CSE 2014 Break-up of Marks of Selected Candidates (Making Spreadsheet)

2456713

Comments

  • soch raha hun marathi hi le loon..kitne din mein ho jayega?
  • Had h Marathi literature ki, total chudiyapa marking h, saalo ka Marathi literature ki vajah se hi selection ho gya hoga, idhar hum apna tohfa abhi bhi Upsc ko qabool karwa rhe h
  • its conspiracy man
  • edited January 2016
    karan_004 said:

    JohnSnow said:

    karan_004 said:

    The irony is not only in Optional Regional Literature subject, with my two UPSC interview experiences, I can say even in Interview so many fishy & biased things are happened that True Aspirants are totally helpless....................

    Bhai interview me to bahut gadbad hai..if u have contacts u can land 200 eaasily
    Can you substantiate it? I have seen people with very good contacts failing miserably in interview.
    Bhai i know personally kne guy who is pathetic but knows shivraj singh(cm of mp) and got 200 odd marks.. He was boasting before result itself he will get 208 and he got that only
    if some members of the board knows him personally, then only he can be so sure and boast! Seems nepotism is there in interview board!
    Our survival instinct is our single greatest source of inspiration. - Dr. Mann
  • Look at thease marks in marathi literature...
    Rank 422...190+165 (355)
    Rank 470....183+174(357) :/

    How is it possibled ?

    In literature 190 in a paper, it is impossible................
    tichi maila....khairat bat rahi thi kya?
  • Rank 470 , GS2--56,GS3--68,GS4--64,interview--146..................These mean lack of knowledge in Politics,ethics,economics, still IAS ?

    UPSC ke no. dene se intelligency ka andaza nahi lagta.... yadi aisa hai to there are engineers from IIT who got very less marks in maths or in their subjects. does it mean ki unka IIT me selection luck se hua tha ??
  • jal said:

    Look at thease marks in marathi literature...
    Rank 422...190+165 (355)
    Rank 470....183+174(357) :/

    How is it possibled ?

    In literature 190 in a paper, it is impossible................
    tichi maila....khairat bat rahi thi kya?
    Pls aisa mat boliye..mae v itna hi xpect kr raha hu
  • edited January 2016

    Rank 470 , GS2--56,GS3--68,GS4--64,interview--146..................These mean lack of knowledge in Politics,ethics,economics, still IAS ?

    UPSC ke no. dene se intelligency ka andaza nahi lagta.... yadi aisa hai to there are engineers from IIT who got very less marks in maths or in their subjects. does it mean ki unka IIT me selection luck se hua tha ??
    I know it friend but the case is different here, your all scores can't be down like that. It is true that in a paper one or two you may get less marks due to some anomalies even i faced earlier that does'n mean all papers are down scored.

    If you see the particular candidate marks, it emphasizes that his selection totally based on Literature............My query was on that.................

  • jal said:

    Look at thease marks in marathi literature...
    Rank 422...190+165 (355)
    Rank 470....183+174(357) :/

    How is it possibled ?

    In literature 190 in a paper, it is impossible................
    tichi maila....khairat bat rahi thi kya?
    I did't make out your language. My pardon..................
  • jal said:

    Look at thease marks in marathi literature...
    Rank 422...190+165 (355)
    Rank 470....183+174(357) :/

    How is it possibled ?

    In literature 190 in a paper, it is impossible................
    tichi maila....khairat bat rahi thi kya?
    I did't make out your language. My pardon..................
    I means -' tichi maila(a marathi abuse)...were being given in charity?'
  • Rank 470 , GS2--56,GS3--68,GS4--64,interview--146..................These mean lack of knowledge in Politics,ethics,economics, still IAS ?

    UPSC ke no. dene se intelligency ka andaza nahi lagta.... yadi aisa hai to there are engineers from IIT who got very less marks in maths or in their subjects. does it mean ki unka IIT me selection luck se hua tha ??
    Bhai gs me 263 aur maraathi me 357 isse kya arth nikala jaye.. Tumhi bata do...
    Yaha pub. Ad . me saala puri duniya ka knowledge le lo tab bhi 270 se aage nahi jaa paa rahe log jabki gs me 370-400 tak aa rahe unhi logo k..
    Ab rahi baat iitians aur math ki to bhai ye koi nahi kah raha ki unka math accha nahi hain..but no. kam aa rahe to kahi na kahi kuch kami to rah gayi hogi naa..
    No.to paper me likhne se milenge copy check karne waale ko ye to nahi pata hoga ki ye iit ka banda hain..aur upsc me math me bhi bhai ratna padta hain wahi question bhi repeat hote hai jitna practice karo utna jyada no..aur ye to sabko pata hai ki iitians is exam k liye bhi kitne din padte hain...(kuch ko chhodkar) ;)

  • jal said:

    jal said:

    Look at thease marks in marathi literature...
    Rank 422...190+165 (355)
    Rank 470....183+174(357) :/

    How is it possibled ?

