INTERVIEW FOR CSE 2019
All ForumIAS members selected for CSE 2019 Personality Test must submit their details and DAF and register below to receive further instructions and guidance from ForumIAS. Click here to register now
INTERVIEW 2020 CHANNEL
ForumIAS Channel for Interview Preparation is now Active! Please join the channel by clicking here
We are hiring!

FINAL CALL TO BOARD CSE-2016, 2017 & 2018: JOIN US FROM 8th March till 16th March

1235712

Comments

  • Not sure why Gov would listen to the argument to award 3 extra attempt for introducing CSAT way back in 2011. I guess extra attempt is awarded for such and also what I remember is that CSAT change was given heads up during Aug/Sep 2010. Issue here shpuld be abruptly changing the marking format by making CSAT qualifing in nature AND PREPARING MERIT LIST OUT OF 20 MARKS ONLY. This though not a major change puts lots of aspirant in jeopardy as they did not get sufficient time to refine their strategy for prelims and lead to major set back. Prelims is all about first cross the line and thus cumulative marks out of 400 is reduced by 50% which actually alters the whole equation here. An extra attempt demand should be for such injustice with aspirants in 2015 instead of reinventing the issue with 2011 CSAT introduction.
  • I strongly have a feeling that age attempt relaxation for 2016 will be removed, as rightly put by @prasadsaatvik in another thread, which was immediately closed. Relaxation was put for 2 years i.e.2014.2015 hence cannot expect to be continued in 2016.
    Sanjeev bhai.....with all due respect to your opinion....I have reasons to differ from you.A number of people have spoken about this issue to Mr T.Jacob Sir,DOPT.I too have spoken abour this issue to T.Jacob sir....4 months back and 4 days ago to under secretary,DOPT....he told me that the present age limit is 32 for gen and future changes are incumbent on Baswan Committee report.It is in public knowledge that the concerned committee has got 6 month extension and CSE 2016 notification is due on 23rd April,2016.Under these conditions it is not possible to have any changes atleast for 2016 unless Baswan committee submits its report prior to 23rd April,2016 and the recommendations are accepted by the government.Last year itself when there was news item about changes in age in the Hindu paper...a statement was issued by Hon Min DOPT and he categorically said that.."there is no proposal before the govt at present about age change"
    @AhamBrahmasmi
    Thanks for your patient explanation for the otherwise. It helps to calm down nerves


    Just to add to the information provided, the committee, after 6 months extention will submit report by 11th August 2016 ( given in pdf file on the committee details, UPSC website). So nothing adverse happening this year atleast, in my opinion.
  • Status of protest
  • @Amit Jain . jo log yahan protest kar rahe hai, unke age/attempt khatam ho gaye isliye unhe consequential relaxation chaiye. par jo first attempt wale hai wo kyun aayenge protest mein? injustice toh 2015 prelims mein hua hai jisme csat 3 months pehle hatakar first attempt wale candidates bahar ho gaye. unki baat koi nahi kar raha hai. sab apna self interest dekh rahe hai, jisko jo suit kar raha hai uske liye protest kar rahe hai. at least on my side, i will only participate in the protest if above issues raised by you are concerning me but they are not. you are saying of injustice, but you all wrere notified 10 months before csat 2011 and try not to shift blame on others. UPSC holds national level competitions and you will have to abide by their rules if you want to participate in this game. I am not saying that csat was catering to/ favourable to needs of all candidates but completely removing csat and making it qualifying was also not justified without any proper time frame. If you really want participation from my side/ first timers, then please forward these 2 demands:-
    1. csat weightage(at least 20%) in prelims
    2. extra attempt for 2015 candidates with age relaxation
    BTW i know that my first demand will not be considered since you all protested for complete removal of csat, but if there is some space left to accomodate these demands do let me know
  • kitne b protests krlo ,kch ni hone wala..likh k lelo
  • @Amit Jain . jo log yahan protest kar rahe hai, unke age/attempt khatam ho gaye isliye unhe consequential relaxation chaiye. par jo first attempt wale hai wo kyun aayenge protest mein? injustice toh 2015 prelims mein hua hai jisme csat 3 months pehle hatakar first attempt wale candidates bahar ho gaye. unki baat koi nahi kar raha hai. sab apna self interest dekh rahe hai, jisko jo suit kar raha hai uske liye protest kar rahe hai. at least on my side, i will only participate in the protest if above issues raised by you are concerning me but they are not. you are saying of injustice, but you all wrere notified 10 months before csat 2011 and try not to shift blame on others. UPSC holds national level competitions and you will have to abide by their rules if you want to participate in this game. I am not saying that csat was catering to/ favourable to needs of all candidates but completely removing csat and making it qualifying was also not justified without any proper time frame. If you really want participation from my side/ first timers, then please forward these 2 demands:-
    1. csat weightage(at least 20%) in prelims
    2. extra attempt for 2015 candidates with age relaxation
    BTW i know that my first demand will not be considered since you all protested for complete removal of csat, but if there is some space left to accomodate these demands do let me know
    Your first demand is out of preview my friend as CSAT has been made qualifying.As far as your second demand is concerned,we have that on our agenda and the same has been communicated to the govt for its consideration.

    So,my friend,do not be on side line and do join the people on ground.Attempts,if granted,shall be given to all.Hitting the ground running will give us those attempts and nothing else.Pls come out with all the friends who are aggrieved like you.
  • @Amit Jain ok fine. No hard feeling but continue with your protest on your own as me and my friends are not concerned with age/attempt demand
  • Khud me spine nahi hai 6 attempt me bhi kuch karne ki and
  • Apj quotes-every youth wants to b unique but d world arnd u wants to make u like anybody else.

    Dear protestors,dose want or need more attempts-apne talnt ko pachanye dosto,Upsc ne apko rejct kia hai zindagi ne nahi.uthiye aur ek naya sapna dekhiye.sabit kijiye khud ko kisi aur field me,is har ko apna ego issue banaye aur naye field me kisi se v bhetar kar dekhye.
    UPSC India ki mahan parkisha hai usme safal hone wale v highly competitive hain.but uske chakkar me zindagi ko nirash na kijiye,use apse dhero umeede hain.atb :)
    Ps-mera bakwas padhne ke liye thnks.i too faild in csm2015.so thoda khud ko motivate kia aur apko v.
  • Apj quotes-every youth wants to b unique but d world arnd u wants to make u like anybody else.

    Dear protestors,dose want or need more attempts-apne talnt ko pachanye dosto,Upsc ne apko rejct kia hai zindagi ne nahi.uthiye aur ek naya sapna dekhiye.sabit kijiye khud ko kisi aur field me,is har ko apna ego issue banaye aur naye field me kisi se v bhetar kar dekhye.
    UPSC India ki mahan parkisha hai usme safal hone wale v highly competitive hain.but uske chakkar me zindagi ko nirash na kijiye,use apse dhero umeede hain.atb :)
    Ps-mera bakwas padhne ke liye thnks.i too faild in csm2015.so thoda khud ko motivate kia aur apko v.
This discussion has been closed.

Welcome!

We are a secret self-moderated community for Civil Services preparation. Feel free to join, start a discussion, answer a question or just to say Thank you.

Just dont spread the word ;)

Sign in or join with Facebook or Google