INTERVIEW FOR CSE 2019
All ForumIAS members selected for CSE 2019 Personality Test must submit their details and DAF and register below to receive further instructions and guidance from ForumIAS. Click here to register now
INTERVIEW 2020 CHANNEL
ForumIAS Channel for Interview Preparation is now Active! Please join the channel by clicking here
We are hiring!

Public Administration 2015 question discussion

245

Comments

  • Guess few takers 4 this thread-so no use 2 proceed.waise@zoly-heady had given 4 paradigms-tht may b the answer-i didn't attmpt that ques
  • Arre nahi man bhai continue.. There are few silent observers.. :)
  • But it ill b a monotonic 1 way conversation if others Dont contribute.
  • Bhai log koi to answer discussion initiate karo-esp stalwarts like @deusAdeeb, @mango_dolly, @Nuralain
    Busy with training bhai. Also, I agree with Nuru madam. The more I dissect the paper, the more depressed I become.
  • People write answers in an exam a with different mind set. I for same can't reproduce here what I actually wrote in exam. Someone mentions one more thinker here and peeple will start doubting their own answers.hence better to wait for results and then discus.
  • For Waldo Question approached as below

    Intro as to why his ideas were in conflict with classical beliefs.
    Then topics to explain
    1. Politics-Admin dichotomy: Waldo was against it unlike the Oldies.
    2. Public-Private Admin Dichotomy: Waldo says Public Admin is different from Pvt as it has to uphold Constitutional values and public interest. He attacked the generic nature as propounded by Henry Fayol and others.
    3. Waldo was sceptical as regard to the reality of Universal theory of Public Administration which the very aim of Classical Theorists through their principles.

    Thus through above ideas Waldo shook some of the foundations of classical beliefs.
  • edited January 2016
    Bhai log koi to answer discussion initiate karo-esp stalwarts like @deusAdeeb, @mango_dolly, @Nuralain
    Sorry.. but I am not dissecting all answers till mains results. Scared :-/.
    You second best decision, Ma'am ! :)
  • Sab vacation ke mood main hain
  • @Happy_Singh
    For Waldo Question approached as below

    Intro as to why his ideas were in conflict with classical beliefs.
    Then topics to explain
    1. Politics-Admin dichotomy: Waldo was against it unlike the Oldies.
    2. Public-Private Admin Dichotomy: Waldo says Public Admin is different from Pvt as it has to uphold Constitutional values and public interest. He attacked the generic nature as propounded by Henry Fayol and others.
    3. Waldo was sceptical as regard to the reality of Universal theory of Public Administration which the very aim of Classical Theorists through their principles.

    Thus through above ideas Waldo shook some of the foundations of classical beliefs.

    Same..
    Just that would add in point 3 that Waldo challenged non - normative and value neutrality concepts of classical thinkers..
  • Next question please
Sign In or Join to comment.

Welcome!

We are a secret self-moderated community for Civil Services preparation. Feel free to join, start a discussion, answer a question or just to say Thank you.

Just dont spread the word ;)

Sign in or join with Facebook or Google