Ramjas College controversy. What's your view?

145791014

Comments

  • He's asking for extra attempts like me :joy:
    किसका घोड़ा पैर घसीटा..किसका घोड़ा लल्लन टाप
  • edited March 1

    @freeman lol lge raho tum jaiso se kuch na ho payega

    tum se ka ho payega :D khud ko sab turram khan hi samajhte hain..tumhari bhi wahi prb hai
  • Hahahha wah rey freeman...bebaak tippaniyan ki tumney :D :D
    ...............................
  • Comment karne se pehle bataa detaa hoon ki mai Thakur hoon. General category ka hoon. So jo kehnaa hogaa keh lena.

    Lekin Freeman ne jo baat kahi h usse doosre angle se samjho. Usme kuchh dum hai.

    Kuchh selfish and super-chaalaak Brahman sahi me iss desh me sabhi ke saath kaand kar gaye hain.

    JL Nehru, MN Roy, Jyoti Basu, Mamta Banerjee, Sheila Dikshit, Anand Sharma, Satish Mishra (Mayawati ka daahina haath), Kapil Sibbal, Satish Deshpande (DU ka socio prof & bade wala pro-reservation thinker), Bipin Chandra, Satish Chandra, RS Sharma (Marxist Historian) etc . saare ke saare brahmin hi hain.

    Mai honestly kehtaa hoon ki yadi 'affirmitive action' ke keval Brahmin scholars bhi chup ho jaayein na, to ek saal me reservation streamline ho jaayega. Flat 30% reservation with creamy layer for SC/ST too.
    Similarly, yadi leftist ideology ke keval Brahmin scholars chup ho jaayein, virodh bhi naa karein sirf chup ho jaayein, saale kisi Kanhaiya, Khalid jaise tatpoonjiye ki aukaat nhi ki chun-chapad kar de.

    Ye conspiracy theory nhi hai. Baareeki se dekhoge to samajh jaaoge.
    Mai brahmins ko criticize bilkul nhi kar rha. Bass keh raha hoon ki kuchh super-shrewd brahmano ne apne faayde ko upar rakh rakhaa hai and desh ko neeche.
  • Aisaa nhi hai ki baaki Thakur, Rajput, Baniyon and Kayasthon me selfish bande nhi hote unme bhi hote hain.

    Meri baat ko khule dimaag se samajhnaa.
  • edited March 1
    ^^
    + Jayalalitha was also brahmin. Dalits of TN sweared by her!!

    I am a brahmin too >:)
    CSM 2015 | CSE 2016 - Ranked it Out!!
    Thank Lord Shiva...
  • Hahahha wah rey freeman...bebaak tippaniyan ki tumney :D :D

    :D
  • pks11630 said:

    Comment karne se pehle bataa detaa hoon ki mai Thakur hoon. General category ka hoon. So jo kehnaa hogaa keh lena.

    Lekin Freeman ne jo baat kahi h usse doosre angle se samjho. Usme kuchh dum hai.

    Kuchh selfish and super-chaalaak Brahman sahi me iss desh me sabhi ke saath kaand kar gaye hain.

    JL Nehru, MN Roy, Jyoti Basu, Mamta Banerjee, Sheila Dikshit, Anand Sharma, Satish Mishra (Mayawati ka daahina haath), Kapil Sibbal, Satish Deshpande (DU ka socio prof & bade wala pro-reservation thinker), Bipin Chandra, Satish Chandra, RS Sharma (Marxist Historian) etc . saare ke saare brahmin hi hain.

    Mai honestly kehtaa hoon ki yadi 'affirmitive action' ke keval Brahmin scholars bhi chup ho jaayein na, to ek saal me reservation streamline ho jaayega. Flat 30% reservation with creamy layer for SC/ST too.
    Similarly, yadi leftist ideology ke keval Brahmin scholars chup ho jaayein, virodh bhi naa karein sirf chup ho jaayein, saale kisi Kanhaiya, Khalid jaise tatpoonjiye ki aukaat nhi ki chun-chapad kar de.

