdf/pink.pdf&ved=0ahUKEwiT_Zf30YHUAhWIKo8KHSzACYUQFggqMAE&usg=AFQjCNFx0SgDOf7KNjYhmZW3f2nAcRiNFQ&sig2=IrZGec92UlhvGnvUglxucA

    @okie
    Symbolic kuch hota hai :D
    Sorry....I did not get you....kya Symbolic @okie

    Okie is already IRAS so he might be knowing
Sign In or Join to comment.

Courses by ForumIAS for CSE
ForumIAS is trusted by over 10,000+ students for their Prelims, Mains and Interview Preparation and we currently run several assistance programs to help students from Civil Services prelims preparation to rank upgradation to IAS. You can enroll for these programs by visiting http://blog.forumias.com/courses

Welcome!

We are a secret self-moderated community for Civil Services preparation. Feel free to join, start a discussion, answer a question or just to say Thank you.

Just dont spread the word ;)

Sign in or join with Facebook or Google

Subscribe to ForumIAS Blog