Download part 1 of the Economic Survey 2016-17 Vol. 2 summary by ForumIAS : Click here to DOWNLOAD

SERIOUS THREAD- LET'S SPEAK IT OUT

All the big talks of toppers and coachingwallas but real truth remains that in any case 99.9% of candidates WOULD NOT clear this examination. So you can guess the scenario of competition. We missed the good opportunities in life for this examination. Many new college graduates will take same path. Is it our duty to tell them harsh truth?? or let them dwell too, in fool's paradise?
God is great.
·
«13

Comments

  • edited February 4
    ^^

    Every 4 minutes a road accident occurs in India and every 15 minutes a person dies in such an accident.
    This is the figure from official data. Recent research by IIT Delhi revealed that this data is grossly underestimated by a factor of 20. So, perhaps one accident occurs every 12 seconds!!

    Do we stop driving automobiles by knowing this 'harsh truth'? Should we?

    What we do is, we invest in road infrastructure and other ancillary factors related to roads and improve driving experience to reduce accidents.

    Similarly, telling this 'harsh truth' to aspirants and scaring/demoralizing them right at outset Isn't going to solve anything. What we need to do is reform the selection ecosystem by various reforms.

    I'll list out some reforms for you:
    - For starters, increase the age limit of UR category to 35 and unlimited attempts.
    - Providing benefit of reservation on ANY ONE stage of exam. If a person qualifies prelims in reserved category, she should be considered as reserved throughout. This has sanction of Supreme Court and is followed in all other recruitments in centre and states. But somehow UPSC misses out on it.
    - Merging various administrative exams under a single recruitment procedure so that those who couldn't perform on the D Day due to luck factor don't go out barehanded and slug out for another exam. They at least get something. We can easily merge SSC, APFC, LS/RS Assistant etc. exams with UPSC.

    Such, practical measures will be more helpful than scaring people off.
    CSM 2015 | CSE 2016 - Ranked it Out!!
    Thank Lord Shiva...
    ·
  • JohnPaul said:

    All the big talks of toppers and coachingwallas but real truth remains that in any case 99.9% of candidates WOULD NOT clear this examination. So you can guess the scenario of competition. We missed the good opportunities in life for this examination. Many new college graduates will take same path. Is it our duty to tell them harsh truth?? or let them dwell too, in fool's paradise?

    Le yaar thodi positivity wali dose, ye rona dhona ladai jhagda forum pe thoda bad gaya hai, me balance karta hun :mrgreen:
    Nahi dekhi hai, to please watch the complete video
    Dekhi hai, to phir bhi watch again
    You will feel better :smiley:

    The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing.
    ·
  • JohnPaul said:

    All the big talks of toppers and coachingwallas but real truth remains that in any case 99.9% of candidates WOULD NOT clear this examination. So you can guess the scenario of competition. We missed the good opportunities in life for this examination. Many new college graduates will take same path. Is it our duty to tell them harsh truth?? or let them dwell too, in fool's paradise?

    Two major reason for this sad state of affairs
    (1) status (Obsession) that our society have towards the government jobs. These jobs are highly glorified in many aspects of our society like guy with the government job always gets preference over guy in private sector while fixing the marriages even if guy with private jobs has better salary than government job guy.
    (2) It's a failure of the government not create enough and good private sector jobs for the youth. It's important to have large number of lucrative private sector jobs for the youth so that they don't waste time in preparation for the competitive exams.
    Preparing for competitive examination should be self motivated decision and not the compulsion born out of some external factors like lack of good jobs in private sector.
    ·
  • ^^

    Every 4 minutes a road accident occurs in India and every 15 minutes a person dies in such an accident.
    This is the figure from official data. Recent research by IIT Delhi revealed that this data is grossly underestimated by a factor of 20. So, perhaps one accident occurs every 12 seconds!!

    Do we stop driving automobiles by knowing this 'harsh truth'? Should we?

    What we do is, we invest in road infrastructure and other ancillary factors related to roads and improve driving experience to reduce accidents.

    Similarly, telling this 'harsh truth' to aspirants and scaring/demoralizing them right at outset Isn't going to solve anything. What we need to do is reform the selection ecosystem by various reforms.