    Ye conspiracy theory nhi hai. Baareeki se dekhoge to samajh jaaoge.
    Mai brahmins ko criticize bilkul nhi kar rha. Bass keh raha hoon ki kuchh super-shrewd brahmano ne apne faayde ko upar rakh rakhaa hai and desh ko neeche.

    is desh ka durbhagya brahmanon ne hi likha hai..lekin dheere dheere improvmnt ho raha..samay ke saath sare caste ek dusre me merge kar jayenge..den we will have a diffused society rather than a prismatic one...mujhe brahmon se koi prb nahi...par kuchh brahaman se prb hai..kyunki wo apni identity apni caste se relate karna nahi bhoolte...which is very cheap of them...baki sab ok hai...sab bhai hain apne.
  • edited March 1
    pks11630 said:

    Aisaa nhi hai ki baaki Thakur, Rajput, Baniyon and Kayasthon me selfish bande nhi hote unme bhi hote hain.

    Meri baat ko khule dimaag se samajhnaa.

    jaise vp singh aur arjun singh among thakurs
  • Kanpur rail derailment ke baad, ab ye thread derail ho chuki hai
    images(27).jpg
    545 x 562 - 29K
    An Ounce of Action Is Worth a Ton of Theory
  • Kanpur rail derailment ke baad, ab ye thread derail ho chuki hai

    new channel pe debate me jo panelists baithe hote hain wo poora topic hi derail kar dete hain....hum to fir bhi timepass kar rahe hain
  • freeman said:

    Kanpur rail derailment ke baad, ab ye thread derail ho chuki hai

    new channel pe debate me jo panelists baithe hote hain wo poora topic hi derail kar dete hain....hum to fir bhi timepass kar rahe hain
    Vai aap kahin @Ramaswamy toh nahi?
    An Ounce of Action Is Worth a Ton of Theory
  • Brahmin here and uchha Kulin Brahmin .was just wondering about the utpatti of thakurs

    :trollface:
    किसका घोड़ा पैर घसीटा..किसका घोड़ा लल्लन टाप
  • raar said:

    pks11630 said:

    Aisaa nhi hai ki baaki Thakur, Rajput, Baniyon and Kayasthon me selfish bande nhi hote unme bhi hote hain.

    Meri baat ko khule dimaag se samajhnaa.

    jaise vp singh aur arjun singh among thakurs
    Lolwa
    किसका घोड़ा पैर घसीटा..किसका घोड़ा लल्लन टाप
  • freeman said:

    pks11630 said:

    Comment karne se pehle bataa detaa hoon ki mai Thakur hoon. General category ka hoon. So jo kehnaa hogaa keh lena.

    Lekin Freeman ne jo baat kahi h usse doosre angle se samjho. Usme kuchh dum hai.

    Kuchh selfish and super-chaalaak Brahman sahi me iss desh me sabhi ke saath kaand kar gaye hain.

    JL Nehru, MN Roy, Jyoti Basu, Mamta Banerjee, Sheila Dikshit, Anand Sharma, Satish Mishra (Mayawati ka daahina haath), Kapil Sibbal, Satish Deshpande (DU ka socio prof & bade wala pro-reservation thinker), Bipin Chandra, Satish Chandra, RS Sharma (Marxist Historian) etc . saare ke saare brahmin hi hain.

    Mai honestly kehtaa hoon ki yadi 'affirmitive action' ke keval Brahmin scholars bhi chup ho jaayein na, to ek saal me reservation streamline ho jaayega. Flat 30% reservation with creamy layer for SC/ST too.
    Similarly, yadi leftist ideology ke keval Brahmin scholars chup ho jaayein, virodh bhi naa karein sirf chup ho jaayein, saale kisi Kanhaiya, Khalid jaise tatpoonjiye ki aukaat nhi ki chun-chapad kar de.

    Ye conspiracy theory nhi hai. Baareeki se dekhoge to samajh jaaoge.
    Mai brahmins ko criticize bilkul nhi kar rha. Bass keh raha hoon ki kuchh super-shrewd brahmano ne apne faayde ko upar rakh rakhaa hai and desh ko neeche.

    is desh ka durbhagya brahmanon ne hi likha hai..lekin dheere dheere improvmnt ho raha..samay ke saath sare caste ek dusre me merge kar jayenge..den we will have a diffused society rather than a prismatic one...mujhe brahmon se koi prb nahi...par kuchh brahaman se prb hai..kyunki wo apni identity apni caste se relate karna nahi bhoolte...which is very cheap of them...baki sab ok hai...sab bhai hain apne.
    Yaar, meri baat ko log galat samajh baithe. Mujhe lag raha tha. Point of view pakadnaa mushkil hotaa hai aise comments me.

