‘Microbial toxins found in popular e-cigarettes’ In a first, NASA probe detects ‘marsquake’ on the Red Planet HC lifts ban on TikTok, but with a caveat IEPF Authority in a major success recovers Rs 1514 Cr of Depositors Money Madras High Court bats for extending legal abortion period upto 24 weeks
Trend Analysis of UPSC CSE Prelims From 2011-18 | Read Here→

ForumIAS Academy Student Minal from Delhi University's St. Stephens Secures Rank 35 - First Batch of ForumIAS Foundation Program Click here to download her copies and notes
IMPORTANT: ForumIAS Discuss is now LIVE. You can visit it at discuss.forumias.com

We are hiring!

[Official] ForumIAS Simulator Open Test - Paper Discussion & Share your Marks & Scores

edited March 17 in Test Series
Hello All,
Appeared for the Test just now. Have some doubts , please help out with two questions

Selection of CBI Director is done by whom? Is it done under Lokpal Act?

Second,

Relationship between equality and justice?
a) There can be justice without equality
b) no equality without justice
c) equality n justice are antithetical
d) absolute equality does away with the need for justice.

I have marked d as it sounds most approporaite to me.

This Discussion has been made Official Discussion Thread and Title Changed.
Prelims - 3 | Mains - 2 | Interview - 1
«13

Comments

  • VivekJ2 said:

    Hello All,
    Appeared for the Test just now. Have some doubts , please help out with two questions

    Selection of CBI Director is done by whom? Is it done under Lokpal Act?

    Second,

    Relationship between equality and justice?
    a) There can be justice without equality
    b) no equality without justice
    c) equality n justice are antithetical
    d) absolute equality does away with the need for justice.

    I have marked d as it sounds most approporaite to me.

    This Discussion has been made Official Discussion Thread and Title Changed.

    Selection of CBI director through selection committee but I don't think it's under Lokpal act

    No equality without justice as art 13 ( rule of law ) is followed by art 14 ( right to equality)
    Hence rule of law is a precondition for equality
  • sss123 said:

    VivekJ2 said:

    Hello All,
    Appeared for the Test just now. Have some doubts , please help out with two questions

    Selection of CBI Director is done by whom? Is it done under Lokpal Act?

    Second,

    Relationship between equality and justice?
    a) There can be justice without equality
    b) no equality without justice
    c) equality n justice are antithetical
    d) absolute equality does away with the need for justice.

    I have marked d as it sounds most approporaite to me.

    This Discussion has been made Official Discussion Thread and Title Changed.

    Selection of CBI director through selection committee but I don't think it's under Lokpal act

    No equality without justice as art 13 ( rule of law ) is followed by art 14 ( right to equality)
    Hence rule of law is a precondition for equality
    you wrote the test?

    i also thought no equality without justice. but then just think, can we have a society where there is

    justice but not equality?
    equality but no justice?
    Prelims - 3 | Mains - 2 | Interview - 1
  • @yashwardhan_singh @carrie Can share some light / views on the second questions?
    Prelims - 3 | Mains - 2 | Interview - 1
  • VivekJ2 said:

    Hello All,
    Appeared for the Test just now. Have some doubts , please help out with two questions

    Selection of CBI Director is done by whom? Is it done under Lokpal Act?

    Second,

    Relationship between equality and justice?
    a) There can be justice without equality
    b) no equality without justice
    c) equality n justice are antithetical
    d) absolute equality does away with the need for justice.

    I have marked d as it sounds most approporaite to me.

    This Discussion has been made Official Discussion Thread and Title Changed.

    Appointment of director by selection committee constituting PM, CJI (Judge nominated by CJI) and Leader of opposition in LS and yes its under Lokpal act before lokpal act appointment was under DSPE act
  • VivekJ2 said:

    sss123 said:

    VivekJ2 said:

    Hello All,
    Appeared for the Test just now. Have some doubts , please help out with two questions

    Selection of CBI Director is done by whom? Is it done under Lokpal Act?

    Second,

    Relationship between equality and justice?
    a) There can be justice without equality
    b) no equality without justice
    c) equality n justice are antithetical
    d) absolute equality does away with the need for justice.

    I have marked d as it sounds most approporaite to me.

    This Discussion has been made Official Discussion Thread and Title Changed.

    Selection of CBI director through selection committee but I don't think it's under Lokpal act

    No equality without justice as art 13 ( rule of law ) is followed by art 14 ( right to equality)
    Hence rule of law is a precondition for equality
    you wrote the test?

    i also thought no equality without justice. but then just think, can we have a society where there is

    justice but not equality?
    equality but no justice?
    Yes we can have justice but not equality as a just system would allow for equals to be treated as equals and unequals as unequals

    Also we can have enforced equality but not justice. In nature we don’t have equality but there is inherent justice .
    Do not inbox meh |
  • VivekJ2 said:

    sss123 said:

    VivekJ2 said:

    Hello All,
    Appeared for the Test just now. Have some doubts , please help out with two questions

    Selection of CBI Director is done by whom? Is it done under Lokpal Act?

