"I really don't think there is anything that is better structured and more interactive in regard to Mains than the ForumIAS Mains Guidance Program." - Mitali Sethi (IAS-2016, AIR-56)
MGP Schedule C - Admissions Open Now!
Click here to read more
*Limited Seats. First Come, First Serve basis only.
ForumIAS Mains Orientation Session on June 24 at 11 AM


ForumIAS will be conducting an Orientation Session for Mains 2017 on June 24 at 11AM. The agenda of the session will be to discuss (1) Mains Guidance Plan along with sources and time management techniques (2) Toppers Talk with Prajit Nair ( AIR 87 ) who will discuss his detailed strategy for Mains Preparation. The event is specially for MGP Students / MGP interested students / Mains Marathon Followers but can be attended by all. Click here to register ( Mandatory)

Note : A second Open to All Session will be conducted soon with MGP Student Mittali Sethi in the coming days.
MITRA'S IAS - Fresh batches of Philosophy : 25th June (Evening)-5:15PM - 7:15PM & 29th June (Morning)-11AM-1PM ; FREE SEMINAR ON 25TH JUNE, 5.15PM Subject To Availability Of Seats
For more information call us at - Tel. No :- 01145505509, Mob. No-8826469839, 9560928172 or
Mail us at :- mitrasiasclasses@gmail.com
, Website:- www.mitrasias.com
Download Topper's answer booklet: (1) Ravi Agarwal(Rank-94, 2016), (2) Vivek Kumar(Rank-200, 2016) (3) Athar Aamir 1st booklet and 2nd booklet(Rank-2)

Deputy Collector (SDM) in home state MP vs scale 2 officer (promoted from PO)

Dear friends​, I have some confusion regarding choice between scale 2 bank officer and Deputy Collector. I am in banking as branch manager but recently selected as deputy collector (SDM) in MP, that is my home state also. So, dear friends, considering all factors like home state, salary, authority, status, future prospects..etc etc pls suggest me better option between these two.
·
«13

Comments

  • Trolls Are getting funnier day by day :D
    if all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail.
    ·
  • @Ant_Man bhaisahab kuchh dikkat Hai to, na Karo reply. Seriously Bata sakte ho to batao.
    ·
  • @Ant_Man bhaisahab kuchh dikkat Hai to, na Karo reply. Seriously Bata sakte ho to batao.

    Its not even a close comparision, that's why i felt you were trolling.
    anyways SDM is million times better
    if all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail.
    ·
  • edited May 9
    @adthelegend

    Close your eyes and go for sdm..no comparison between these two as sdm is far far better
    ·
  • Go for SDM
    ·
  • edited May 9
    the day is not far when people will ask Daily Wage Laborer under MGNREGA vs SDM :wink:
    ·
  • Dear friends​, I have some confusion regarding choice between scale 2 bank officer and Deputy Collector. I am in banking as branch manager but recently selected as deputy collector (SDM) in MP, that is my home state also. So, dear friends, considering all factors like home state, salary, authority, status, future prospects..etc etc pls suggest me better option between these two.

    yar comparision to dhang ka karo..isme koi confusion hai hi nahi SDM mila hai wo bhi home state aur kya chahiye..
    PO is anytime like a private job only.
    Mehnat itni khamoshi se karo ki qamyabi shor macha de !!!
    ·
  • the day is not far when people will ask Daily Wage Laborer under MGNREGA vs SDM :wink:

    :mrgreen:
    An Ounce of Action Is Worth a Ton of Theory
    ·
  • Ant_Man said:

    Trolls Are getting funnier day by day :D

    agree
    Pre 2015- Fail
    Pre 2016- Fail
    CSIR Life Science NET- 18 June
    Road 2018 (Last Attempt)
    ·
  • the day is not far when people will ask Daily Wage Laborer under MGNREGA vs SDM :wink:

    hahahahaha.
    Pre 2015- Fail
    Pre 2016- Fail
    CSIR Life Science NET- 18 June
    Road 2018 (Last Attempt)
    ·
  • Sometimes low confidence and feeling of lack of self worth make low in life. Particularly, when reason is some other person. I, myself have given upsc civil service interviews and one forest service interview. Luckily, got selected as deputy collector. Still, prevailing personal conditions​ forcing me to compare between said posts.... starting late preparation can negatively compensate our dreams of higher life style, particularly when low grade job people start living their full life...