    Maine political ya egalitarian viewpoint se comment bilkul nhi likhaa tha.

    Dekho abhi haal filhaal mid-term future me identity-caste equations dissolve nhi hone waali. At least tab tak, jab tak ki reservation hai. Log iss cheez ko nhi kehte but Indian reservation policy has only ossified caste structures. Rather than dissolve it. Identity hi to reservation ka base hai yaar.

    Bhai jab doosraa bandaa (dalit/OBC/Muslim etc) identity ki baat kar raha hai to mai ya koi brahman ya koi kayastha ya koi ahir chup kyun baithe. Mai bhi apni thakur identity flaunt karungaa. Doosra apni brahmin identity flaunt karegaa. Teesra apne baniyon ka group banayega.

    Kal ko yadi dwand ya social strife ho jaaye to mai to akelaa pad gaya naa baaki groups ke beech me. Isliye identity-caste duo kahin nhi jaane waala.
    Ye kehna sirf wishful thinking hai ki caste merge kar jaayenge. Kuchh metropolitan pockets me ye possible hai but hinterland me caste will remain a solid touchstone.

    Yadi caste-identity prism ko diffuse karnaa hai then STOP RESERVATION AND APPEASEMENT OF MINORITIES. Only then diffusion is possible.

    #############

    Maine sirf person ke point of view se kahaa tha. Meraa kehnaa tha ki kuchh upper caste selfish logon ne apne personal interest ko upar and general society ke interest ko neeche rakhaa.
    Yes, usme VP Singh, Arjun Singh etc.bhi utne hi bade mujrim hain jitne ki Nehru, Mamta, RS Sharma, Bipin Chandra etc.

    Bhai, Satish Chandra ki NCERT ke har panne pe Brahmin-bashing and Muslim eulogy hui h. Society ko baantne me in Marxist historians ne koi kasar nhi chhodi. And jabki wo bandaa khud brahmin tha. Meraa ye kehnaa tha.
    That people became selfish at personal level for scholarly praise, political power or whatever reasons.
  • edited March 1
    kaahey na relate karein bhai.Hum hee vaaman,hum hee ravan, hum hee parshuram. Hum hee chanakya .bhokal Dena to bunta hai

    :D
    किसका घोड़ा पैर घसीटा..किसका घोड़ा लल्लन टाप
  • edited March 1
    Wrt Student's Union; getting it undone totally, isn't a welcome idea.

    We don't have formal institutions offering courses in political leaderships. In such situation, if we say that college students shouldn't be involved in political parties, will result in "dynastic leadership".
    these Unions provide platforms to teach the college goers , as to how to raise funds, how to garner support and how to identify the issues and solve those. It teaches how to "agree to disagree".

    However, it should be regulated efficiently and adequately.
    - capping the expenses, limiting the number of times one could re-contest etc could be few solutions.
    Dum Spiro Spero
  • Yaar caste politics me reverse discrimination ki baat karke kya ukhad liya kisi ne aj tak? Meri baat mano aur sare jamke khao piyo aur khush raho itne me hi jitna haath me hai. Koi bhi party reservation khatam karke apne paschat desh me baans nahi dalwane wali. Forward caste minority hai. Muh bandh karo aur kaam karo.
    Dead and departed general caste player. RIP.
  • edited March 1
    pks11630 said:

    freeman said:

    pks11630 said:

    Comment karne se pehle bataa detaa hoon ki mai Thakur hoon. General category ka hoon. So jo kehnaa hogaa keh lena.

    Lekin Freeman ne jo baat kahi h usse doosre angle se samjho. Usme kuchh dum hai.

    Kuchh selfish and super-chaalaak Brahman sahi me iss desh me sabhi ke saath kaand kar gaye hain.

    JL Nehru, MN Roy, Jyoti Basu, Mamta Banerjee, Sheila Dikshit, Anand Sharma, Satish Mishra (Mayawati ka daahina haath), Kapil Sibbal, Satish Deshpande (DU ka socio prof & bade wala pro-reservation thinker), Bipin Chandra, Satish Chandra, RS Sharma (Marxist Historian) etc . saare ke saare brahmin hi hain.

