43 out of 86 MGP 2016 Students Appeared for their first Interview in CSE 2016. ForumIAS MGP 2017 ADMISSIONS ARE NOW OPEN

ForumIAS MGP 2017 New Batch Admissions Plan Details and Admission Links are now ACTIVE, along with our performance of MGP 2016 in terms of conversion into interview calls for Mains Appearing Candidates.Click here to join NOW!

Why Both Vajiram and Sriram both Giving Governor appoints Chief Secretary?

edited August 2016 in Polity & Governance
Both Vajiram and sriram are giving " Governor appoints Chief Secretary". Can someone clear this doubt?

http://www.vajiramandravi.com/testseries.php?type=pre

http://www.sriramsias.com/UPSC2016-Paper1.pdf
http://www.sriramsias.com/UPSC2016-Paper1Answers.pdf
·
«1

Comments

  • all executive actions in a state are taken in the name of governor!!
    ·
  • Vajiram and Sriram can be wrong. They have been wrong earlier also.
    ·
  • vajiram has not given pleease check again
    answer was *d* in their answer list
    chocolate is my life
    ·
  • all executive actions in a state are taken in the name of governor!!

    All Executive actions "Taking in the name of Governor" is different from "Appointed by Governor" himself.
    Civil War 2016. Started. UPSC Ruthlessly Brutal. As Always.
    ·
  • Don't worry upsc won't give governor
    ·
  • choco_dip said:

    vajiram has not given pleease check again
    answer was *d* in their answer list

    bhai set C ka Question No. 75 hai vajiram ne "a" diya hua hai
    ·
  • bhai agar governor appoint karta toh arvind kejriwal appoint na kar pata apna chief sec...toh abhi UT me CM appoint karta hai toh states me toh possible nhi hai
    ·
  • arre bhaio... PM ko kon appoint karta hai president of india... but in reality he is selected by the elected MPs... But do we say that president is appointed by MPs? iska answer governor hi hoga...
    ·
  • they are giving that because that is the FACT. Why is this question even an issue?? PM or CM or AG or MP or MLA never appoints Chief secy or even an officer for that matter. All official appointments and orders are in the name of the Governor. If anyone still has doubt please ask any serving group A government official.
    ·
  • they are giving that because that is the FACT. Why is this question even an issue?? PM or CM or AG or MP or MLA never appoints Chief secy or even an officer for that matter. All official appointments and orders are in the name of the Governor. If anyone still has doubt please ask any serving group A government official.

    It

    they are giving that because that is the FACT. Why is this question even an issue?? PM or CM or AG or MP or MLA never appoints Chief secy or even an officer for that matter. All official appointments and orders are in the name of the Governor. If anyone still has doubt please ask any serving group A government official.

    All appointments are done by the CM/PM being the chairman of the cabinet committee on appointments. Every group A appointment is in the name of Governor/President but that does not mean he can appoint any officer as Chief Secretary on his own. Cabinet committee headed by CM/PM appoints the CS since the authority is delegated to them. Please remember all appointments done by CM/ other executive decisions made are presumed to be in the name of Governor as per the constitution but appointing CS is not part of his decision making powers.

    Hope this settles the confusion.
    ·
  • edited August 2016
    Appointment of chief secretary again and second time landed in controversy here on forumias,... after kejriwal - najib power struggle at nct delhi! :D
    ·
  • Unless one is a borderline case, where every mark is important.. others should not bother themselves with one question .. I have seen atleast 4-5 threads to discuss this one question on appointment of Chief Secy !!

    Start with your mains preps now !!!!!!!!
    Indian Revenue Service
    अबकी बारी, ज़िला अधिकारी ||
    ·
  • garconfou said:

    they are giving that because that is the FACT. Why is this question even an issue?? PM or CM or AG or MP or MLA never appoints Chief secy or even an officer for that matter. All official appointments and orders are in the name of the Governor. If anyone still has doubt please ask any serving group A government official.

    It

    they are giving that because that is the FACT. Why is this question even an issue?? PM or CM or AG or MP or MLA never appoints Chief secy or even an officer for that matter. All official appointments and orders are in the name of the Governor. If anyone still has doubt please ask any serving group A government official.

    All appointments are done by the CM/PM being the chairman of the cabinet committee on appointments. Every group A appointment is in the name of Governor/President but that does not mean he can appoint any officer as Chief Secretary on his own. Cabinet committee headed by CM/PM appoints the CS since the authority is delegated to them. Please remember all appointments done by CM/ other executive decisions made are presumed to be in the name of Governor as per the constitution but appointing CS is not part of his decision making powers.

    Hope this settles the confusion.
    OK then what about this appointment letter which is shared by crazyaspirant83??
    ·
  • all executive actions in a state are taken in the name of governor!!

    all executive actions of the union are taken in the name of the president ...does not mean he appoints everyone... i don't think even the cabinet secretary is appointed by the president
    ·
  • Question: Who appoints Chief secretary of a state?????
    ·
  • The TN Chief Secretary appointment order.

    Even a copy is not marked to the Governor.
    pdf
    pdf
    Chief Secy Appointment.pdf
    62K
    ·
  • rexuias said:

    The TN Chief Secretary appointment order.

    Even a copy is not marked to the Governor.

    By order of the governor, clearly likha to hai usme

    A Lannister always pays his debts
    ·
  • rexuias said:

    The TN Chief Secretary appointment order.

    Even a copy is not marked to the Governor.

    BRO, PLEASE carefully see, it's written at bottom, ' by the order of governor '.....cm is no where mentioned in this letter.....we have seen almost 4 appointment letters on this forum and all of them have governor written on them....

    ·
Sign In or Join to comment.

Welcome!

We are a secret self-moderated community for Civil Services preparation. Feel free to join, start a discussion, answer a question or just to say Thank you.

Just dont spread the word ;)

Sign in or join with Facebook or Google