    Second,

    Relationship between equality and justice?
    a) There can be justice without equality
    b) no equality without justice
    c) equality n justice are antithetical
    d) absolute equality does away with the need for justice.

    I have marked d as it sounds most approporaite to me.

    This Discussion has been made Official Discussion Thread and Title Changed.

    Selection of CBI director through selection committee but I don't think it's under Lokpal act

    No equality without justice as art 13 ( rule of law ) is followed by art 14 ( right to equality)
    Hence rule of law is a precondition for equality
    you wrote the test?

    i also thought no equality without justice. but then just think, can we have a society where there is

    justice but not equality?
    equality but no justice?
    Nope, I haven't appeared for this test

    1. Justice but no equality - it means only upper class people can get justice and twist judiciary in their own way.
    2. Equality can be ensured in typical communist type societies but justice can never prevail in those societies as we all know what type of punishments/sentences are rewarded in China
  • edited March 17
    sss123 said:

    VivekJ2 said:

    sss123 said:

    VivekJ2 said:

    Hello All,
    Appeared for the Test just now. Have some doubts , please help out with two questions

    Selection of CBI Director is done by whom? Is it done under Lokpal Act?

    Second,

    Relationship between equality and justice?
    a) There can be justice without equality
    b) no equality without justice
    c) equality n justice are antithetical
    d) absolute equality does away with the need for justice.

    I have marked d as it sounds most approporaite to me.

    This Discussion has been made Official Discussion Thread and Title Changed.

    Selection of CBI director through selection committee but I don't think it's under Lokpal act

    No equality without justice as art 13 ( rule of law ) is followed by art 14 ( right to equality)
    Hence rule of law is a precondition for equality
    you wrote the test?

    i also thought no equality without justice. but then just think, can we have a society where there is

    justice but not equality?
    equality but no justice?
    Nope, I haven't appeared for this test

    1. Justice but no equality - it means only upper class people can get justice and twist judiciary in their own way.
    2. Equality can be ensured
    in typical communist type societies but justice can never prevail in those societies as we all know what type of punishments/sentences are rewarded in China
    If preamble is any clue then justice then answer should be "no equality without justice" i.e. option (b).

    Justice but no equality is no justice at all.

    Why derive definition of justice based on experience in China?? That is no justice at all.

    Justice has a biggere meaning encompassing equality and China's system should be tested based on the definition of justice rather than other way around.
    When life gives you lemons, make lemonade :)
  • sss123 said:

    VivekJ2 said:

    sss123 said:

    VivekJ2 said:

    Hello All,
    Appeared for the Test just now. Have some doubts , please help out with two questions

    Selection of CBI Director is done by whom? Is it done under Lokpal Act?

    Second,

    Relationship between equality and justice?
    a) There can be justice without equality
    b) no equality without justice
    c) equality n justice are antithetical
    d) absolute equality does away with the need for justice.

    I have marked d as it sounds most approporaite to me.

    This Discussion has been made Official Discussion Thread and Title Changed.

    Selection of CBI director through selection committee but I don't think it's under Lokpal act

    No equality without justice as art 13 ( rule of law ) is followed by art 14 ( right to equality)
    Hence rule of law is a precondition for equality
    you wrote the test?

    i also thought no equality without justice. but then just think, can we have a society where there is

    justice but not equality?
    equality but no justice?
    Nope, I haven't appeared for this test

    1. Justice but no equality - it means only upper class people can get justice and twist judiciary in their own way.
    2. Equality can be ensured
    in typical communist type societies but justice can never prevail in those societies as we all know what type of punishments/sentences are rewarded in China
    If preamble is any clue then justice then answer should be "no equality without justice" i.e. option (b).

    Justice but no equality is no justice at all.

    Why derive definition of justice based on experience in China?? That is no justice at all.

    Justice has a biggere meaning encompassing equality and China's sister should be tested based on the definition of justice rather than other way around.
    Actually there is no justice in China but they justify giving absurd and out of context punishment to their officials :mrgreen:
    They have created illusion of justice as their friend North Korea's illusion of democratic elections
  • VivekJ2 said:

    Hello All,
    Appeared for the Test just now. Have some doubts , please help out with two questions

    Selection of CBI Director is done by whom? Is it done under Lokpal Act?

    Second,

    Relationship between equality and justice?
    a) There can be justice without equality
    b) no equality without justice
    c) equality n justice are antithetical
    d) absolute equality does away with the need for justice.

    I have marked d as it sounds most approporaite to me.

    This Discussion has been made Official Discussion Thread and Title Changed.

    Yes it's done under Lokpal act , by 3 member committee...PM+CJI(or its nominee) + LOO....it was all over news due to sacking of Alok Verma.

    :)
  • sss123 said:

    sss123 said:

    VivekJ2 said:

    sss123 said:

    VivekJ2 said:

    Hello All,
    Appeared for the Test just now. Have some doubts , please help out with two questions

    Selection of CBI Director is done by whom? Is it done under Lokpal Act?