    Mai honestly kehtaa hoon ki yadi 'affirmitive action' ke keval Brahmin scholars bhi chup ho jaayein na, to ek saal me reservation streamline ho jaayega. Flat 30% reservation with creamy layer for SC/ST too.
    Similarly, yadi leftist ideology ke keval Brahmin scholars chup ho jaayein, virodh bhi naa karein sirf chup ho jaayein, saale kisi Kanhaiya, Khalid jaise tatpoonjiye ki aukaat nhi ki chun-chapad kar de.

    Ye conspiracy theory nhi hai. Baareeki se dekhoge to samajh jaaoge.
    Mai brahmins ko criticize bilkul nhi kar rha. Bass keh raha hoon ki kuchh super-shrewd brahmano ne apne faayde ko upar rakh rakhaa hai and desh ko neeche.

    is desh ka durbhagya brahmanon ne hi likha hai..lekin dheere dheere improvmnt ho raha..samay ke saath sare caste ek dusre me merge kar jayenge..den we will have a diffused society rather than a prismatic one...mujhe brahmon se koi prb nahi...par kuchh brahaman se prb hai..kyunki wo apni identity apni caste se relate karna nahi bhoolte...which is very cheap of them...baki sab ok hai...sab bhai hain apne.
    Yaar, meri baat ko log galat samajh baithe. Mujhe lag raha tha. Point of view pakadnaa mushkil hotaa hai aise comments me.

    Maine political ya egalitarian viewpoint se comment bilkul nhi likhaa tha.

    Dekho abhi haal filhaal mid-term future me identity-caste equations dissolve nhi hone waali. At least tab tak, jab tak ki reservation hai. Log iss cheez ko nhi kehte but Indian reservation policy has only ossified caste structures. Rather than dissolve it. Identity hi to reservation ka base hai yaar.

    Bhai jab doosraa bandaa (dalit/OBC/Muslim etc) identity ki baat kar raha hai to mai ya koi brahman ya koi kayastha ya koi ahir chup kyun baithe. Mai bhi apni thakur identity flaunt karungaa. Doosra apni brahmin identity flaunt karegaa. Teesra apne baniyon ka group banayega.

    Kal ko yadi dwand ya social strife ho jaaye to mai to akelaa pad gaya naa baaki groups ke beech me. Isliye identity-caste duo kahin nhi jaane waala.
    Ye kehna sirf wishful thinking hai ki caste merge kar jaayenge. Kuchh metropolitan pockets me ye possible hai but hinterland me caste will remain a solid touchstone.

    Yadi caste-identity prism ko diffuse karnaa hai then STOP RESERVATION AND APPEASEMENT OF MINORITIES. Only then diffusion is possible.

    #############

    Maine sirf person ke point of view se kahaa tha. Meraa kehnaa tha ki kuchh upper caste selfish logon ne apne personal interest ko upar and general society ke interest ko neeche rakhaa.
    Yes, usme VP Singh, Arjun Singh etc.bhi utne hi bade mujrim hain jitne ki Nehru, Mamta, RS Sharma, Bipin Chandra etc.

    Bhai, Satish Chandra ki NCERT ke har panne pe Brahmin-bashing and Muslim eulogy hui h. Society ko baantne me in Marxist historians ne koi kasar nhi chhodi. And jabki wo bandaa khud brahmin tha. Meraa ye kehnaa tha.
    That people became selfish at personal level for scholarly praise, political power or whatever reasons.
    And aajkal to pataa bhi nhi chaltaa ki kaun 'real' brahmin ya real baniya ya real kayastha hai.

    B.Tech me mere ek batchmate ka 'Gautam' surname thaa. Mai usse 4 saal tak brahmin samajhtaa raha. Final year me DRDO on-campus ke liye aayi to pataa chalaa ki vo to SC hai. :D Jitendra Gupta, bihar ka corrupt IAS, OBC niklaa. Naam se baniya lag rha thaa.

    Sab golmaal h. >:)
    CSM 2015 | CSE 2016 - Ranked it Out!!
    Thank Lord Shiva...
  • edited March 1

    pks11630 said:

    freeman said:

    pks11630 said:

    Comment karne se pehle bataa detaa hoon ki mai Thakur hoon. General category ka hoon. So jo kehnaa hogaa keh lena.

    Lekin Freeman ne jo baat kahi h usse doosre angle se samjho. Usme kuchh dum hai.