    So, dear friends nothing trolls n all....I wanted some genuine views to find motivating path of my life....


    All the best to all aspirants

    If possible then remember some good suggestion by AXIS bank CEO at IIM Ahmdabad convocation about life...
    ·
  • aise chaman bhi SDM ban jaate hain jo sale PO or SDM ki job compare na kar sake. Bhai gali main ghumne wale kisi rsikshey wale se bhi poochenga na woh bhi bata dega ki...SDM kya hota hai. Bhai kahi tu Vyapam ghotale ki upaj toh nahi hai ???
    ·
  • Sometimes low confidence and feeling of lack of self worth make low in life. Particularly, when reason is some other person. I, myself have given upsc civil service interviews and one forest service interview. Luckily, got selected as deputy collector. Still, prevailing personal conditions​ forcing me to compare between said posts.... starting late preparation can negatively compensate our dreams of higher life style, particularly when low grade job people start living their full life...

    So, dear friends nothing trolls n all....I wanted some genuine views to find motivating path of my life....


    All the best to all aspirants

    If possible then remember some good suggestion by AXIS bank CEO at IIM Ahmdabad convocation about life...

    Yaar ye ek kaam ki cheez to mili. Waise bhi neend aa rahi. B)
    Life is a crazy ride and nothing is guaranteed. Keeping expectations low and just trying to not disappoint people who look up to me.
    -Account ditched. Tudor be damned. Ha ha ha.
    youtu.be/0sFvFVkeGVg
    ·
  • Sometimes low confidence and feeling of lack of self worth make low in life. Particularly, when reason is some other person. I, myself have given upsc civil service interviews and one forest service interview. Luckily, got selected as deputy collector. Still, prevailing personal conditions​ forcing me to compare between said posts.... starting late preparation can negatively compensate our dreams of higher life style, particularly when low grade job people start living their full life...

    So, dear friends nothing trolls n all....I wanted some genuine views to find motivating path of my life....


    All the best to all aspirants

    If possible then remember some good suggestion by AXIS bank CEO at IIM Ahmdabad convocation about life...

    You may not be a troll, but you are on a website where most people have a common bias in favour of administrative jobs.


    In terms of comparison between an SDM and a bank PO, an SDM, gets immediate respect and decent administrative powers. Law & Order is a duty often assigned to SDMs, even if they are not holding the post of SDM, but as a magistrate with any portfolio in the district, be it rajasvya or transport.

    The job is much less armchair than bank PO.

    SDMs command high respect and value in the society and the job is the closes that you can imagine to the IAS ( provided you got the top rank and actually got SDM, and not some other department specific job like registrar etc. )

    The one advantage that bank POs may have over the SDM, may be in the very long run, is that career progression for SDMs stagnate, and unless promoted to IAS , they stay at the district level, retiring at the rank of ADM.


    Whereas POs in PSU can rise to the top level. The SDM rises very little in rank. In powers, it is almost a demotion. The SDM is an independent office and powerful. All other posts that you get are not independent and you will spend your career between SDM and ADM, who does not have real powers. The next independent office is DM, which you will not get if you do not get IAS.

    If you are serving in state Police via this exam, you are likely to be DSP at least for 15 years and maybe for life. You may not become an SP at all.

    Secondly, law and order is not an easy job or lucrative job. You don't get to do lathi charge and riot control at will . There is democracy. In real life situations, the DM may ask you as a magistrate to go for riot control and it will be on your orders that the police force will shoot a bullet.

    Remember that in real life situations, firing is a big thing. You are likely to abdicate responsibility because you would want to take the DM into confidence before ordering shooting or use of violence. The DMs, a large number of times stop picking up calls when situation goes out of control and there is need to kill people to control the mob.