    I'll list out some reforms for you:
    - For starters, increase the age limit of UR category to 35 and unlimited attempts.
    - Providing benefit of reservation on ANY ONE stage of exam. If a person qualifies prelims in reserved category, she should be considered as reserved throughout. This has sanction of Supreme Court and is followed in all other recruitments in centre and states. But somehow UPSC misses out on it.
    - Merging various administrative exams under a single recruitment procedure so that those who couldn't perform on the D Day due to luck factor don't go out barehanded and slug out for another exam. They at least get something. We can easily merge SSC, APFC, LS/RS Assistant etc. exams with UPSC.

    Such, practical measures will be more helpful than scaring people off.

    :+1: :+1:
    कभी किसी को मुकम्मल जहाँ नहीं मिलता..
    कहीं ज़मीं तो कहीं आसमां नहीं मिलता.....

    ·
  • ^^

    Every 4 minutes a road accident occurs in India and every 15 minutes a person dies in such an accident.
    This is the figure from official data. Recent research by IIT Delhi revealed that this data is grossly underestimated by a factor of 20. So, perhaps one accident occurs every 12 seconds!!

    Do we stop driving automobiles by knowing this 'harsh truth'? Should we?

    What we do is, we invest in road infrastructure and other ancillary factors related to roads and improve driving experience to reduce accidents.

    Similarly, telling this 'harsh truth' to aspirants and scaring/demoralizing them right at outset Isn't going to solve anything. What we need to do is reform the selection ecosystem by various reforms.

    I'll list out some reforms for you:
    - For starters, increase the age limit of UR category to 35 and unlimited attempts.
    - Providing benefit of reservation on ANY ONE stage of exam. If a person qualifies prelims in reserved category, she should be considered as reserved throughout. This has sanction of Supreme Court and is followed in all other recruitments in centre and states. But somehow UPSC misses out on it.
    - Merging various administrative exams under a single recruitment procedure so that those who couldn't perform on the D Day due to luck factor don't go out barehanded and slug out for another exam. They at least get something. We can easily merge SSC, APFC, LS/RS Assistant etc. exams with UPSC.

    Such, practical measures will be more helpful than scaring people off.

    +1

    Eloquently put. Completely agree.
    ·
  • edited February 4
    gt2015 said:


    Two major reason for this sad state of affairs
    (1) status (Obsession) that our society have towards the government jobs. These jobs are highly glorified in many aspects of our society like guy with the government job always gets preference over guy in private sector while fixing the marriages even if guy with private jobs has better salary than government job guy.
    (2) It's a failure of the government not create enough and good private sector jobs for the youth. It's important to have large number of lucrative private sector jobs for the youth so that they don't waste time in preparation for the competitive exams.
    Preparing for competitive examination should be self motivated decision and not the compulsion born out of some external factors like lack of good jobs in private sector.

    I wud slightly differ with you on point 1.

    It's there in all societies. Working for government is highly respected all over the world.

    Even in US, the torch-bearer of neo-liberalism, recruitment for FBI, IRS and State Department sees some of the finest talent from Ivy League slug it out. Most brilliant profs would prefer to work at Los Alamos or NASA rather than private universities. So, it's not only India.

    Rest of ur argument is on the point.
    ·
  • akkib89 said:


    Le yaar thodi positivity wali dose, ye rona dhona ladai jhagda forum pe thoda bad gaya hai, me balance karta hun :mrgreen:
    Nahi dekhi hai, to please watch the complete video
    Dekhi hai, to phir bhi watch again
    You will feel better :smiley:

    Kya, Akki bhai, Constitutional debates khatm ho gayi kya :mrgreen:

    This is a sign that ForumIAS is coming of age as a platform. It's good.
    Shuru me Facebook was just for social networking. Now, it has everything from fake news, breakups to political propaganda and activism for noble causes.
    Apnaa Forum bhi aspirant community ka Facebook ban raha hai. Rona, dhona, frustration nikaalna, gaali-galoch sab diversity hai o:)

    Bookmarked ur video in #gyan folder on YT. Will see it later surely. :blush:
    CSM 2015 | CSE 2016 - Ranked it Out!!
    Thank Lord Shiva...
    ·
  • edited February 4

    gt2015 said:


    Two major reason for this sad state of affairs
    (1) status (Obsession) that our society have towards the government jobs. These jobs are highly glorified in many aspects of our society like guy with the government job always gets preference over guy in private sector while fixing the marriages even if guy with private jobs has better salary than government job guy.
    (2) It's a failure of the government not create enough and good private sector jobs for the youth. It's important to have large number of lucrative private sector jobs for the youth so that they don't waste time in preparation for the competitive exams.
    Preparing for competitive examination should be self motivated decision and not the compulsion born out of some external factors like lack of good jobs in private sector.

