ForumIAS New Batch Announcement 

MGP Batch C: (Starts 25th January, Ends 17th September)       PLAN DOCUMENT        PAYMENT LINK 
MGP + Batch C: (Starts 25th January, Ends 17th September)    PLAN DOCUMENT        PAYMENT LINK 
MGP Batch C (Rapid): (Starts 25th Jan, Ends 19th Apr)              PLAN DOCUMENT        PAYMENT LINK 

Post your Interview Transcripts: CSE 2017, Indian forest service-2017

edited February 13 in Interview Preparation
Please post your transcripts in the following format:

Interview date
Interview board
Background
Employment and work-ex (if applicable)
Domicile
Hobbies
Questions

continuing @DrKingSchultz previous year initiative
If possible please make this thread as announcement.
Thank You

Comments

  • Please announce this thread. @DrKingSchultz @Yo_Yo_Choti_Singh and any other moderators.
  • Please announce this thread
  • Rango said:

    Please post your transcripts in the following format:

    Interview date
    Interview board
    Background
    Employment and work-ex (if applicable)
    Domicile
    Hobbies
    Questions

    continuing @DrKingSchultz previous year initiative
    If possible please make this thread as announcement.
    Thank You

    ALSO mention "attempt number(overall-mains-interview-selection)" so that we can put @DrKingSchuItz theory of 1st timers having sub-quota to the test.

    we can also guess if the calling order was completely random or something else(this is far fetched but mains marks could also be a possibility)
  • edited February 19
    55 candidates interviewed and no transcripts yet??
  • @PTT2018

    Telegram channel link for Interview Transcripts 2018 :)
    Being IAS... 4 U Onlyyy... :-)
  • mneutron:
    Rammy:


    Interview started around 3-10,
    Bhosle sir board... Was first candidate in the morning

    Wished the board...they asked me to. Sit... Even in. Beginning say Said no. Need to. Keep hands crossed or anything sit comfortably on chair by putting hands over arm support. There was also few sheets of pages in a transparent folder he asked to think for few sec n even write on page then give good answers also he will only ask simple questions.

    Now chairman
    Q1Then he saw I graduated in 2013 so which year mbbs entry.. What u did after that...some praise etc in between
    Q2 do u feel as u have rural background n working in village that govt policy wrt rural is good if any lacuna where.

    Chairman did asked few questions on end on dog n medical


    Member 1

    Q1 ur doing good working in village but doctors don't want to go why n how to change that.
    Q2 provision of nmc.. Is less representation of Dr a issue
    Q3 what abut compulsory internship after mbbs
    Q4 ayush Dr being allowed to practice allopathic.. Good or bad.


    Ek. Doh aur yaad nahi

    Member 2

    Q1 so many places named as Sagar in rajasthan why
    Q2 what is intergenerational equity... Follow up what's meaning of equity here... Also. How's equity makes sense in medical profession /health
    Q3 some old ancient river of rajasthan
    Q4 Himalayan blunder... Cudnt understand but chairman also had knocked pencil as sign to move on.



    Member 4 lady member

    Question 1

    She said she is baised to health so. Why after mbbs ias...
    Q2 issues of women n child in rajasthan n solutions
    Q3


    Member 4
    Asked abut city of school ajmer... Famous king of ajmer... Why famous... How he died.. Any role of sanyogata on his defeat.

    Q2 padmavat situation is example of anomie.. Is it so.. What u mean by anomie which social thinker gave the concept

    Chairman again
    Q1 U have graduated from. Govt mbbs was ur education not subsidized... Wastage of resources etc
    Q2 advantages of being Dr... I said being emphatic so can't a no Dr have empathy..
    Q3 dog lover... Which breed... Why different breed behave differently
    Tell a joke on dog... Then he told a joke... End of interview...

    Missed few questions if I am able to recall will post...

    Overall very cordial n had better experience than mocks...

    Forwarded
  • Tom Billa:
    Bankesh Pawar
    Board- P K Joshi Sir
    Optional-Sociology


    Chairman-
    1. You have graduated in 2015,what have u been doing since then.
    2.What changes do u find between the cultures of Pune and Delhi
    3.Among Bhagat Singh,Sukhdev and Rajguru..who is from Pune.
    4.Your hobby is cartoon sketching....name some famous cartoonists of India.
    5.Name some famous sociologists from India.
    M1-
    1.what is a smart city.Tell me specific aspects
    2.which book have u read..tell me what part u enjoyed the most
    3.Technology has made people like us(aged) more dependable..do you think so...1- 2 more questions on it.