    And if you are the one who gave shooting orders , there will be a magistratial probe, where your seniors may not be brave enough to write that situation warranted it. Most of the times, your seniors end up writing " The Office lacks decision making qualities and resorted to violence where mob control could have been done peacefully"

    In fact when even SPs order firing as last resort, and if the SP has not kept good terms with the DM, who will avoid giving orders for firing , even when the mob has taken control, sometimes end up writing "SP uses force when it can be avoided"

    Which is why you will see that most people in IAS boast that I can do everything what the IPS can do , plus more.

    Also, Unfortunately, in working, the power gap between you first posting and the last posting is negligible, making you feel that there is no growth at all.

    In fact , if you got the administrative service in the state and are actually made SDM in the first posting , which is also the first posting of IAS officers ( but they will quickly climb the succession to ADC/DDC , DM , Commissioner, Secy and Principal Secy ), further posting which are non- SDM, but in-charge of Land revenue, Land Acquisition, Agriculture, Nazarat, Treasury etc. are vastly different from an SDM's life.

    However, because the job is difficult, it has more prestige, and it enjoys respect in the society. If you enjoy hierarchy ( by which I mean, enjoy giving orders and taking orders ), you will love this job.

    If you are looking for a more 10-5 job, the PO is suitable. Again, SBI does make its POs work a lot. But career progression is good in Banking as of now.

    I have worked at District Level and I am aware of many SDMs who would give up their jobs to be Professors, who earn very very well, have a peaceful life, and get leaves when you need + spend festivals like Durga Pooja and Diwali with family, and not on some magisterial duty like the SDM.

    Not sure about anyone leaving SDMship to be a PO though.
    *No good deed goes unpunished*
    ·
  • I would rate SDM better than GM of Bank. I left scale 2 manager without any option in feb 17.
    ·
  • coolbuddy said:

    I would rate SDM better than GM of Bank. I left scale 2 manager without any option in feb 17.

    I would pick SDM over the CEO of Google India! :mrgreen:
    An Ounce of Action Is Worth a Ton of Theory
    ·
  • Neyawn said:

    Sometimes low confidence and feeling of lack of self worth make low in life. Particularly, when reason is some other person. I, myself have given upsc civil service interviews and one forest service interview. Luckily, got selected as deputy collector. Still, prevailing personal conditions​ forcing me to compare between said posts.... starting late preparation can negatively compensate our dreams of higher life style, particularly when low grade job people start living their full life...

    So, dear friends nothing trolls n all....I wanted some genuine views to find motivating path of my life....


    All the best to all aspirants

    If possible then remember some good suggestion by AXIS bank CEO at IIM Ahmdabad convocation about life...

    You may not be a troll, but you are on a website where most people have a common bias in favour of administrative jobs.


    In terms of comparison between an SDM and a bank PO, an SDM, gets immediate respect and decent administrative powers. Law & Order is a duty often assigned to SDMs, even if they are not holding the post of SDM, but as a magistrate with any portfolio in the district, be it rajasvya or transport.

    The job is much less armchair than bank PO.

    SDMs command high respect and value in the society and the job is the closes that you can imagine to the IAS ( provided you got the top rank and actually got SDM, and not some other department specific job like registrar etc. )

    The one advantage that bank POs may have over the SDM, may be in the very long run, is that career progression for SDMs stagnate, and unless promoted to IAS , they stay at the district level, retiring at the rank of ADM.


    Whereas POs in PSU can rise to the top level. The SDM rises very little in rank. In powers, it is almost a demotion. The SDM is an independent office and powerful. All other posts that you get are not independent and you will spend your career between SDM and ADM, who does not have real powers. The next independent office is DM, which you will not get if you do not get IAS.

    If you are serving in state Police via this exam, you are likely to be DSP at least for 15 years and maybe for life. You may not become an SP at all.

    Secondly, law and order is not an easy job or lucrative job. You don't get to do lathi charge and riot control at will . There is democracy. In real life situations, the DM may ask you as a magistrate to go for riot control and it will be on your orders that the police force will shoot a bullet.

    Remember that in real life situations, firing is a big thing. You are likely to abdicate responsibility because you would want to take the DM into confidence before ordering shooting or use of violence. The DMs, a large number of times stop picking up calls when situation goes out of control and there is need to kill people to control the mob.

