Ranklist & Marks ! Offline Test Takers of ForumIAS Simulator Test 0
Click here to view score and results
We are hiring!
Visit http://go.forumias.com/changetheworld to apply now!
Click here for online test   All India Open Simulator Test 2019, Online test will be active upto 18th March, 8 PM today.

गरीब सवर्णों को 10% आरक्षण: सही नीयत या फिर अगले चुनाव में संभावित हार की आशंका से लिया गया फैसला?

«13456716

Comments

  • Desperate attempt to balance SC-ST amendment blunder.
  • How is 8 lakh limit is decided for a pensioner?
    What all documents have to be produced for income proof.
    Some are saying last 3 ulyear ITR. Any obc NCL candidate please throw light.
  • Another jumla ..it will only get quashed by SC.
  • Haha ...thank God our forefathers were wise enough to gift us institutions like Supreme Court ...Else these Politicians would have destroyed the nation ...
  • Yeh lo.. jo 50% seat bacha tha reservation mein se usmein se bhi 10% gya.. aise hi itna madamari tha ab aur..

    Seeing this decision, seat may increase significantly in 2019 in civils.. aa gyi hai uut pahad ke niche B)
  • Satta admi ko pagal kar deti hai. :D :D :D
  • Only one who can quash this decision is sc. No political party has guts to oppose this
    36 ka aankda with upsc
  • Just wait for modiji fans to say i'll vote for him no matter what
  • Simmu said:

    Haha ...thank God our forefathers were wise enough to gift us institutions like Supreme Court ...Else these Politicians would have destroyed the nation ...

    Are you an anglo Indian?
  • AutoGlobe said:

    Yeh lo.. jo 50% seat bacha tha reservation mein se usmein se bhi 10% gya.. aise hi itna madamari tha ab aur..

    Seeing this decision, seat may increase significantly in 2019 in civils.. aa gyi hai uut pahad ke niche B)

    Yup...seats were 1300+ in 2014 and 778 in 2018...they wont come below 500 for sure.

    And people say prelims has become a game of luck.
  • edited January 7
    won't matter for there is intense cometition in the 'upper caste' with less than 8 lpa income group. The real issue is of giving value to the principle of merit. And by the way this move is not for upper caste but is caste-neutral, religion-neutral economic backwardness category. Would have mattered if 30-40% would have been marked out. Right now it's just political signalling. So if you don't manage to get any certification for qualifying income you are most probably not losing anything for there is nothing to be gained.
    Empowered ur ego, enhanced ur desire - u'll die without living.

    U need to empower your intelligence, and enhance ur competence. Do something to the best of ur ability, and get fulfillment, joy, life.
  • Either abolish all qoutas or don't cry when a son of a poor Brahmin gets some benefit.
    You are laboratory project , owned by some handful elites. They test their utopian ideas on you.
  • edited January 7

    won't matter for there is intense cometition in the 'upper caste' with less than 8 lpa income group. The real issue is of giving value to the principle of merit. And by the way this move is not for upper caste but is caste-neutral, religion-neutral economic backwardness category. Would have mattered if 30-40% would have been marked out. Right now it's just political signalling. So if you don't manage to get any certification for qualifying income you are most probably not losing anything for there is nothing to be gained.

    Or if they had carved this 10% out of the 27% OBC category that would have had strong effect, but could also have been poilitically suicidal. So we have now this political lollipop. Inconsequential political signalling.
    Empowered ur ego, enhanced ur desire - u'll die without living.

    U need to empower your intelligence, and enhance ur competence. Do something to the best of ur ability, and get fulfillment, joy, life.
  • Either abolish all qoutas or don't cry when a son of a poor Brahmin gets some benefit.

    Bhai kisiko koi benefit nhi milega.. benefit k naam pe votes milenge,baad main tai tai fish.
  • won't matter for there is intense cometition in the 'upper caste' with less than 8 lpa income group. The real issue is of giving value to the principle of merit. And by the way this move is not for upper caste but is caste-neutral, religion-neutral economic backwardness category. Would have mattered if 30-40% would have been marked out. Right now it's just political signalling. So if you don't manage to get any certification for qualifying income you are most probably not losing anything for there is nothing to be gained.

    Rightly said.
    People are not reading the signal correctly and are misled by the fact that Savarna are going to get the reservation. The truth is after OC, EWS and then SC/ST/OBC lists will be compiled.
  • Either abolish all qoutas or don't cry when a son of a poor Brahmin gets some benefit.

    Son/daughter/others of all all caste are welcome in this group. This reservation isn't for savarna samaaj as is wrongly advertised by paid media.
  • Seats kam hoti ja rahi h but reservation increase hota ja raha h :trollface:
  • Waah modi ji waah :trollface:
  • Koi solid work kisi bhi government ko nahi karna h jisase employment generate ho ya increase ho.
    Bus elections pe kuch na kuch halke kaam ya naare phenkne h.
    Are bhai jab govenrment me vacancy hi nahi rahegi toh reservation de kar koun sa significant change aa jayega.
  • edited January 7

    won't matter for there is intense cometition in the 'upper caste' with less than 8 lpa income group. The real issue is of giving value to the principle of merit. And by the way this move is not for upper caste but is caste-neutral, religion-neutral economic backwardness category. Would have mattered if

  • This is just to divert attention from the inability of govt to create jobs.
  • Koi solid work kisi bhi government ko nahi karna h jisase employment generate ho ya increase ho.
    Bus elections pe kuch na kuch halke kaam ya naare phenkne h.
    Are bhai jab govenrment me vacancy hi nahi rahegi toh reservation de kar koun sa significant change aa jayega.