    I wud slightly differ with you on point 1.

    It's there in all societies. Working for government is highly respected all over the world.

    Even in US, the torch-bearer of neo-liberalism, recruitment for FBI, IRS and State Department sees some of the finest talent from Ivy League slug it out. Most brilliant profs would prefer to work at Los Alamos or NASA rather than private universities. So, it's not only India.

    Rest of ur argument is on the point.
    This logic is flawed. Los Alamos and nasa is akin to drdo and isro. These are scientific/technical jobs, hence people with such backgrounds would get attracted to these institutions irrespective of nationality. Also in the us, they have lateral entries into the government sector. The pvt sector is way more attractive in the US as compared to India specifically due to the feudal character of civil services still prevalent in india.

    Profs in the us are much better paid, and are way more respected compared to their Indian counterparts.
    An Ounce of Action Is Worth a Ton of Theory
    ·
  • *govt sector attractive in india and pvt sector in the us as in india, the feudal mindset is still prevalent and in the us, pvt sector is way more liberal and pays better.
    An Ounce of Action Is Worth a Ton of Theory
    ·
  • Height of Obsession with government jobs is when peon in government office is preferred over jobless engineer in marriage market and PhD student and post graduate students standing in que to fill out the form for the post of peon in government office. ( it's not a exaggeration but the reality )
    ·

  • This logic is flawed. Los Alamos and nasa is akin to drdo and isro. These are scientific/technical jobs, hence people with such backgrounds would get attracted to these institutions irrespective of nationality. Also in the us, they have lateral entries into the government sector. The pvt sector is way more attractive in the US as compared to India specifically due to the feudal character of civil services still prevalent in india.

    Profs in the us are much better paid, and are way more respected compared to their Indian counterparts.

    *govt sector attractive in india and pvt sector in the us as in india, the feudal mindset is still prevalent and in the us, pvt sector is way more liberal and pays better.

    Bhai your argument is based on perception. What I wrote is from experience.

    State jobs are highly respected all over the world. From Japan to US. In US talented profs prefer State assignments in NOAA, USDA, NASA, State department etc. in private universities profs get tenures of few years only which has to be renewed over and over again.
    And Afro-Americans in US almost invariably opt for State jobs only as the get reservation in govt. jobs.

    You are perhaps calling Indian setup as 'feudal' due to pressure of CSE prep. It's a natural psychological defence mechanism which is kicking in. This will change once you get in.

    But for paucity of time, I wish I could elaborate more exact points to you in this regard.
    ·
  • edited February 4
    gt2015 said:

    PhD student and post graduate students standing in que to fill out the form for the post of peon in government office. ( it's not a exaggeration but the reality )

    I completely agree with this example.
    I personally know IIT/NIT/NSIT graduates are working in SSC jobs.
    ·
  • gt2015 said:

    PhD student and post graduate students standing in que to fill out the form for the post of peon in government office. ( it's not a exaggeration but the reality )

    I completely agree with this example.
    I personally know IIT/NIT/NSIT graduates are working in SSC jobs.
    Hardly 1% bhi nahi honge imo :mrgreen:
    At least recent years ke passouts to nahin hi honge
    Aur kuch jo kar rahe honge unki ya to CGPA bhasad gayi hogi ya unhone conscious decision lee hogi taki kisi aur job ki preparation kar sakein B)
    The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing.
    ·
  • Congress ke jamaane me private sector ki badi craze thi. Everybody wanted to be software engineer, MBA, work abroad etc.
    God is great.
    ·
  • akkib89 said:


    Le yaar thodi positivity wali dose, ye rona dhona ladai jhagda forum pe thoda bad gaya hai, me balance karta hun :mrgreen:
    Nahi dekhi hai, to please watch the complete video
    Dekhi hai, to phir bhi watch again
    You will feel better :smiley:

    Kya, Akki bhai, Constitutional debates khatm ho gayi kya :mrgreen:

    This is a sign that ForumIAS is coming of age as a platform. It's good.
    Shuru me Facebook was just for social networking. Now, it has everything from fake news, breakups to political propaganda and activism for noble causes.
    Apnaa Forum bhi aspirant community ka Facebook ban raha hai. Rona, dhona, frustration nikaalna, gaali-galoch sab diversity hai o:)