    And if you are the one who gave shooting orders , there will be a magistratial probe, where your seniors may not be brave enough to write that situation warranted it. Most of the times, your seniors end up writing " The Office lacks decision making qualities and resorted to violence where mob control could have been done peacefully"

    In fact when even SPs order firing as last resort, and if the SP has not kept good terms with the DM, who will avoid giving orders for firing , even when the mob has taken control, sometimes end up writing "SP uses force when it can be avoided"

    Which is why you will see that most people in IAS boast that I can do everything what the IPS can do , plus more.

    Also, Unfortunately, in working, the power gap between you first posting and the last posting is negligible, making you feel that there is no growth at all.

    In fact , if you got the administrative service in the state and are actually made SDM in the first posting , which is also the first posting of IAS officers ( but they will quickly climb the succession to ADC/DDC , DM , Commissioner, Secy and Principal Secy ), further posting which are non- SDM, but in-charge of Land revenue, Land Acquisition, Agriculture, Nazarat, Treasury etc. are vastly different from an SDM's life.

    However, because the job is difficult, it has more prestige, and it enjoys respect in the society. If you enjoy hierarchy ( by which I mean, enjoy giving orders and taking orders ), you will love this job.

    If you are looking for a more 10-5 job, the PO is suitable. Again, SBI does make its POs work a lot. But career progression is good in Banking as of now.

    I have worked at District Level and I am aware of many SDMs who would give up their jobs to be Professors, who earn very very well, have a peaceful life, and get leaves when you need + spend festivals like Durga Pooja and Diwali with family, and not on some magisterial duty like the SDM.

    Not sure about anyone leaving SDMship to be a PO though.
    Mate, how did u write so many words??? :o
    I would have suffered a heart attack :mrgreen: But all things aside, nothing compares to Civils.... :)
    Civils rocks <3 o:) </b>
    An Ardent Civil services Aspirant, Bibliophile, Bodybuilder, Comics (Doga) Fan, Cook, Cynophile, Linguaphile, Nature Lover, Numismatist......

    ·
  • Neyawn said:

    Sometimes low confidence and feeling of lack of self worth make low in life. Particularly, when reason is some other person. I, myself have given upsc civil service interviews and one forest service interview. Luckily, got selected as deputy collector. Still, prevailing personal conditions​ forcing me to compare between said posts.... starting late preparation can negatively compensate our dreams of higher life style, particularly when low grade job people start living their full life...

    So, dear friends nothing trolls n all....I wanted some genuine views to find motivating path of my life....


    All the best to all aspirants

    If possible then remember some good suggestion by AXIS bank CEO at IIM Ahmdabad convocation about life...

    You may not be a troll, but you are on a website where most people have a common bias in favour of administrative jobs.


    In terms of comparison between an SDM and a bank PO, an SDM, gets immediate respect and decent administrative powers. Law & Order is a duty often assigned to SDMs, even if they are not holding the post of SDM, but as a magistrate with any portfolio in the district, be it rajasvya or transport.

    The job is much less armchair than bank PO.

    SDMs command high respect and value in the society and the job is the closes that you can imagine to the IAS ( provided you got the top rank and actually got SDM, and not some other department specific job like registrar etc. )

    The one advantage that bank POs may have over the SDM, may be in the very long run, is that career progression for SDMs stagnate, and unless promoted to IAS , they stay at the district level, retiring at the rank of ADM.


    Whereas POs in PSU can rise to the top level. The SDM rises very little in rank. In powers, it is almost a demotion. The SDM is an independent office and powerful. All other posts that you get are not independent and you will spend your career between SDM and ADM, who does not have real powers. The next independent office is DM, which you will not get if you do not get IAS.

    If you are serving in state Police via this exam, you are likely to be DSP at least for 15 years and maybe for life. You may not become an SP at all.

    Secondly, law and order is not an easy job or lucrative job. You don't get to do lathi charge and riot control at will . There is democracy. In real life situations, the DM may ask you as a magistrate to go for riot control and it will be on your orders that the police force will shoot a bullet.