    Kuchh selfish and super-chaalaak Brahman sahi me iss desh me sabhi ke saath kaand kar gaye hain.

    JL Nehru, MN Roy, Jyoti Basu, Mamta Banerjee, Sheila Dikshit, Anand Sharma, Satish Mishra (Mayawati ka daahina haath), Kapil Sibbal, Satish Deshpande (DU ka socio prof & bade wala pro-reservation thinker), Bipin Chandra, Satish Chandra, RS Sharma (Marxist Historian) etc . saare ke saare brahmin hi hain.

    Mai honestly kehtaa hoon ki yadi 'affirmitive action' ke keval Brahmin scholars bhi chup ho jaayein na, to ek saal me reservation streamline ho jaayega. Flat 30% reservation with creamy layer for SC/ST too.
    Similarly, yadi leftist ideology ke keval Brahmin scholars chup ho jaayein, virodh bhi naa karein sirf chup ho jaayein, saale kisi Kanhaiya, Khalid jaise tatpoonjiye ki aukaat nhi ki chun-chapad kar de.

    Ye conspiracy theory nhi hai. Baareeki se dekhoge to samajh jaaoge.
    Mai brahmins ko criticize bilkul nhi kar rha. Bass keh raha hoon ki kuchh super-shrewd brahmano ne apne faayde ko upar rakh rakhaa hai and desh ko neeche.

    is desh ka durbhagya brahmanon ne hi likha hai..lekin dheere dheere improvmnt ho raha..samay ke saath sare caste ek dusre me merge kar jayenge..den we will have a diffused society rather than a prismatic one...mujhe brahmon se koi prb nahi...par kuchh brahaman se prb hai..kyunki wo apni identity apni caste se relate karna nahi bhoolte...which is very cheap of them...baki sab ok hai...sab bhai hain apne.
    Yaar, meri baat ko log galat samajh baithe. Mujhe lag raha tha. Point of view pakadnaa mushkil hotaa hai aise comments me.

    Maine political ya egalitarian viewpoint se comment bilkul nhi likhaa tha.

    Dekho abhi haal filhaal mid-term future me identity-caste equations dissolve nhi hone waali. At least tab tak, jab tak ki reservation hai. Log iss cheez ko nhi kehte but Indian reservation policy has only ossified caste structures. Rather than dissolve it. Identity hi to reservation ka base hai yaar.

    Bhai jab doosraa bandaa (dalit/OBC/Muslim etc) identity ki baat kar raha hai to mai ya koi brahman ya koi kayastha ya koi ahir chup kyun baithe. Mai bhi apni thakur identity flaunt karungaa. Doosra apni brahmin identity flaunt karegaa. Teesra apne baniyon ka group banayega.

    Kal ko yadi dwand ya social strife ho jaaye to mai to akelaa pad gaya naa baaki groups ke beech me. Isliye identity-caste duo kahin nhi jaane waala.
    Ye kehna sirf wishful thinking hai ki caste merge kar jaayenge. Kuchh metropolitan pockets me ye possible hai but hinterland me caste will remain a solid touchstone.

    Yadi caste-identity prism ko diffuse karnaa hai then STOP RESERVATION AND APPEASEMENT OF MINORITIES. Only then diffusion is possible.

    #############

    Maine sirf person ke point of view se kahaa tha. Meraa kehnaa tha ki kuchh upper caste selfish logon ne apne personal interest ko upar and general society ke interest ko neeche rakhaa.
    Yes, usme VP Singh, Arjun Singh etc.bhi utne hi bade mujrim hain jitne ki Nehru, Mamta, RS Sharma, Bipin Chandra etc.

    Bhai, Satish Chandra ki NCERT ke har panne pe Brahmin-bashing and Muslim eulogy hui h. Society ko baantne me in Marxist historians ne koi kasar nhi chhodi. And jabki wo bandaa khud brahmin tha. Meraa ye kehnaa tha.
    That people became selfish at personal level for scholarly praise, political power or whatever reasons.
    And aajkal to pataa bhi nhi chaltaa ki kaun 'real' brahmin ya real baniya ya real kayastha hai.