    Time aa gaya h ki pure reservation systm ka review hona chahiye.

    And reservation policy aisi honi chahiye jo present scenario ko address kare acche se.
    Saath me merit bhi compromise na ho.
  • BTW who do you people think will get benefit from this reservation? Or things will remain same due to high competition in upper caste ews category?
  • Koi solid work kisi bhi government ko nahi karna h jisase employment generate ho ya increase ho.
    Bus elections pe kuch na kuch halke kaam ya naare phenkne h.
    Are bhai jab govenrment me vacancy hi nahi rahegi toh reservation de kar koun sa significant change aa jayega.

    Time aa gaya h ki pure reservation systm ka review hona chahiye.

    And reservation policy aisi honi chahiye jo present scenario ko address kare acche se.
    Saath me merit bhi compromise na ho.
    Iski ummeed to surf sc se hi kar sakte ho..koi party itti himmat nhi karegi.
  • won't matter for there is intense cometition in the 'upper caste' with less than 8 lpa income group. The real issue is of giving value to the principle of merit. And by the way this move is not for upper caste but is caste-neutral, religion-neutral economic backwardness category. Would have mattered if 30-40% would have been marked out. Right now it's just political signalling. So if you don't manage to get any certification for qualifying income you are most probably not losing anything for there is nothing to be gained.

    Or if they had carved this 10% out of the 27% OBC category that would have had strong effect, but could also have been poilitically suicidal. So we have now this political lollipop. Inconsequential political signalling.
    but it won't harm anyone at the same time. It's just signalling but nevertheless a development on reservation policy.hope OBC and 10% are merged down the line, and then reduced gradually together proppoing up the principle of merit.
    Empowered ur ego, enhanced ur desire - u'll die without living.

    U need to empower your intelligence, and enhance ur competence. Do something to the best of ur ability, and get fulfillment, joy, life.
  • edited January 7
    Btw cutoff for EWS will be higher than open category. Because all people other than sc/st/obc will come under this and there is just 10 % quota. 8 lacks pa is baseline. How many people have income more than 8 lacks ?
    You are laboratory project , owned by some handful elites. They test their utopian ideas on you.
  • neha231 said:

    BTW who do you people think will get benefit from this reservation? Or things will remain same due to high competition in upper caste ews category?

    if ews cutoff is to be prepared after OC then it may lower the cutoff by 1-2 marks at least as those clearing OC cutoff would be counted as general.
  • Btw cutoff for EWS will higher than open category. Because all people other than sc/st/obc will come under this and there is just 10 % quota. 8 lacks pa is baseline. How many people have income more than 8 lacks ?

    People from SC St won't come under this 10%. This is for non reserved class.
  • won't matter for there is intense cometition in the 'upper caste' with less than 8 lpa income group. The real issue is of giving value to the principle of merit. And by the way this move is not for upper caste but is caste-neutral, religion-neutral economic backwardness category. Would have mattered if 30-40% would have been marked out. Right now it's just political signalling. So if you don't manage to get any certification for qualifying income you are most probably not losing anything for there is nothing to be gained.

    Or if they had carved this 10% out of the 27% OBC category that would have had strong effect, but could also have been poilitically suicidal. So we have now this political lollipop. Inconsequential political signalling.
    but it won't harm anyone at the same time. It's just signalling but nevertheless a development on reservation policy.hope OBC and 10% are merged down the line, and then reduced gradually together proppoing up the principle of merit.
    I think cutoff will depend on how many people apply under this ews category..we can't guess it for now.
  • neha231 said:

    won't matter for there is intense cometition in the 'upper caste' with less than 8 lpa income group. The real issue is of giving value to the principle of merit. And by the way this move is not for upper caste but is caste-neutral, religion-neutral economic backwardness category. Would have mattered if 30-40% would have been marked out. Right now it's just political signalling. So if you don't manage to get any certification for qualifying income you are most probably not losing anything for there is nothing to be gained.

    Or if they had carved this 10% out of the 27% OBC category that would have had strong effect, but could also have been poilitically suicidal. So we have now this political lollipop. Inconsequential political signalling.
    but it won't harm anyone at the same time. It's just signalling but nevertheless a development on reservation policy.hope OBC and 10% are merged down the line, and then reduced gradually together proppoing up the principle of merit.
    I think cutoff will depend on how many people apply under this ews category..we can't guess it for now.
    cutoff has to be less than general that's the whole point of reservations; otherwise how can you call them backward if they score above general lol
Sign In or Join to comment.

Subscribe to ForumIAS Blog

Welcome!

We are a secret self-moderated community for Civil Services preparation. Feel free to join, start a discussion, answer a question or just to say Thank you.

Just dont spread the word ;)

Sign in or join with Facebook or Google