    In literature 190 in a paper, it is impossible................
    tichi maila....khairat bat rahi thi kya?
    I did't make out your language. My pardon..................
    I means -' tichi maila(a marathi abuse)...were being given in charity?'

    If you pragmatic, then i think so..................................it can't be possible.May be charity

    Here in Pub Ad, Sociology, Management , Geology , etc people are struggling to get 140-150 marks in a paper at Maximum & Literature people are scoring 190/250 ,means 76%. It is not a 10 th standard or 12 th standard exam dude.

    Unless got-up case or Fault assessment not possible at all.................
  • jal said:

    jal said:

    Look at thease marks in marathi literature...
    Rank 422...190+165 (355)
    Rank 470....183+174(357) :/

    How is it possibled ?

    In literature 190 in a paper, it is impossible................
    tichi maila....khairat bat rahi thi kya?
    I did't make out your language. My pardon..................
    I means -' tichi maila(a marathi abuse)...were being given in charity?'

    If you pragmatic, then i think so..................................it can't be possible.May be charity

    Here in Pub Ad, Sociology, Management , Geology , etc people are struggling to get 140-150 marks in a paper at Maximum & Literature people are scoring 190/250 ,means 76%. It is not a 10 th standard or 12 th standard exam dude.

    Unless got-up case or Fault assessment not possible at all.................
    at my centre in mumbai..there were only 2 marathi lit candidates...that means not more than 7-8 at all combined centres...if 2 people get such high marks..this is a sure case of regional favoritism..similar was case with haritha v kumar....kaustubh diwegaonkar....they made it to list only because of regional favoritism
  • jal said:

    jal said:

    jal said:

    Look at thease marks in marathi literature...
    Rank 422...190+165 (355)
    Rank 470....183+174(357) :/

    How is it possibled ?

    In literature 190 in a paper, it is impossible................
    tichi maila....khairat bat rahi thi kya?
    I did't make out your language. My pardon..................
    I means -' tichi maila(a marathi abuse)...were being given in charity?'

    If you pragmatic, then i think so..................................it can't be possible.May be charity

    Here in Pub Ad, Sociology, Management , Geology , etc people are struggling to get 140-150 marks in a paper at Maximum & Literature people are scoring 190/250 ,means 76%. It is not a 10 th standard or 12 th standard exam dude.

    Unless got-up case or Fault assessment not possible at all.................
    at my centre in mumbai..there were only 2 marathi lit candidates...that means not more than 7-8 at all combined centres...if 2 people get such high marks..this is a sure case of regional favoritism..similar was case with haritha v kumar....kaustubh diwegaonkar....they made it to list only because of regional favoritism
    acha hai 7-8 hi hain bc yadi 200-300 hon tab toh ho gaya selection :/
  • one thing is sure that all insiders are not fake. i could remember that one of insider was telling last year that marathi lit. highest mark was 357 and it is.
  • edited January 2016
    Are nahi bhai har literature waale ki selection nahi hoti....Hamare yaha se kaafi log punjabi literature liye the lekin har kisi ke achhe marks nhi aaye though punjabi literature has also very high success rate after med.science....So we can say content really matters and not only regional fav. :)
    Zindagi me Mazein lena seekho,

    Waqt to tumhare Mazein leta hi rahega......
  • galti upsc ki hain na ki candidates ki. mujhe marathi aate acche se toh main bhi wo leke acche marks lata na ki gs k liye sir khapaata. har banda apne marks ka hi sochega. ye upsc ko sochna chahiye ki galat ho raha hain. yehi csat mein bhi hota tha. jab csat se marks aa rahe the toh gs mein raayta failaane se kuch nahi hota tha
    It is Job Hi Karwalo .. not Jo Bhi Karwalo.... mind it
  • Are nahi bhai har literature waale ki selection nahi hoti....Hamare yaha se kaafi log punjabi literature liye the lekin har kisi ke achhe marks nhi aaye though punjabi literature has also very high success rate after med.science....So we can say content really matters ant not only regional fav. :)

    it is not that every one gets good marks...strategy is to give some so high that they find their name in top 100....sale ye log to wo bhi nahi kar paye
  • Are nahi bhai har literature waale ki selection nahi hoti....Hamare yaha se kaafi log punjabi literature liye the lekin har kisi ke achhe marks nhi aaye though punjabi literature has also very high success rate after med.science....So we can say content really matters and not only regional fav. :)

    aap affect ;)
    Our survival instinct is our single greatest source of inspiration. - Dr. Mann
  • Rank 470 , GS2--56,GS3--68,GS4--64,interview--146..................These mean lack of knowledge in Politics,ethics,economics, still IAS ?