    M2-
    1.Have you heard of Julian asaange...he has recently written a book..tell the book name.
    2.What do think of aadhaar and privacy issue..is privacy possible in this interconnected world..even Google knows that I am sitting here.
    3.Tell me about rapid changes which have happened in pune in 2 decades and what are the reasons

    M4(lady)-
    1.This prohibition law....is it good or bad.

    2.Your hobby is cartoon sketching..there r instances when certain people are depicted in a derogatory way..what u think
    3.who is the father of sociology
    4.which has more profound impact on child's upbringing..family or school..and why.
    5.if father is a drunkard what impact will it have on the child..

    M5-
    1.what is the border issue with Karnataka and Maharashtra
    2.Why Western coastal states are more developed than eastern coastal states
    3.As a tourism secretary how will u promote Ajanta and Ellora.

    Chairman- Thank you your interview is over
  • Aditya VS:
    Kalaivanan:
    Kalaivanan:
    Sujetha metha mam board
    Chairman :
    1. So tell me about yourself ?
    2. Which year did you graduate?
    3. What has kept you busy these days?
    4. What do you do in your free time other than preparation?
    5. So your hobby is language learning ? How many languages do you know?
    6. Since your mother tongue is tamil , which language did you find easy to learn hindi or malayalam?
    7. What is your view on linguistic reorganisation of states?
    8. Should the present demands allowed?

    Member1:
    1. So your hobby is football why is india not able to win in olympics?
    2. If infrastructure is not there in rural areas how is north east performing well?
    3. If given a chance how will you change the name of your course electrical and electronics engineering?
    4. Do you know about moocs?
    5. How is it usefull?

    Member2:
    1. Is tamil derived from sanskrit?
    2. But many words like neer(tamil – water) is derived from sanskrit? What is your view? Learning hindi should be easy for you right?
    3. What is the difference between language and literature?
    4. Where does grammar fit in ? Language or literature?

    Member 3:
    1. Where was www found?
    2. Who founded it ?
    3. Name of the institution in Switzerland?
    4. Who founded binary no. ?
    5. Name of the indian mathematician who worked on it?
    6. Who wrote our national anthem?
    7. Which other country also follows the same?
    8. What is the name of it?

    Member 4:
    1. So tell me about vellore (my district)?
    2. Which one is important for vellore's glory? Revolt of 1806 or cmc hospital?
    3. So what is your view on cauvery?
    4. How should interstate river disputes solved?
    5. View on interstate river linking?

    Chairman:
    1. Environment issues on river linking?
    2. Our part is done . Do you feel anything left out in your draft?
    I mean for which you have prepared well and we have not asked ? :P
    3. (I told my project mam) so tell me what is your project?
    4. Why it is not implemented?
    Your interview is over. !





  • 20/8. Afternoon session. First to go

    Ch - Bhonsle sir
    -nice haircut! How often?
    -‎how did you get interested in astrophysics?
    -‎ who gave the theory of evolution and what was the name of the book
    M1
    What did you do to get this ambsaador of change award?
    Do you think you were successful?
    Why so?
    What is needed to bring the chaneg?
    Three changes that you will like to bring on district?
    M2
    - who said that we should leave the earth in 100 years? What could be the rationale? Do you subscribe to it?
    - ‎some wise man said that Venus was like earth before? Why did he say so?
    M3 (lady)
    -what do you like to cook?
    -‎how do you cook daal baati?
    -‎what were you doing in Chile?
    -‎what is last memoir you've read and what is your favorite memoir?
    -‎what do you like about it?
    M4
    - is police service or force?
    - ‎wb has WB police and WB police service? What's the difference?
    - ‎what is the perception of people about police?
    - ‎why is it so?
    - ‎what are the issues being faced by police?
    - ‎what will you do to address these?
    - ‎three challenges facing India?
    Ch
    - what should india do for women empowerment to bring them at the level they are in Singapore?
    - ‎have you seen dabang? What's the image of police it potrays? Is it correct?

  • Sujatha Mehta Board
    Optional - History
    Graduation - Civil Engineering
    District - Erode, TN

    CHAIRMAN
    1. Introduce yourselves
    2. What you have been doing after graduation?
    3. Why didnt you think of getting employed?
    4. What is your opinion on Cauvery verdict? Is it favourable to TamilNadu?
    5. What do you know about Adam's bridge? Is it really existing?
    6. Is all data from NASA trustable? Why Indians wonder about NASA?
    7. What is demographic dividend? Is it an advantage to have millions of unemployment youth in India?