    Bookmarked ur video in #gyan folder on YT. Will see it later surely. :blush:
    Debates chal rahein hain sir, public domain se private domain me shift ho gayen hain bas :mrgreen:

    Haan, I agree to what you say, bas thoda personal ho jate hain aspirants, jawani ka josh hai sahi bhi hai....
    Overall badiya forum ubhar kar aaya hai ye IAS aspirants ke liye undoubtedly

    Bookmark kar lee! , hehe, chalo dekh hi lena yaar :#

    TC
    The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing.
    ·
  • akkib89 said:


    Hardly 1% bhi nahi honge imo :mrgreen:
    At least recent years ke passouts to nahin hi honge
    Aur kuch jo kar rahe honge unki ya to CGPA bhasad gayi hogi ya unhone conscious decision lee hogi taki kisi aur job ki preparation kar sakein B)

    True.
    ·
  • gt2015 said:

    PhD student and post graduate students standing in que to fill out the form for the post of peon in government office. ( it's not a exaggeration but the reality )

    I completely agree with this example.
    I personally know IIT/NIT/NSIT graduates are working in SSC jobs.
    This is harsh reality of India
    God is great.
    ·
  • edited February 4
    JohnPaul said:

    Congress ke jamaane me private sector ki badi craze thi. Everybody wanted to be software engineer, MBA, work abroad etc.

    Dotcom crash ke baad jo pant utri na sab software engineeron ki kya batayoon, sab job khoja karte the India wapis aakar. Hahaha.
    Abroad to log isliye darte hain ki PR card ke liye ajkal shaddi - divorce ka khel khela ja rahen hai bahut wahan par....Haha...Kaun byahega apni beti ko NRI se (unless purani jaan pehchan na ho)...Hahaha
    Upar se Pay commission ne bhi hila diya hai sari Pvt companies ko.. Haha.
    #GovtJobIsTheBest
    Angoor milen na milen par hain to meethe hi, reservation wala khel bas destroy kar rha hai isko
    The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing.
    ·
  • Everybody knows the truth. No body is so naive that he/she is unaware of the fact that the number of applicants is much larger than number of vacancies, as is the case with all exams. Everybody knows they might not get to see the light at the end of the tunnel but keep saying to themselves - let it not be me.

    This is for all of us who tried: Manzil to mil hi jayegi, Bhatak kar ke hi sahi. Gumrah to wo hain, Jo ghar se nikle hi nahin.
    2013-Failed Pre by 7 marks
    2014-Failed Pre by 1 marks
    2015-Failed Mains by 25 marks
    2016-Failed Pre
    2017-Final Battle
    ·
  • edited February 4
    akkib89 said:


    Dotcom crash ke baad jo pant utri na sab software engineeron ki kya batayoon, sab job khoja karte the India wapis aakar. Hahaha.
    Abroad to log isliye darte hain ki PR card ke liye ajkal shaddi - divorce ka khel khela ja rahen hai bahut wahan par....Haha...Kaun byahega apni beti ko NRI se (unless purani jaan pehchan na ho)...Hahaha
    Upar se Pay commission ne bhi hila diya hai sari Pvt companies ko.. Haha.
    #GovtJobIsTheBest
    Angoor milen na milen par hain to meethe hi, reservation wala khel bas destroy kar rha hai isko

    Aap to kaam ke bande ho yaar. IITian urself, if I'm not wrong. Am I ?

    Lagtaa hai maine galat bande par haath daal diya tha pehle din wo Constitutional legitimacy waale thread pe. :mrgreen:
    Shit...
    CSM 2015 | CSE 2016 - Ranked it Out!!
    Thank Lord Shiva...
    ·
  • edited February 4
    JohnPaul said:

    gt2015 said:

    PhD student and post graduate students standing in que to fill out the form for the post of peon in government office. ( it's not a exaggeration but the reality )

    I completely agree with this example.
    I personally know IIT/NIT/NSIT graduates are working in SSC jobs.
    This is harsh reality of India
    Bhai, ye jo bahut saare IITian and NITians aapko dikhte hain na govt. job market me in me se majority reserved category waale hote hain.