    UPSC ke no. dene se intelligency ka andaza nahi lagta.... yadi aisa hai to there are engineers from IIT who got very less marks in maths or in their subjects. does it mean ki unka IIT me selection luck se hua tha ??
    I know it friend but the case is different here, your all scores can't be down like that. It is true that in a paper one or two you may get less marks due to some anomalies even i faced earlier that does'n mean all papers are down scored.

    If you see the particular candidate marks, it emphasizes that his selection totally based on Literature............My query was on that.................

    sahi baat hai ... ek subject ka highest hi 265 aur doosre ka 365 ... to 100 number ka difference to yahin ho gaya ....
  • jal said:

    jal said:

    jal said:

    Look at thease marks in marathi literature...
    Rank 422...190+165 (355)
    Rank 470....183+174(357) :/

    How is it possibled ?

    In literature 190 in a paper, it is impossible................
    tichi maila....khairat bat rahi thi kya?
    I did't make out your language. My pardon..................
    I means -' tichi maila(a marathi abuse)...were being given in charity?'

    If you pragmatic, then i think so..................................it can't be possible.May be charity

    Here in Pub Ad, Sociology, Management , Geology , etc people are struggling to get 140-150 marks in a paper at Maximum & Literature people are scoring 190/250 ,means 76%. It is not a 10 th standard or 12 th standard exam dude.

    Unless got-up case or Fault assessment not possible at all.................
    at my centre in mumbai..there were only 2 marathi lit candidates...that means not more than 7-8 at all combined centres...if 2 people get such high marks..this is a sure case of regional favoritism..similar was case with haritha v kumar....kaustubh diwegaonkar....they made it to list only because of regional favoritism
    Bhai haritha kumar had scored very high in all the subjects not only Malayalam. Her economics optional marks were all India highest
  • jal said:

    jal said:

    jal said:

    Look at thease marks in marathi literature...
    Rank 422...190+165 (355)
    Rank 470....183+174(357) :/

    How is it possibled ?

    In literature 190 in a paper, it is impossible................
    tichi maila....khairat bat rahi thi kya?
    I did't make out your language. My pardon..................
    I means -' tichi maila(a marathi abuse)...were being given in charity?'

    If you pragmatic, then i think so..................................it can't be possible.May be charity

    Here in Pub Ad, Sociology, Management , Geology , etc people are struggling to get 140-150 marks in a paper at Maximum & Literature people are scoring 190/250 ,means 76%. It is not a 10 th standard or 12 th standard exam dude.

    Unless got-up case or Fault assessment not possible at all.................
    at my centre in mumbai..there were only 2 marathi lit candidates...that means not more than 7-8 at all combined centres...if 2 people get such high marks..this is a sure case of regional favoritism..similar was case with haritha v kumar....kaustubh diwegaonkar....they made it to list only because of regional favoritism
    Bhai haritha kumar had scored very high in all the subjects not only Malayalam. Her economics optional marks were all India highest
    my apologies...but she secured rank 1 due to lit effect
  • Rank 470 , GS2--56,GS3--68,GS4--64,interview--146..................These mean lack of knowledge in Politics,ethics,economics, still IAS ?

    UPSC ke no. dene se intelligency ka andaza nahi lagta.... yadi aisa hai to there are engineers from IIT who got very less marks in maths or in their subjects. does it mean ki unka IIT me selection luck se hua tha ??
    I know it friend but the case is different here, your all scores can't be down like that. It is true that in a paper one or two you may get less marks due to some anomalies even i faced earlier that does'n mean all papers are down scored.

    If you see the particular candidate marks, it emphasizes that his selection totally based on Literature............My query was on that.................

    sahi baat hai ... ek subject ka highest hi 265 aur doosre ka 365 ... to 100 number ka difference to yahin ho gaya ....
    ye aap galat comparison kar rahe hain. upsc ko kya pata 1 student ka paper-1 aur paper-2 ki copy kaun si hai.
    better indicator paper wise highest dekhiye.
    maximum subject ke 1 paper ka highest 180s me aur dusra 160s me hai.
    lit me 1 hi bande ko 2no paper me highest ya kam aata hai kyonki 1 hi skill check hoti hai.
    arts paper me nahi lagta bc marks lottery se deta hai :/
  • Rank 470 , GS2--56,GS3--68,GS4--64,interview--146..................These mean lack of knowledge in Politics,ethics,economics, still IAS ?