    Member 1
    1. Specialities of QutbMinar?
    2. Temples in Kumbakonam?
    3. Who built most temples in your state?
    4. Trade relationship between Ancient India and south east Asia?
    5. What Coimbatore is famous for?
    6. Status of textile industries in last decade in India?

    Member 2
    1. Traffic problems in Salem?
    2. Causes of road accidents in T.N? Solutions?
    3. Advanced technologies to control accidents?
    4. What should be the role of the government to control accidents?
    5. What was your role in creating accident free cities during college days?

    Member 3
    1. Is Parking avenue are engineering solution?
    2. Why you are interested in railways?
    3. What is ballast less track? Status in India?
    4. Explain railway connectivity in Northeast? Especially Meghalaya?
    5. What is Smart city according to you?

    Member 4
    1. What is climate change? Do you believe in such Climate change theory?
    2. Why USA left Paris agreement?
    3. What is History? Definition?
    4. Why so much interpretations in Indian History?
    5. How chronology is arrived in historical writings?

    CHAIRMAN
    1. Why history is a scientific study?
    2. How science helps to understand TipuSultan history?
    3. Do you want to ask anything from us?
    4. Have we asked questions as you expected or anything different?

    Overall, cordial board with mostly opinion based questions.

  • Bassi Sir, 20 Feb 2018, AN
    Geo optional
    Works in a bank

    Chairman :
    1. Meditation (just mentioned this word - no question)
    2. You listen to music, why don't you sing?
    3. Internship at a, working at b what was nature of work?
    4. Could the bank fraud have been prevented? (I asked PNB? He said yes, gave answer)
    5. IT in service - applications - stress question as wanted me to speak for 2 minutes on this, he kept looking at wall clock. I couldn't see the clock.Kept telling me time left this much etc

    M1 :
    1. Situational question regarding being poll officer and violence in booth
    2. Creativity Vs efficiency

    M2 :
    1. Financial inclusion
    2. What schemes for financial inclusion
    3. What are startups?
    4. Some Indian startups
    5. Govt initiatives for startups
    6. What is GHG effect?

    M3 :
    1. What is green chemistry in pharmaceutical?
    2. What are virtual organisations?
    3. Relation between virtual organisation and venture capital
    4. Some question on oop programming (cse)
    5. Some more - can't remember.

    M4 :
    1. Npa issue
    2. Your suggestions for npa prevention
    3. Re-capitalisation of banks - impact on banks, on economy and need
    4. Should public money be used for re-capitalisation
    5. rural banking in india
    6. Should banks be part of secondary equity market in India?
    7. Most pressing problems in banking sector at present
    8. Banks that don't lend? Any example
    9. Creative accounting. What is it? Done in banks?
    10. Asked about some book. Didn't know about it.

    C :
    Showed my picture - covered face with thumb. Is it your picture?

    Your interview is over. Thank you.

    Stress test in beginning. Largely opinion based. "What do you think" in most questions
  • edited February 21
    Self representation is prohibited here..
    Replace YOUR from title with THEIR'S.. :smiley:
  • ajay000 said:


    20/8. Afternoon session. First to go

    Ch - Bhonsle sir
    -nice haircut! How often?
    -‎how did you get interested in astrophysics?
    -‎ who gave the theory of evolution and what was the name of the book
    M1
    What did you do to get this ambsaador of change award?
    Do you think you were successful?
    Why so?
    What is needed to bring the chaneg?
    Three changes that you will like to bring on district?
    M2
    - who said that we should leave the earth in 100 years? What could be the rationale? Do you subscribe to it?
    - ‎some wise man said that Venus was like earth before? Why did he say so?
    M3 (lady)
    -what do you like to cook?
    -‎how do you cook daal baati?
    -‎what were you doing in Chile?
    -‎what is last memoir you've read and what is your favorite memoir?
    -‎what do you like about it?
    M4
    - is police service or force?
    - ‎wb has WB police and WB police service? What's the difference?
    - ‎what is the perception of people about police?
    - ‎why is it so?
    - ‎what are the issues being faced by police?
    - ‎what will you do to address these?
    - ‎three challenges facing India?
    Ch
    - what should india do for women empowerment to bring them at the level they are in Singapore?
    - ‎have you seen dabang? What's the image of police it potrays? Is it correct?