    B.Tech me mere ek batchmate ka 'Gautam' surname thaa. Mai usse 4 saal tak brahmin samajhtaa raha. Final year me DRDO on-campus ke liye aayi to pataa chalaa ki vo to SC hai. :D Jitendra Gupta, bihar ka corrupt IAS, OBC niklaa. Naam se baniya lag rha thaa.

    Sab golmaal h. >:)
    Isiliye milte hee gotra pooch Leni chahiye..aur ho sake to Vaastavya. Vaastavya ek Tarah ka confirmatory test hai.


    Ab ghar pe poocho apna vaastavya .kyuki tum jante nahin hogey
    किसका घोड़ा पैर घसीटा..किसका घोड़ा लल्लन टाप
  • edited March 1
    .
    "old wine in new bottle"....in with state services.
  • @Burger wa .... aag laga k bhaag gaya..... Usko dharo....bhut bada politician hai..... Hum masoom aspirants ko..jaat, dharm, pe ladta chor gaya..... Wo popcorn hath main le kar ..is thread ko padhta hoga...aur..jor jor se hasta hoga..... Bebkoof na bano.....burgerwa ko...dharo.... :angry:
    You talk when u cease to be at peace with your mind
  • No no I appreciate him he did the right thing
    किसका घोड़ा पैर घसीटा..किसका घोड़ा लल्लन टाप
  • GEHREBAAZ said:

    No no I appreciate him he did the right thing

    Yes, samaj...ki sachai bahar aa gaiee.... :D :D
    You talk when u cease to be at peace with your mind
  • GEHREBAAZ said:

    No no I appreciate him he did the right thing

    Yes, samaj...ki sachai bahar aa gaiee.... :D :D
    Samaj ki Sachai ki aisi ki taisi .Kyunki Raja To banate bhee hum hain aur girate bhee Ham hain ;)

    Aur aj se nahi, na Jane kub se B)

    किसका घोड़ा पैर घसीटा..किसका घोड़ा लल्लन टाप
  • .

    Aapne comment likh ke delete kar diya!!

    Bhai, daro mat apne honest vichaar vyakt karne se.
    Ye left-liberal logon ne jo jhooth ka bulbulaa banaa rakhaa h usse phodne ke liye jaroori h ki log khul ke bolen.
    CSM 2015 | CSE 2016 - Ranked it Out!!
    Thank Lord Shiva...
  • The undeleted version of his comment has been quoted by tudor
    किसका घोड़ा पैर घसीटा..किसका घोड़ा लल्लन टाप
  • GEHREBAAZ said:



    Isiliye milte hee gotra pooch Leni chahiye..aur ho sake to Vaastavya. Vaastavya ek Tarah ka confirmatory test hai.


    Ab ghar pe poocho apna vaastavya .kyuki tum jante nahin hogey

    Yes. Maine actually vaastavya first time sunaa. Abhi-abhi :#
    CSM 2015 | CSE 2016 - Ranked it Out!!
    Thank Lord Shiva...
  • GEHREBAAZ said:



    Isiliye milte hee gotra pooch Leni chahiye..aur ho sake to Vaastavya. Vaastavya ek Tarah ka confirmatory test hai.


    Ab ghar pe poocho apna vaastavya .kyuki tum jante nahin hogey

    Yes. Maine actually vaastavya first time sunaa. Abhi-abhi :#
    Main Jaanta tha ISI liye bold Me likha
    किसका घोड़ा पैर घसीटा..किसका घोड़ा लल्लन टाप
  • edited March 1
    Brahmin still rules and will rule forever.apne dimag se,apni boli se, apne gyaan se .apne maan sammaan ke bodh k karan aur avashyaktanusaar apne sammaan ki raksha kar lene ki kala k karan
    JaiBrahman.JaiWaman jaiRavan B)
    किसका घोड़ा पैर घसीटा..किसका घोड़ा लल्लन टाप
This discussion has been closed.

Courses by ForumIAS for CSE
ForumIAS is trusted by over 10,000+ students for their Prelims, Mains and Interview Preparation and we currently run several assistance programs to help students from Civil Services prelims preparation to rank upgradation to IAS. You can enroll for these programs by visiting http://blog.forumias.com/courses

Welcome!

We are a secret self-moderated community for Civil Services preparation. Feel free to join, start a discussion, answer a question or just to say Thank you.

Just dont spread the word ;)

Sign in or join with Facebook or Google

Subscribe to ForumIAS Blog