    Humaare reserved category waale bhai log pataa nahi kyun apne ko itnaa devaluate karte hain. Top colleges se graduate hone ke baavjood sarkaar me chhoti moti job me chale jaate hain.
    SVNIT se graduate humaare ek Meena dost, iss waqt Railway me ticket kaat rahe hain :D
    CSM 2015 | CSE 2016 - Ranked it Out!!
    Thank Lord Shiva...
    ·
  • JohnPaul said:

    gt2015 said:

    PhD student and post graduate students standing in que to fill out the form for the post of peon in government office. ( it's not a exaggeration but the reality )

    I completely agree with this example.
    I personally know IIT/NIT/NSIT graduates are working in SSC jobs.
    This is harsh reality of India
    Bhai, ye jo bahut saare IITian and NITians aapko dikhte hain na govt. job market me in me se majority reserved category waale hote hain.

    Humaare reserved category waale bhai log pataa nahi kyun apne ko itnaa devaluate karte hain. Top colleges se graduate hone ke baavjood sarkaar me chhoti moti job me chale jaate hain.
    SVNIT se graduate humaare ek Meena dost, iss waqt Railway me ticket kaat rahe hain :D
    IRTS?
    ·
  • ^^
    Arre nahi yaar, I mean literally ticket kaat rahe hain... :D
    Went in through RRB exam. TTE in West Zone.
    CSM 2015 | CSE 2016 - Ranked it Out!!
    Thank Lord Shiva...
    ·
  • ^^
    Arre nahi yaar, I mean literally ticket kaat rahe hain... :D
    Went in through RRB exam. TTE in West Zone.

    Okk.
    ·
  • JohnPaul said:

    gt2015 said:

    PhD student and post graduate students standing in que to fill out the form for the post of peon in government office. ( it's not a exaggeration but the reality )

    I completely agree with this example.
    I personally know IIT/NIT/NSIT graduates are working in SSC jobs.
    This is harsh reality of India
    Bhai, ye jo bahut saare IITian and NITians aapko dikhte hain na govt. job market me in me se majority reserved category waale hote hain.

    Humaare reserved category waale bhai log pataa nahi kyun apne ko itnaa devaluate karte hain. Top colleges se graduate hone ke baavjood sarkaar me chhoti moti job me chale jaate hain.
    SVNIT se graduate humaare ek Meena dost, iss waqt Railway me ticket kaat rahe hain :D
    bhai india me sc st obc vale hi majority me hai ,population ka percentage dekhe to. Jobless growth h india ki 5% ho gayi h. Ab kisi ko private sector me job na mile to ghar pe bethega thode hi. isme devaluate karne ki baat kaha se aa gayi? jis meena bandhu ka aap example de rahe h ya to uska cgpi accha nahi hoga ya college se placement nahi mili hogi. aapne jo sarcasm use kiya h "railway me ticket kaat rahe h :D " kya prove karna chahte ho? na kate? berozgaar betha rahe ya ticket chodkar jeb kate?
    I see you.
    ·
Sign In or Join to comment.

Courses by ForumIAS for CSE
ForumIAS is trusted by over 10,000+ students for their Prelims, Mains and Interview Preparation and we currently run several assistance programs to help students from Civil Services prelims preparation to rank upgradation to IAS. You can enroll for these programs by making the payment through the links below

1. Mains Guidance Program 2017 - July 1st : Batch C ( 24 Seats | 21 GS + Essay Tests ) | Test Plan | Payment Link |
2. Mains Guidance Program 2017 - 7th August : Batch D ( 50 Seats| 8 GS Tests ) | Test Plan | Payment Link
3. Current Affairs Classes for Mains 2017 (OFFLINE) - 16th August - ( 200 Issues for Mains 2017 ) | Class Plan | Enrollment Link
4. Current Affairs (Online) Classes for Mains 2017 - 20th August | Details | Enrollment Link
5. Prelims Test Series 2018 - Coming Soon 6. Mains Guidance Program for Mains 2018 - Coming soon

UPCOMING EVENTS by ForumIAS
1. Open Session on DAF Filling : What you fill in your Detailed Application form, will decide the marks you get in the Interview, the service that you will get and the state you will live in , for the rest of your life. Last but not the least, it will also decide who you will marry. Don't make mistakes. Join us for an open session on filling up the DAF. We will be assisted by ForumIAS Members who have secured a service or rank in this initiative.

Welcome!

We are a secret self-moderated community for Civil Services preparation. Feel free to join, start a discussion, answer a question or just to say Thank you.

Just dont spread the word ;)

Sign in or join with Facebook or Google

Subscribe to ForumIAS Blog