    Remember that in real life situations, firing is a big thing. You are likely to abdicate responsibility because you would want to take the DM into confidence before ordering shooting or use of violence. The DMs, a large number of times stop picking up calls when situation goes out of control and there is need to kill people to control the mob.

    And if you are the one who gave shooting orders , there will be a magistratial probe, where your seniors may not be brave enough to write that situation warranted it. Most of the times, your seniors end up writing " The Office lacks decision making qualities and resorted to violence where mob control could have been done peacefully"

    In fact when even SPs order firing as last resort, and if the SP has not kept good terms with the DM, who will avoid giving orders for firing , even when the mob has taken control, sometimes end up writing "SP uses force when it can be avoided"

    Which is why you will see that most people in IAS boast that I can do everything what the IPS can do , plus more.

    Also, Unfortunately, in working, the power gap between you first posting and the last posting is negligible, making you feel that there is no growth at all.

    In fact , if you got the administrative service in the state and are actually made SDM in the first posting , which is also the first posting of IAS officers ( but they will quickly climb the succession to ADC/DDC , DM , Commissioner, Secy and Principal Secy ), further posting which are non- SDM, but in-charge of Land revenue, Land Acquisition, Agriculture, Nazarat, Treasury etc. are vastly different from an SDM's life.

    However, because the job is difficult, it has more prestige, and it enjoys respect in the society. If you enjoy hierarchy ( by which I mean, enjoy giving orders and taking orders ), you will love this job.

    If you are looking for a more 10-5 job, the PO is suitable. Again, SBI does make its POs work a lot. But career progression is good in Banking as of now.

    I have worked at District Level and I am aware of many SDMs who would give up their jobs to be Professors, who earn very very well, have a peaceful life, and get leaves when you need + spend festivals like Durga Pooja and Diwali with family, and not on some magisterial duty like the SDM.

    Not sure about anyone leaving SDMship to be a PO though.
    Perfect answer
    ·
  • coolbuddy said:

    I would rate SDM better than GM of Bank. I left scale 2 manager without any option in feb 17.

    I would pick SDM over the CEO of Google India! :mrgreen:
    I would even choose naib tehsildar over juckerbergua :mrgreen: :mrgreen:
    ·
  • I would pick sdm over modi
    ·
  • I would pick sdm over modi

    Any girl would :mrgreen:
    Life is a crazy ride and nothing is guaranteed. Keeping expectations low and just trying to not disappoint people who look up to me.
    -Account ditched. Tudor be damned. Ha ha ha.
    youtu.be/0sFvFVkeGVg
    ·
  • edited May 10

    Dear friends​, I have some confusion regarding choice between scale 2 bank officer and Deputy Collector. I am in banking as branch manager but recently selected as deputy collector (SDM) in MP, that is my home state also. So, dear friends, considering all factors like home state, salary, authority, status, future prospects..etc etc pls suggest me better option between these two.


    What is grade pay of Deputy Collector in your state???...... I am asking this because in some state rank of deputy Collector is not equivalent to SDM ..... In these states a officer equivelent to Naib Tehsildar with Grade Pay 4200.is called Deputy Collector.

    If your Deputy Collector is indeed SDM with Grade Pay 5400(Level 10 as per 7th CPC)...... Then with full politeness , I would say that your question is quite absurd. I am currently working as Custom Inspector(through SSC CGL) and in my department every year many PO of scale 2,3(whatever) are coming in droves that too most of them are from SBI.....

    So, There is no comparison of SDM and PO whatsoever..... Many people leave IPS,IRS for SDM in their home state...... So if deputy collector of your state is indeed SDM(grade pay 5400) then you should not ask this question any futher.....
    ·
  • Tudor said:

    I would pick sdm over modi

    Any girl would :mrgreen:
    Edjacktaly.. :mrgreen: ok bye
    ·
  • Neyawn said:

    Sometimes low confidence and feeling of lack of self worth make low in life. Particularly, when reason is some other person. I, myself have given upsc civil service interviews and one forest service interview. Luckily, got selected as deputy collector. Still, prevailing personal conditions​ forcing me to compare between said posts.... starting late preparation can negatively compensate our dreams of higher life style, particularly when low grade job people start living their full life...