    Second,

    Relationship between equality and justice?
    a) There can be justice without equality
    b) no equality without justice
    c) equality n justice are antithetical
    d) absolute equality does away with the need for justice.

    I have marked d as it sounds most approporaite to me.

    This Discussion has been made Official Discussion Thread and Title Changed.

    Selection of CBI director through selection committee but I don't think it's under Lokpal act

    No equality without justice as art 13 ( rule of law ) is followed by art 14 ( right to equality)
    Hence rule of law is a precondition for equality
    you wrote the test?

    i also thought no equality without justice. but then just think, can we have a society where there is

    justice but not equality?
    equality but no justice?
    Nope, I haven't appeared for this test

    1. Justice but no equality - it means only upper class people can get justice and twist judiciary in their own way.
    2. Equality can be ensured
    in typical communist type societies but justice can never prevail in those societies as we all know what type of punishments/sentences are rewarded in China
    If preamble is any clue then justice then answer should be "no equality without justice" i.e. option (b).

    Justice but no equality is no justice at all.

    Why derive definition of justice based on experience in China?? That is no justice at all.

    Justice has a biggere meaning encompassing equality and China's sister should be tested based on the definition of justice rather than other way around.
    Actually there is no justice in China but they justify giving absurd and out of context punishment to their officials :mrgreen:
    They have created illusion of justice as their friend North Korea's illusion of democratic elections
    Agreed.. China delivers justice in the same manner in which they work against terrorists in unsc..
    When life gives you lemons, make lemonade :)
  • I have registered..but where is link to take the test?
  • I have registered..but where is link to take the test?

    Academy
  • I marked D in Justice vs Equality question.
  • Whats the average attempt?
  • is the test online on the portal?
  • is the test online on the portal?

    5 PM
  • Online test portal website down!!!
  • shubh04 said:

    Online test portal website down!!!

    Check again
    ForumIAS Techy
  • Scores?
  • sss123 said:

    sss123 said:

    VivekJ2 said:

    sss123 said:

    VivekJ2 said:

    Hello All,
    Appeared for the Test just now. Have some doubts , please help out with two questions

    Selection of CBI Director is done by whom? Is it done under Lokpal Act?

    Second,

    Relationship between equality and justice?
    a) There can be justice without equality
    b) no equality without justice
    c) equality n justice are antithetical
    d) absolute equality does away with the need for justice.

    I have marked d as it sounds most approporaite to me.

    This Discussion has been made Official Discussion Thread and Title Changed.

    Selection of CBI director through selection committee but I don't think it's under Lokpal act

    No equality without justice as art 13 ( rule of law ) is followed by art 14 ( right to equality)
    Hence rule of law is a precondition for equality
    you wrote the test?

    i also thought no equality without justice. but then just think, can we have a society where there is

    justice but not equality?
    equality but no justice?
    Nope, I haven't appeared for this test

    1. Justice but no equality - it means only upper class people can get justice and twist judiciary in their own way.
    2. Equality can be ensured
    in typical communist type societies but justice can never prevail in those societies as we all know what type of punishments/sentences are rewarded in China
    If preamble is any clue then justice then answer should be "no equality without justice" i.e. option (b).

    Justice but no equality is no justice at all.

    Why derive definition of justice based on experience in China?? That is no justice at all.

    Justice has a biggere meaning encompassing equality and China's sister should be tested based on the definition of justice rather than other way around.
    Actually there is no justice in China but they justify giving absurd and out of context punishment to their officials :mrgreen:
    They have created illusion of justice as their friend North Korea's illusion of democratic elections
    there can be justice without equality, for ex in law minors and adults are treated differently but that doesn't mean its unjust. or take IPC provisions like on adultery that were not gender neutral but still justice was served :neutral:
    for me any extreme statement is a no no, so I'll go with A
  • edited March 17
    Score-84/200

  • Where is the answer key? Plz upload
  • monty001 said:

    Scores?

    Yours?
  • Only 94

    Do u have answer key plz upload or send me the link
  • Nope. I attempted it online
  • VivekJ2 said:

    Hello All,
    Appeared for the Test just now. Have some doubts , please help out with two questions

    Selection of CBI Director is done by whom? Is it done under Lokpal Act?

    Second,

    Relationship between equality and justice?
    a) There can be justice without equality
    b) no equality without justice
    c) equality n justice are antithetical
    d) absolute equality does away with the need for justice.

    I have marked d as it sounds most approporaite to me.

    This Discussion has been made Official Discussion Thread and Title Changed.

    Answer key plz
  • Only 94

    Do u have answer key plz upload or send me the link
    Ans key on 19th
Sign In or Join to comment.
Success Stories from Our IFoS Toppers
Naveen Reddy(AIR-1) | Read His Story
Arushi Mishra(AIR-2) | Read Her Story
Chirag Jain(AIR-10) | Watch His Interview
Kshitij Saxena(AIR-22) | Watch His Interview

Welcome!

We are a secret self-moderated community for Civil Services preparation. Feel free to join, start a discussion, answer a question or just to say Thank you.

Just dont spread the word ;)

Sign in or join with Facebook or Google