    Can I get this person's whole interview with his answers? Sounds very interesting, especially the Chile part.
  • Current Affairs 2018 Click Here
  • ajay000 said:


    Sujatha Mehta Board
    Optional - History
    Graduation - Civil Engineering
    District - Erode, TN

    CHAIRMAN
    1. Introduce yourselves
    2. What you have been doing after graduation?
    3. Why didnt you think of getting employed?
    4. What is your opinion on Cauvery verdict? Is it favourable to TamilNadu?
    5. What do you know about Adam's bridge? Is it really existing?
    6. Is all data from NASA trustable? Why Indians wonder about NASA?
    7. What is demographic dividend? Is it an advantage to have millions of unemployment youth in India?

    Member 1
    1. Specialities of QutbMinar?
    2. Temples in Kumbakonam?
    3. Who built most temples in your state?
    4. Trade relationship between Ancient India and south east Asia?
    5. What Coimbatore is famous for?
    6. Status of textile industries in last decade in India?

    Member 2
    1. Traffic problems in Salem?
    2. Causes of road accidents in T.N? Solutions?
    3. Advanced technologies to control accidents?
    4. What should be the role of the government to control accidents?
    5. What was your role in creating accident free cities during college days?

    Member 3
    1. Is Parking avenue are engineering solution?
    2. Why you are interested in railways?
    3. What is ballast less track? Status in India?
    4. Explain railway connectivity in Northeast? Especially Meghalaya?
    5. What is Smart city according to you?

    Member 4
    1. What is climate change? Do you believe in such Climate change theory?
    2. Why USA left Paris agreement?
    3. What is History? Definition?
    4. Why so much interpretations in Indian History?
    5. How chronology is arrived in historical writings?

    CHAIRMAN
    1. Why history is a scientific study?
    2. How science helps to understand TipuSultan history?
    3. Do you want to ask anything from us?
    4. Have we asked questions as you expected or anything different?

    Overall, cordial board with mostly opinion based questions.

    ajay000 said:


    Sujatha Mehta Board
    Optional - History
    Graduation - Civil Engineering
    District - Erode, TN

    CHAIRMAN
    1. Introduce yourselves
    2. What you have been doing after graduation?
    3. Why didnt you think of getting employed?
    4. What is your opinion on Cauvery verdict? Is it favourable to TamilNadu?
    5. What do you know about Adam's bridge? Is it really existing?
    6. Is all data from NASA trustable? Why Indians wonder about NASA?
    7. What is demographic dividend? Is it an advantage to have millions of unemployment youth in India?

    Member 1
    1. Specialities of QutbMinar?
    2. Temples in Kumbakonam?
    3. Who built most temples in your state?
    4. Trade relationship between Ancient India and south east Asia?
    5. What Coimbatore is famous for?
    6. Status of textile industries in last decade in India?

    Member 2
    1. Traffic problems in Salem?
    2. Causes of road accidents in T.N? Solutions?
    3. Advanced technologies to control accidents?
    4. What should be the role of the government to control accidents?
    5. What was your role in creating accident free cities during college days?

    Member 3
    1. Is Parking avenue are engineering solution?
    2. Why you are interested in railways?
    3. What is ballast less track? Status in India?
    4. Explain railway connectivity in Northeast? Especially Meghalaya?
    5. What is Smart city according to you?

    Member 4
    1. What is climate change? Do you believe in such Climate change theory?
    2. Why USA left Paris agreement?
    3. What is History? Definition?
    4. Why so much interpretations in Indian History?
    5. How chronology is arrived in historical writings?

    CHAIRMAN
    1. Why history is a scientific study?
    2. How science helps to understand TipuSultan history?
    3. Do you want to ask anything from us?
    4. Have we asked questions as you expected or anything different?

    Overall, cordial board with mostly opinion based questions.

    any question from civil engineering.?
Sign In or Join to comment.

Courses by ForumIAS for CSE
ForumIAS is trusted by over 10,000+ students for their Prelims, Mains and Interview Preparation and we currently run several assistance programs to help students from Civil Services prelims preparation to rank upgradation to IAS. You can enroll for these programs by visiting http://blog.forumias.com/courses

Welcome!

We are a secret self-moderated community for Civil Services preparation. Feel free to join, start a discussion, answer a question or just to say Thank you.

Just dont spread the word ;)

Sign in or join with Facebook or Google

Subscribe to ForumIAS Blog