    So, dear friends nothing trolls n all....I wanted some genuine views to find motivating path of my life....


    All the best to all aspirants

    If possible then remember some good suggestion by AXIS bank CEO at IIM Ahmdabad convocation about life...

    You may not be a troll, but you are on a website where most people have a common bias in favour of administrative jobs.


    In terms of comparison between an SDM and a bank PO, an SDM, gets immediate respect and decent administrative powers. Law & Order is a duty often assigned to SDMs, even if they are not holding the post of SDM, but as a magistrate with any portfolio in the district, be it rajasvya or transport.

    The job is much less armchair than bank PO.

    SDMs command high respect and value in the society and the job is the closes that you can imagine to the IAS ( provided you got the top rank and actually got SDM, and not some other department specific job like registrar etc. )

    The one advantage that bank POs may have over the SDM, may be in the very long run, is that career progression for SDMs stagnate, and unless promoted to IAS , they stay at the district level, retiring at the rank of ADM.


    Whereas POs in PSU can rise to the top level. The SDM rises very little in rank. In powers, it is almost a demotion. The SDM is an independent office and powerful. All other posts that you get are not independent and you will spend your career between SDM and ADM, who does not have real powers. The next independent office is DM, which you will not get if you do not get IAS.

    If you are serving in state Police via this exam, you are likely to be DSP at least for 15 years and maybe for life. You may not become an SP at all.

    Secondly, law and order is not an easy job or lucrative job. You don't get to do lathi charge and riot control at will . There is democracy. In real life situations, the DM may ask you as a magistrate to go for riot control and it will be on your orders that the police force will shoot a bullet.

    Remember that in real life situations, firing is a big thing. You are likely to abdicate responsibility because you would want to take the DM into confidence before ordering shooting or use of violence. The DMs, a large number of times stop picking up calls when situation goes out of control and there is need to kill people to control the mob.

    And if you are the one who gave shooting orders , there will be a magistratial probe, where your seniors may not be brave enough to write that situation warranted it. Most of the times, your seniors end up writing " The Office lacks decision making qualities and resorted to violence where mob control could have been done peacefully"

    In fact when even SPs order firing as last resort, and if the SP has not kept good terms with the DM, who will avoid giving orders for firing , even when the mob has taken control, sometimes end up writing "SP uses force when it can be avoided"

    Which is why you will see that most people in IAS boast that I can do everything what the IPS can do , plus more.

    Also, Unfortunately, in working, the power gap between you first posting and the last posting is negligible, making you feel that there is no growth at all.

    In fact , if you got the administrative service in the state and are actually made SDM in the first posting , which is also the first posting of IAS officers ( but they will quickly climb the succession to ADC/DDC , DM , Commissioner, Secy and Principal Secy ), further posting which are non- SDM, but in-charge of Land revenue, Land Acquisition, Agriculture, Nazarat, Treasury etc. are vastly different from an SDM's life.

    However, because the job is difficult, it has more prestige, and it enjoys respect in the society. If you enjoy hierarchy ( by which I mean, enjoy giving orders and taking orders ), you will love this job.

    If you are looking for a more 10-5 job, the PO is suitable. Again, SBI does make its POs work a lot. But career progression is good in Banking as of now.

    I have worked at District Level and I am aware of many SDMs who would give up their jobs to be Professors, who earn very very well, have a peaceful life, and get leaves when you need + spend festivals like Durga Pooja and Diwali with family, and not on some magisterial duty like the SDM.

    Not sure about anyone leaving SDMship to be a PO though.
    <3
    Life is a crazy ride and nothing is guaranteed. Keeping expectations low and just trying to not disappoint people who look up to me.
    -Account ditched. Tudor be damned. Ha ha ha.
    youtu.be/0sFvFVkeGVg
    ·
Sign In or Join to comment.

Welcome!

We are a secret self-moderated community for Civil Services preparation. Feel free to join, start a discussion, answer a question or just to say Thank you.

Just dont spread the word ;)

Sign in or join with Facebook or Google