    What do you mean by lack of knowledge , he cleared exam thats important what ever may be the optional and u should know that scoring that many marks is not easy and he must be an expert in that subject

  • Cant download the pdf.....

    If some1 has already downloaded the pdf frm persmin website....send it on meritlist13@gmail.com

    I shall make the excel and upload.
  • Rank 470 , GS2--56,GS3--68,GS4--64,interview--146..................These mean lack of knowledge in Politics,ethics,economics, still IAS ?

    What do you mean by lack of knowledge , he cleared exam thats important what ever may be the optional and u should know that scoring that many marks is not easy and he must be an expert in that subject

    Don't take it personal...................... I don't have any problem what optional he took. Problem is on so much deviation in marks.................between Optional & others..................

    It is not college exams where we used get marks by any means.......... 76% in Literature is impossible...........

  • edited January 2016
    Kaahe ko maahol grma rhe ho dosto..Baswan dada ki committee bethi h na..wo sochegi in sb pe ..pd lo kaam ayega..data analysis agr krni h to Sirf Apni kro..jisko lgta h literature m marks ate h leke dekh lo vehm dur hojega..u hv 1 year ahead !!!..discrimination appears when u fail..when u succeed it either converts into Your Luck or Your EXTRA ordinary Hard Work..onlyyy 1 thing u cn..Read More Write More Pray More and Improve More.. gud nyttt..

    Btw m too Pub Ad Victim..so sry if anything conflicts with ur train of thoughts brothers/sis ;)
    Being IAS... 4 U Onlyyy... :-)


    " Woods are lovely dark and deep..
    But I have promises to keep..
    But I have promises to keep..
    And miles to go before I sleep.. before I sleep. " :)

    #HumHongeKamyaabEkDin :)
  • edited January 2016

    Rank 470 , GS2--56,GS3--68,GS4--64,interview--146..................These mean lack of knowledge in Politics,ethics,economics, still IAS ?

    What do you mean by lack of knowledge , he cleared exam thats important what ever may be the optional and u should know that scoring that many marks is not easy and he must be an expert in that subject

    @vijaydinanathchauhan that is the point brother that EXPERTS of pub ad, sociology ,history , geo dont get that much marks...Now this discussion is part of trail of grievances...other optionals envy Geography which got bumper scucess rate in top 100 last year...makkan paper and makkan checking... Non Lit optionals envy Lit optionals...I belong to history and last two years had been very bad for us..only 2-3 guys in top 100

  • Rank 470 , GS2--56,GS3--68,GS4--64,interview--146..................These mean lack of knowledge in Politics,ethics,economics, still IAS ?

    What do you mean by lack of knowledge , he cleared exam thats important what ever may be the optional and u should know that scoring that many marks is not easy and he must be an expert in that subject

    Don't take it personal...................... I don't have any problem what optional he took. Problem is on so much deviation in marks.................between Optional & others..................

    It is not college exams where we used get marks by any means.......... 76% in Literature is impossible...........

    Difference in marks may be that people with other might not be that well prepared and everything is possible
  • edited January 2016

    Rank 470 , GS2--56,GS3--68,GS4--64,interview--146..................These mean lack of knowledge in Politics,ethics,economics, still IAS ?

    What do you mean by lack of knowledge , he cleared exam thats important what ever may be the optional and u should know that scoring that many marks is not easy and he must be an expert in that subject

    Don't take it personal...................... I don't have any problem what optional he took. Problem is on so much deviation in marks.................between Optional & others..................

    It is not college exams where we used get marks by any means.......... 76% in Literature is impossible...........

    Difference in marks may be that people with other might not be that well prepared and everything is possible
    @vijaydinanathchauhan Dont overestaimate urself and underestimate others..Had this exam been a 2-3 month affair..people would have cleared this doubt of yours too BY Switching their Optional to Literature....

    That is Why there is cry for removing optionals
Sign In or Join to comment.

Welcome!

We are a secret self-moderated community for Civil Services preparation. Feel free to join, start a discussion, answer a question or just to say Thank you.

Just dont spread the word ;)

Sign in or join with Facebook or Google

Subscribe to ForumIAS Blog